The internet transformed commerce, creating a “co-constructed environment for flourishing” and elevating figures like Jack Ma and Jeff Bezos.
Now, AI is driving an academic revolution.
This revolution awaits you and me—not as spectators, but as participants. Together, let us “co-construct an environment for flourishing” and build a new academic institutional order.
-–
The Fundamental Differences Between Old and New Systems:
Old System:
Journals select papers. Authors beg journals. Peer review is a black hole. Rejection is the final verdict. The evaluation standard is “who you are, what tools you used, whether your formatting is correct.” They can silence you without giving any reason.
New System:
Papers select journals. Journals compete for papers. Argumentative validation precedes formatting review. Rejection is repairable. Injustice can be appealed. The evaluation standard is “whether your argument holds.” Paradigm innovations are protected from suppression by conservative forces. Scientific progress is accelerated.
-–
The new system achieves three reversals:
· Power Reversal: From “authors seeking journals” to “journals competing for papers”
· Standard Reversal: From “inquiring about provenance” to “testing arguments”
· Role Reversal: From “journals reviewing papers” to “journals servicing papers”
-–
Paper One: The Paradigm Shift in Academic Evaluation: From Textual Provenance to Argumentative Validation
Paper One completes the philosophical critique—explaining why the old system is wrong and why the new system is right.
Paper Two: A New Paradigm for Academic Ecosystems: Institutional Exploration from Argumentative Validation to Intelligent Triage
Paper Two completes the institutional design—explaining how the new system is built, how it operates, and how the transition is achieved.
Read the two papers together—from thought to action—for a complete understanding of this academic revolution.
-–
Full texts are now available. Welcome to read, discuss, and co-construct.
Paper One Download Link:
https://philpapers.org/rec/TPSGGL
Paper Two Download Link: