# Airplane on a Treadmill Problem

**URL:** https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287
**Category:** Science, Technology, and Math
**Created:** [September 8, 2008, 4:35pm UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287 "2008-09-08T16:35:54Z")
**Posts on this page:** 18
**Page:** 2

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/anthem/32/605_2.png) [@Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Anthem)
#### Post date: [September 19, 2008, 1:48am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/21 "2008-09-19T01:48:41Z")

</div>

Yes, I have piloted a Cessna, actually. I can dig up some pictures if you’d like.

I’m also a mechanical engineer. I know a few things about physics.

By the way…there is ALWAYS friction. Always always always. In everything, always. Should I say it again? Always.

P.S. Always.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![xzc](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/xzc/32/568_2.png) [@xzc](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/xzc)
#### Post date: [September 19, 2008, 1:57am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/22 "2008-09-19T01:57:24Z")

</div>

![](http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y11/drloomis3/Cat-YouJustGotServed.jpg)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/anthem/32/605_2.png) [@Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Anthem)
#### Post date: [September 19, 2008, 2:37am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/23 "2008-09-19T02:37:15Z")

</div>

Thank ya, sir ![](http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v409/mcsalv/Smilies/hsughr.gif)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![namelesss](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/n/eb8c5e/32.png) [@namelesss](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/namelesss)
#### Post date: [September 20, 2008, 11:07am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/24 "2008-09-20T11:07:36Z")

</div>

> [@Anthem](#):
>
> Yes, I have piloted a Cessna, actually. I can dig up some pictures if you’d like.
> 
> I’m also a mechanical engineer. I know a few things about physics.

In the real world, there’s only so much that you can learn in 23 short years, son. If you knew a few more things about aeronautics and physics, you might understand what I’m saying.

> [@](#):
>
> By the way…there is ALWAYS friction. Always always always. In everything, always. Should I say it again? Always.
> 
> P.S. Always.

Irrelevent to the equation!  
Increase the friction and increase the thrust, so? The OP provided no limits either way.  
But, I’m good with agreeing to disagree.  
Peace

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/anthem/32/605_2.png) [@Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Anthem)
#### Post date: [September 20, 2008, 5:16pm UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/25 "2008-09-20T17:16:40Z")

</div>

Haha, you’re a joke, son, and if you’d have spent a little more time on this site you’d know that saying ‘son’ is my thing, so step off, junior.

I’m a master of the physics it takes to solve this problem. I’m not bragging because it’s not hard.

By the way, I’m also in the Air Force…I’m not particularly proud of that fact either but it does mean I spend a little bit of time around airplanes. Like, all day every day.

Friction is only irrelevant if you want to make the problem unrealistic. So go ahead, son.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/cyrene/32/615_2.png) [@Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Cyrene)
#### Post date: [September 20, 2008, 5:25pm UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/26 "2008-09-20T17:25:46Z")

</div>

This is by far the best thread ever. haha.

Calling someone out on whether or not they pilot planes, when they do. Hahaha. ah, wow.

glad it wasn’t me.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![namelesss](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/n/eb8c5e/32.png) [@namelesss](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/namelesss)
#### Post date: [September 20, 2008, 7:11pm UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/27 "2008-09-20T19:11:01Z")

</div>

This^^^ is nothing but a display of a young ego and adds nothing to ‘refute’ what I have offered, or to advance the conversation. Now, while in college you are also in the air force, also an ‘engineer’… also in the CIA?? Whatever… Blah, blah… Thats right, yes, you are soooo special, I agree. Happy?  
It must be difficult learning anything there in school when you are so full of yourself.  
Well, your problem not mine. The OP has been solved. If you have no serious rational, logical, definitive examination and refutation to what has been offered, stand down, son, and if you have such, stand and deliver. I’m not interested in the wounded squeakings of your ego… Mice don’t make such a fuss when their tails get stepped on… (rolls eyes)  
Stop telling us all how special you are and stand and deliver!  
Or stand down!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/cyrene/32/615_2.png) [@Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Cyrene)
#### Post date: [September 20, 2008, 7:53pm UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/28 "2008-09-20T19:53:20Z")

</div>

Theres nothing to add to the ‘debate’ because the straight dope is right. Well, minus slight changes to the problem, myth busters also did it, as was mentioned earlier. Theres also plenty of great explanations, readily available online for “WHY” this is the case.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/anthem/32/605_2.png) [@Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Anthem)
#### Post date: [September 21, 2008, 12:26am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/29 "2008-09-21T00:26:08Z")

</div>

I’m not in college anymore, I just haven’t updated my profile because I’ve been busy getting indoctrinated into active duty. You know, “growing up,” as you might call it.

