Some say that Infamous is to Capote what Valmont is to Dangerous Liasons. In other words, movies that are basically about the same thing [and the same people] that came out at about the same time.
But:
Though both of these films received generally good reviews, the critics clearly preferred one over the other. Here it was Capote:
RT:
Capote: 90% fresh rating on 181 reviews
Infamous: 73% fresh rating on 146 reviews
Two accounts:
npr.org/templates/story/stor … Id=6259809
pacejmiller.com/2010/08/29/c … mous-2006/
I actually liked both of them about equally. Besides, the story itself is compelling. Especially if you have read Capote’s book. Both films more or less do it justice in my view.
Still, it was after I watched this rendition that I was compelled to reread the book.
It basically revolves around the gap between this quintessessential New York intellectual and the Heartland folks as it pertains to the slaughter of the Clutter family out in Holcomb, Kansas. And on both sides of the law. These people simply do not know what to make of this “fruitcake” writer that has descended upon them. That is until he starts dropping names — Bogie, Sinatra, Gardner, Monroe — and it all quickly gets turned around.
But then there is the considerably more haunting gap between this part of the film and the murders themselves. And then the gap between the murderers and all of those reacting to them with horror and disgust. Or, for Capote, with fascination.
And yet, in particular, there is the complex, enigmatic relationship between Truman Capote and Perry Smith. To what extent does he genuinely care about him…and to what extent is he basically just molding and manipulating him into becoming the “character” he wants him to be in the “novelization” of those cold blooded murders in Kansas?
at wiki: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infamous_(film
trailer: youtu.be/jZw8ORyIbLI
INFAMOUS [2006]
Written and directed by Douglas McGrath
[b]Diana Vreeland: Everything about him is designed to rivet: The appearance, the demeanor, and, of course, the voice.
…
Gore Vidal: The voice? To the lucky person who has never heard it, I can only say: imagine what a brussels sprout would sound like, if a brussels sprout could talk.
…
Diana Vreeland: Here’s a word I loathe: eccentric. Eccentric is a word that boring people use to describe someone I think of as interesting. A great many people think of me as eccentric simply because when I have my shoes polished, I have the entire shoe polished. Top, sides and soles. Some people think it eccentric that every morning I have my maid iron my money. When I told Truman I had my maid iron my money, you know what he said? Here’s what he didn’t say: “How eccentric.” Here’s what he did say: “How wonderful.” [/b]
See what I mean about the gap between “these people” and the folks out in the Heartland?
[b]Truman: I want to explore how a crime like this affects a town…where everyone trusts each other.
Editor: It may be preferable that we don’t know the identity of the killers.
Truman: Exactly! Because what I imagine everyone is now afraid of is, “Who among us did this horrible thing?” It used to be you’d look at someone and think, “There’s old Mr. Busybody.” Now you think…“Did he do it?”
…
D.A.'s Secretary: I’m sorry. The D.A. doesn’t take calls from strange women.
Truman: Who says I’m strange?
…
Nelle Harper Lee [to the camera]: Truman’s parents deserted him at an early age…leaving him with elderly relations in my town. And Truman always disguised his shame over the absence of his parents with grand tales of adventure and glory. “My daddy can’t be here, he’s an aviator.” “My mother’s a photographic subject but they’re coming for me” he would always say. “They’re coming for me.” Every year at Christmas our elementary school did a pageant through the center of town. And one year, Truman wrote his parents that he was the star of the pageant…though he was only a snowflake like me. But, no matter, it worked. They wired him to say they’d take the train from New orleans and get there just in time for the pageant. They even said they’d stand right by the cannon in the square so they could cheer him on. Well, we marched through townand as we got closer to that cannon I could see him straining to see his parents. When we got to that cannon, he stopped forgetting we were supposed to be marching in time to the music. He stopped and he stared…They had not come. I thought for a minute he might break. And then he threw his arms up in the air and twirled himself all the way over. A cartwheel. And then again. And again all the way down the street till his tears were gone.
