as always, I just write for me…
in my pursuit to understand what it means to be human…
I engage in some “idol” speculations…
think about emotions…
we, as philosophers, tend to think about the rational side of
being human, but, we are as much emotional animals as we are
rational animals… and perhaps, we are more emotional/feelings
animals then we are rational/logical beings…
today, we see the conflict in the modern political world,
as being a battle between those who are conservative and they
engage with security/safety beliefs as one of their primary
beliefs…whereas we have liberals who tend to, again, tend to,
to engage in other primary beliefs which is the belief in justice and freedom…
conservatives are the one’s pushing for security/safety laws…
they support such things as “Patriot act” and other self defense
measures as torture to “protect” America…
Liberals push such political agendas as making justice the primary
driver of American political agenda… along with freedom…
we see this interplay as being the primary source of American
politics over the last 20 years… are you in favor of security/safety, conservative
or are you in favor of justice/freedom, liberal…
but where does this come from? I mean how do we get to
the point where the two basic pushes of the political drive comes
from either the need for security/safety or the drive for justice/freedom?
I would suggest and we begin our “idol speculation”
effort right now…
I would suggest that we get our primary drives from our childhood…
and my suggestion derives from Hobbes… who wrote that the basic
fundamental drive of his life comes from fear…he admits to being a man
who lived in fear all his life… and his political philosophy would certainly
suggest this…he argued for the idea that the state/society itself cannot
be secure unless it was ruled by an absolute sovereign/king…
he argued quite strongly that the only way to make the state safe, was
to turn over to the king all of the responsibilities of making the state safe…
to this end, he even defended the right of this “absolute” ruler being able
to enforce all laws and rules in any way, shape or form, that the ruler
wanted to, up to and including the right of the ruler to take the goods of
the subjects which includes the property of the subjects…
a ruler whose word was absolute law…
and we see how the fear that Hobbes felt manifested itself
in his political philosophy……
so let us take that as our starting point…
so what would it mean if we have someone who isn’t in fear about
their security/safety? what would their political philosophy look like?
I would suggest that it would be the liberal viewpoint of society…
if you are always fearful, then making security/safety as your primary
goal, makes sense…but if you are not fearful, then making security/safety
your primary goal makes no sense… it isn’t needed if you feel secure in life…
and we can see how that this security/safety need arises in childhood…
and how the need for justice/freedom can also arise in childhood…
just as Hobbes felt fear which lead him to adapt security/safety as his
primary goal in life, we can see how those who grew up being safe/secure
can make justice/freedom their primary goal in life…
so depending upon how one approaches life, will come one’s political
philosophy… as I am not fearful of life, my political beliefs are liberal,
thus I make as my primary goal justice/freedom…
in a very real sense, the goal we attempt to reach comes from how
we feel about life… I feel safe and secure and conservatives feel threaten
and uneasy about life… and it shows in our respective political philosophy…
and it should be easy to confirm this and it is… reread IQ45 convention speech…
it is one dire and frighten speech… in reading it, one would think
that our inner cites were on fire and the nation was in complete and dire
threat of collapse… and that resonated with some people, conservatives
who live with fear…
as liberals don’t see America that way, we see the positive…
thus we don’t need to pursue security/safety as our primary goal…
now as a thought experiment, try this…
how do you see America?
How do you view society?
are you fearful and scared about what others might do to you?
your answers will tell you if you are a conservative or a liberal…
or said another way, political philosophy is a confession about
your viewpoint of society…
fearful/mistrustful… conservative…
secure/feeling safe… liberal…
now this little thought experiment is not for me, I already know
my own viewpoint/political philosophy…do it for your own benefit…
Kropotkin