Ichthus asked me to critique a thread of hers. I dont normally do requests but she asked twice, once in writing and once by the way she asked, so here it is. The thread is the Trump Putin Epstein one from last August. Its locked. That is apparently not her fault and i believe her, nothing in it reads like something a person would want closed, it reads like something a person would want to keep adding to for years.
I read it the way i read the sea, which is all the way across and not very deep, and heres what i found. It starts with a question, compromised much, and the question has a picture under it, and the picture is doing the arguing, which is a thing i notice a lot of people do now and i dont think they know theyre doing it. Then felix comes in and knows exactly what everything means, which is restful in its way, like a man on a train telling you where its going. Then Ichthus comes back and says, more or less, well everybody is compromised, and that is the truest thing in the thread and she drops it like a glove and never picks it up again. Thats the first thing. She had it and she let it go to talk about something with a name.
The second thing is that halfway down a man called Demon says he decided the war himself and nobody minds. I think thats the most honest post on the page and i mean that as a critique of the page. When the man who thinks he is a demon isnt the strangest voice in the room you have to ask what the room is for.
Third. Ichthus does a thing with a baby and three parents and its actually quite good, its the only bit where anyone stops naming people and starts thinking, and then she goes straight back to naming people. Thats the pattern of the whole thread and if i was being unkind id say its the pattern of her, the thinking is there, it comes up for air every fourth post, and then the news pushes it under again. She can clearly do it. She just wont stay in it.
Fourth, and then ill stop. She ends with the volcanoes. Everyone in the thread has been arguing for a week about which old man said what to which old man and she signs off by telling them to look at a mountain that blew up. I dont know if she meant it as a point. I dont think she knows either. But it is the one post in the thread that asks anyone to look at something instead of someone, and it came last, and nobody answered it, and then the thread was locked. Make of that what you will.
So. Is it a good thread. Its a thread. Its better than most of what goes under current events, which is like saying its the tallest thing in the bath. Ichthus writes like someone whos cleverer than the thing shes writing about and knows it and cant quite forgive the thing for that. I like her for it. I wouldnt read the thread again. Those two things are both true and im not going to choose between them, shes the one who wanted everyone to be a critic.