…
Dectective Dewey: No reporter has special access.
Truman: Sir, I’m not writing a news story. I’m from The New Yorker magazine. I’m writing a psychological study of a village and how that place is affected by a vicious crime. I will not be careless in my depiction. I shall labor over every word, every sound. The final result must be just so…as dazzling and unique as a Faberge egg.
Dewey: Right. And I got a crime to solve.
Truman: But I don’t care whether the crime is solved or not.
Dewey: Well, I sure as hell care. The Clutters went to our church. They were friends of my family’s. No access.
…
Truman [about the Kansas townspeople]: Do you think everyone keeps calling me “lady” to be mean, or can they honestly not tell?
…
Truman [in a grocery store at the Velvetta cheese display]: Could this be all the cheese?
Mrs. Dewey: Well, how much do you need?
Truman: Mine is a matter of quality, dear, not quantity.
Mrs. Dewey: Oh, you mean other types of cheese. Goodness, no. Not here. Are you staying for Christmas?
Truman: Yes, we are.
Mrs. Dewey: What will you and Mrs. Capote do for your Christmas supper?
Truman: Well, if this is the only cheese I find, Mrs. Capote and I might try cyanide.[/b]
By “Mrs Capote” she means Nelle.
[b]Dewey: Truman, you like football?
Truman: Not much. Though I must admit it always sends shivers up my spine when the men get inside that little huddle and whisper.
…
Truman: My goodness, I love shawls. I have several. I think the prettiest one is the one Jennifer Jones gave me.
Mrs. Dewey: Jennifer Jones? The movie star?
Truman: Yes. We were in Rome making a picture called Beat the Devil and I was struggling to write a scene for Bogie when I began to feel the most inhuman pain.
Dewey: Bogie? You mean Humphrey Bogart?!
Truman: I mean Mr. Lauren Bacall, yes. I was trying to write a scene for him and Peter in which they both…
Mrs. Dewey: Wait a minute. Who’s Peter?
Truman: Peter Lorre. But I had a terrible impacted tooth, and so John…
Dewey: Wayne?
Mrs Dewey: Garfield? Kennedy?
Truman: Huston. John Huston, the director.
…
Dewey: Did you meet Humphrey Bogart?
Truman: Meet? My dear, every night we had drinks and dinner and, once, poker!
Dewey: You played poker with Humphrey Bogart?!
Truman: I had a disadvantage in that I didn’t know the game in the way that Bogie or Frank did.
Both Deweys: Frank?!
Truman: Sinatra. Experience had taught them things a relative novice such as myself may not know, like, well…did you know that three of a kind beats a pair? So, I did not defeat Mr. Humphrey Bogart at cards but you may be interested to know I soundly beat him at something else.
[they all lean forward in rapt attention]
Truman: Arm wrestling.[/b]
Great scene. In other words, now they are impressed.
[b]Farmer [to Truman and Nelle]: Herb was one of the most respected ranchers in this state. If there was a list that told you how to succeed with honor…well, he just did everything on it. You see, he worked hard, he took care of his family and when he went to church, he just didn’t get his time card punched. No, he went in and he listened. And I’ve always believed that whenever you do something right it gives you a little bit of weight so that you come to feel rooted to this earth, you know? Solid. Secure. Now what scares me is that, well, sometimes, out of nowhere a bad wind blows up. Now it could be cancer, could be drink, could be some woman that don’t belong to you. And despite the weight that’s holding you to the ground when that wind comes, it picks you up light as a leaf and it takes you where it wants. We’re in control until we’re not. Then we’re helpless.
…
Truman: I think this story is bigger than an article. I think it’s a book.
Nelle: I can see that. But non-fiction, right?
Truman: Yes, of course it will all be true, but…
Nelle: But what? Either it is or it isn’t.
Truman: You’re not understanding. I wanna to bring fictional techniques to a non-fiction story.
Nelle: What fictional techniques? The ones where you make stuff up?