This guy is something, eh Cyrene? I gave him plenty of physical explanation and a god damn video of the actual problem and apparently that adds nothing to the conversation 😆

Oh, for the record Cyrene, I am not a pilot, although I have flown a Cessna before. I was selected for pilot training but was later disqualified for medical reasons. All Air Force officers should know something about airplanes, however; it’s in the curriculum for good commissioning programs. I’m currently working as a base civil engineer. It’s not the same interaction with planes as maintenance or piloting, but you do have to know something about the aircraft in order to design facilities to support them. Also, you learn simply by being in the culture and picking up what other people talk about.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/cyrene/32/615_2.png) [@Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Cyrene)
#### Post date: [September 21, 2008, 3:46am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/30 "2008-09-21T03:46:53Z")

</div>

Theres still the obviously huge gap in professional knowledge which the guy discounts out of hand as meaningless, despite your clear explanations as to why he’s wrong. If you were wrong the fact that you had relevant experience would be meaningless, but because you’re correct; its really not.

Like I said earlier; haha!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/anthem/32/605_2.png) [@Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Anthem)
#### Post date: [September 21, 2008, 4:56am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/31 "2008-09-21T04:56:12Z")

</div>

He’s not really wrong…we’re pretty much saying the same thing, but he attacked me right off the bat as having discredited something he said earlier. That’s not the case because I didn’t even waste the time to read his posts.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![namelesss](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/n/eb8c5e/32.png) [@namelesss](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/namelesss)
#### Post date: [September 22, 2008, 6:15pm UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/32 "2008-09-22T18:15:13Z")

</div>

[mythbustersresults.com/episode97](http://mythbustersresults.com/episode97)

Over and done! Now you can continue to display your ignorances. Perhaps reading the posts would have kept you from embarassing yourselves… kiddies. Ego, ego…  
(Perhaps this thread should have been in the psychology section?)

(Poor poor poor ruffled juvenile egos. If you both knew anything about physics, children… you know, ‘action and equal and opposite reaction’ and all, but… have fun on your skateboards, kiddies! Perfect intellect for the military, though! Hahahha… Pffft!)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/cyrene/32/615_2.png) [@Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Cyrene)
#### Post date: [September 22, 2008, 7:52pm UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/33 "2008-09-22T19:52:26Z")

</div>

Was that last post supposed to mean somthing? most of the people talking in this thread have come to the conclusion that the plane does take off. if they didn’t already come to that conclusion quite some time ago.

Kiddies is plural, who are you talking to? How many people in this thread have engaged you in formal debate for you to be calling them wrong and stupid over it?

Granted, I may have called you wrong and that assertion would be incorrect because I didn’t read your posts, but my assertion at the start of this thread was that the plane lifts. Infact, I still don’t understand how Cecil’s explanation isn’t on the spot.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/anthem/32/605_2.png) [@Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Anthem)
#### Post date: [September 23, 2008, 12:59am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/34 "2008-09-23T00:59:39Z")

</div>

Haha, oh my god are you kidding me? Did you even bother to follow my youtube link? It IS the clip from mythbusters!!!

> [@Anthem](#):
>
> Mythbusters did it.

> [@Anthem](#):
>
> Oh sure, everyone just ignore that crazy bastard Anthem.
> 
> [youtube.com/watch?v=YORCk1BN7QY](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YORCk1BN7QY)
> 
> The only way to keep the airplane stationary would be to govern the wheels to the takeoff speed of the aircraft (which is the speed of the treadmill in the problem). As it is, the wheels spin twice as fast as the takeoff speed dictates.

Wow you’re an ignoramus! That’s awesome beyond comprehension.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/cyrene/32/615_2.png) [@Cyrene](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Cyrene)
#### Post date: [September 24, 2008, 10:52am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/35 "2008-09-24T10:52:27Z")

</div>

> [@Anthem](#):
>
> Haha, oh my god are you kidding me? Did you even bother to follow my youtube link? It IS the clip from mythbusters!!!
> 
> > [@Anthem](#):
> >
> > Mythbusters did it.
> 
> > [@Anthem](#):
> >
> > Oh sure, everyone just ignore that crazy bastard Anthem.
> > 
> > [youtube.com/watch?v=YORCk1BN7QY](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YORCk1BN7QY)
> > 
> > The only way to keep the airplane stationary would be to govern the wheels to the takeoff speed of the aircraft (which is the speed of the treadmill in the problem). As it is, the wheels spin twice as fast as the takeoff speed dictates.
> 
> Wow you’re an ignoramus! That’s awesome beyond comprehension.

I thought that youtube link was just a link of you performing some bada$$ tricks on your skateboard.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/user_avatar/www.ilovephilosophy.com/anthem/32/605_2.png) [@Anthem](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/Anthem)
#### Post date: [September 25, 2008, 3:10am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/36 "2008-09-25T03:10:55Z")

</div>

I had a sweet image having to do with a skateboard, but now I can’t make it. Sorry to disappoint, all.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![north](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/n/7ea924/32.png) [@north](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/north)
#### Post date: [October 4, 2008, 3:42am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/37 "2008-10-04T03:42:12Z")

</div>

> [@Carleas](#):
>
> > [@"\[url=http://www.boingboing.net/2006/12/11/airplanetreadmill-pr.html](#):
> >
> > Boingboing[/url], quoting the New York Times,"]“Imagine a plane is sitting on a massive conveyor belt, as wide and as long as a runway. The conveyer belt is designed to exactly match the speed of the wheels, moving in the opposite direction. Can the plane take off? “I say no, because the plane will not move relative the the ground and air, and thus, very little air will flow over the wings. However, other people are convinced that since the wheels of a plane are free spinning, and not powered by the engines, and the engines provide thrust against the air, that somehow that makes a difference and air will flow over the wing.”
> 
> your right
> 
> because the speed of the wheels are exactly the result of the the thrust given off by the engines
> 
> a stand-still
> 
> > [@"\[url=http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2638/an-airplane-taxies-in-one-direction-on-a-moving-conveyor-belt-going-the-opposite-direction-can-the-plane-take-off](#):
> >
> > The Straight Dope[/url]"]First the obvious-but-wrong answer. The unwary tend to reason by analogy to a car on a conveyor belt–if the conveyor moves backward at the same rate that the car’s wheels rotate forward, the net result is that the car remains stationary. An aircraft in the same situation, they figure, would stay planted on the ground, since there’d be no air rushing over the wings to give it lift. But of course cars and planes don’t work the same way. A car’s wheels are its means of propulsion–they push the road backwards (relatively speaking), and the car moves forward. In contrast, a plane’s wheels aren’t motorized; their purpose is to reduce friction during takeoff (and add it, by braking, when landing). What gets a plane moving are its propellers or jet turbines, which shove the air backward and thereby impel the plane forward. What the wheels, conveyor belt, etc, are up to is largely irrelevant. Let me repeat: Once the pilot fires up the engines, the plane moves forward at pretty much the usual speed relative to the ground–and more importantly the air–regardless of how fast the conveyor belt is moving backward. This generates lift on the wings, and the plane takes off. All the conveyor belt does is, as you correctly conclude, make the plane’s wheels spin madly.
> > 
> > A thought experiment commonly cited in discussions of this question is to imagine you’re standing on a health-club treadmill in rollerblades while holding a rope attached to the wall in front of you. The treadmill starts; simultaneously you begin to haul in the rope. Although you’ll have to overcome some initial friction tugging you backward, in short order you’ll be able to pull yourself forward easily.
> 
> I’m with the New York Times on this. Cecil’s explanation is wrong. Here’s why: The wheels on a plane are there to reduce friction. It therefore seems accepted that a certain amount of friction will stop the plane from taking off. But a treadmill beneath the plane, increasing the speed at which the wheels are turning, also increases the friction that they feel: they are the equivalent of a drag on the plane. If that drag is great enough, the plane cannot take off. Since there will always be a coefficient of friction, the drag will become great enough at some speed.  
> The example Cecil gives of the rollerblades doesn’t account for the ever-increasing speed of the treadmill. The treadmill will knock you over, even with rollerblades on, at a certain speed. You won’t necessarily be able to pull yourself forward without falling.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![north](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/n/7ea924/32.png) [@north](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/u/north)
#### Post date: [October 4, 2008, 3:43am UTC](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287/38 "2008-10-04T03:43:15Z")

</div>

> [@north](#):
>
> > [@Carleas](#):
> >
> > > [@"\[url=http://www.boingboing.net/2006/12/11/airplanetreadmill-pr.html](#):
> > >
> > > Boingboing[/url], quoting the New York Times,"]“Imagine a plane is sitting on a massive conveyor belt, as wide and as long as a runway. The conveyer belt is designed to exactly match the speed of the wheels, moving in the opposite direction. Can the plane take off? “I say no, because the plane will not move relative the the ground and air, and thus, very little air will flow over the wings. However, other people are convinced that since the wheels of a plane are free spinning, and not powered by the engines, and the engines provide thrust against the air, that somehow that makes a difference and air will flow over the wing.”

your right

because the speed of the wheels are exactly the result of the the thrust given off by the engines

a stand-still

[Previous page](https://www.ilovephilosophy.com/t/airplane-on-a-treadmill-problem/22287.md?page=1)