Truman: Excuse me, if I were gonna make stuff up you think I’d bother taking all these notes?
Nelle: You obviously plan to turn Bonnie Clutter into some faux poetic recluse when what it sounds like is that she was just thrown off by her menopause.
Truman: What is your stupid fucking point?
Nelle: That you shouldn’t be doing what you’re doing. The truth is enough!
Truman: I must say I don’t appreciate this lecture from you of all people. To Kill a Mockingbird was based on true things, and you sure improved that.
Nelle: Right. It’s a novel! Reportage means re-creating, not creating.
Truman: This is a new kind of reportage!
Nelle: I’ll say.[/b]
Then they catch the killers.
[b]Nelle: This kind of changes your book.
Truman: You’re telling me. Of course, if I thought it was hard getting the townspeople to open up how in heaven’s name will I ever get the killers to talk?
…
Sheriff: No press inside the prison.
Truman: I have many connections in government. Perhaps I could have someone call, explain what I’m doing?
Sheriff: You’d pretty much have to know the president of the United States before I’d let you visit these boys.[/b]
Guess who Truman knows?
[b]Hickock: You want to write a book about me? If my jackass teachers could hear you say that! Did you ever write a book?
Truman: Certainly. My first novel, Other Voices, Other Rooms, was heralded by critics as the most exciting literary debut since…
Hickock: Yeah, okay.You a queer?
Truman: Yes.
Hickcock: Because I’d let you suck me. I’m not a queer, but letting you suck my dick don’t make me queer. It makes you queer. A mouth’s a mouth.
Truman: Well, thanks, I guess, but no.
…
Smith: What kind of stuff does Tennessee Williams write? I know his name, I just can’t think what are his books.
Truman: He’s a dramatist. He wrote A Streetcar Named Desire.
Smith: That Brando was in?
Truman: The very same.
Smith: Marlon Brando is the fucking king! Now, he’s one of my two favorite actors.
Truman: Who’s the other?
Smith: Humphrey Bogart.
…
Smith: See, this is why I don’t wanna to talk to you! If you want to make me look like some asshole, you will.
Truman: Perry, I never judge my characters.
Smith: Well, here’s something for you to remember all 100 percent of. I am not a character. I’m a human-fucking-being!
Truman: Perry Edward Smith! I am writing this book with or without you. Now, you can get involved, so I can make you a three-dimensional human being or you can continue this foolishness and I will head straight back to New York and write what I want!
…
Truman: When you’re talking to Dick and Perry, they seem like perfectly nice boys. To be frank, I’m much more concerned for my safety around Norman Mailer.
…
Smith [in a letter to Truman regarding the pornography Truman sent him]: “Dear Mr. Capote: It was extremely solicitous of you to send me those periodicals. But I regret to inform you that the reading material was repellent. My future will soon be determined. But there are only two outcomes: Life in prison or death. So, whether I have a short time remaining or a long time to come I owe it to my mind to fill it with things of beauty and intelligence.”[/b]
So, Truman send him books that he has written:
[b]Smith [in the next letter]: “Dear Mr. Capote: Thank you for the reading material. It was much more intellectual than the pussy pictures you sent before. However, though the stories are told well I, ultimately, did not like them, because I thought the writing lacked kindness.”
…
Truman: I want you to know. I have given my whole life to one effort…the creation of a great work of art.
[Smith laughs]
Truman: Please don’t laugh at me.
Smith: My whole life…all I’ve wanted was to create a work of art. I sang, nobody listened. I painted, nobody looked. Now, Dick and me, we murder four people. And what’s gonna come out of it? A work of art. I’m laughing at me.
…
Smith: You want me to open up, but I don’t think you can understand me.
Truman: Why not?
Smith: It was your books. I thought you looked down on the people you were writing about like you were sneering at them…If I’m gonna put my heart in front of you I need to know I’m doing it with someone who will listen to it and not make a joke out of it like you did with Holly Go-fucking-lightly. You can’t write my story because your idea of suffering is so far from mine.
Truman: It’s not. I promise.
Smith: Goodbye.
…
Smith [after he grabs Truman, clamps his hand around his mouth and drags him into his cell]: So, I’m sympathetic, am I? You been looking out for me, have you? What’s the title of your book? The “sympathetic” one about me? I know the title. The fucking guard told me, and it’s not sympathetic. It’s called In Cold Blood, isn’t it? It is, isn’t it? It’s called In Cold Fucking Blood! You sold me out, you shit after I opened myself up and gave you everything. Well, you’re not gonna get away with it. One sound out of you and you’ll join the Clutters in hell.
…
Truman: In Cold Blood is the title of my book, but it’s not exactly what you think. You boys did a monstrous thing. And the public and their prosecutors are calling for your blood. If they get what they want, they will kill you not in a senseless moment of passion, but with scrupulous premeditation. That is the legal definition of “in cold blood.” This title is a condemnation of their plans.
Smith: But not only their plans.
Truman: No. No, not only. Look, you did a terrible thing. You’re not innocent. That doesn’t mean you’re not a human being. I want people to see that.
Smith: I’m not talking to you until I’ve read what you’ve written.
…
Nelle: So how’s the book?
Truman: Well, it’s coming. I have to leave in a couple days for their trial.
Nelle: That’s all pro forma, right? They’re not contesting anything, are they?
Truman: No, they hope for life, not death. Death would be better for the book. It would satisfy the readers more, and it would make the title work too. Honey, I’ve worked harder on this than anything my whole life. I don’t want it ruined just because a jury makes a dumb decision.
…
Truman [after Smith and Hickcock are sentenced to die]: Will you appeal?
Smith: Dick wants to. But we’ll hang. We should.
Truman: You think hanging is fair?
Smith: It’s funny. Last night I was laying awake and thinking: What is punishment? Being in jail isn’t punishment, if you didn’t like it on the outside. And neither is death, if it was painful to live.
…
Smith: I’ll tell you what punishment is for me.
Truman: What?
Smith: It’s hoping there’s someone for you. And after years of no one you find him and you can’t have him.
…
Babe: Do you have any word yet about when the book is coming out?
Truman: I don’t know. You simply cannot conceive of the agony. I’ve worked on this book ceaselessly for four years pouring the whole of myself into it, head and heart. And then to be waiting like this…unable to publish what I’ve done until they’re hanged.
…
Jack [to the camera]: On death row, you may only write two letters a week. Every week, for five years Perry wrote both letters to Truman.[/b]
After they are hung and the book is published…
[b]Bennett Cerf: It made him the most famous author in America and very, very rich. He moved to Manhattan where, oddly, he had a very good view of the place he had left.
…
Nelle: Who ever knows what our hearts will want? Who can defend themselves from it Seeing what’s happened to him since…well, despite the bravado that only appears to be confidence…I have come to feel with great heart-sickness that there were three deaths on the gallows that night.
…
Bennett Cerf: He never wrote anything big again. Just collections, fragments pulled together. God knows he didn’t have to write, not after all that money on In Cold Blood. It’s funny. It made him, and it ruined him.
…
Jack: You know, in his will Perry left everything to Truman.
…
Nelle: America is not a country where the small gesture goes noticed. We’re not a country like France, where charm – something light or effervescent – can survive. We want everything you have, and we want it as fast as you can turn it out.
…
Nelle: I read an interview with Frank Sinatra in which he said about Judy Garland: “Every time she sings, she dies a little.” That’s how much she gave. It’s true for writers, too who hope to create something lasting. They die a little getting it right. And then the book comes out and there’s a dinner. Maybe they give you a prize. And then comes the inevitable and very American question: What’s next?
…
Nelle: But the next thing can be so hard…because now you know what it demands.[/b]
Of course, after To Kill a Mockingbird there really wasn’t anything that came “next” for her either.