– Nice work sir – the trial was almost as good as the orginal Lewis Carroll version!
I suppose I’m sort of an existentialist/perspectivist if I’m anything so you were pushing against an open door anyhow– but the points were delivered in a lovely witty dialectic.
Personally for me scary thing about Rand is not just philosophical absolutism but that a version of her philosophy seems to be the ONLY thinking permitted in economics today – that objectively all people act in their “rational self interests†and that the only real “good†or “interest†or motivation to get up in the morning is the realisation of financial gain.
But that’s really a political argument and I’d have to disagree with you personally about capitalism in general as a vehicle for realising anyone’s potential fully.
That said NickOtanin Neo Objectivism seems like a reasonable and broadminded approach to understanding the world to me!
I tried but I couldn’t finish; my apologies. I read the first four parts but found I was getting bogged down so I began to skim. All I succeeded in doing was to confirm my philosophical deficiency. As I read faster and faster an image slowly appeared in my mind. I was in a room with a number of learned looking men in suits, all with unique, distinguished presentations of facial hair, sitting around a bored room table. They were discussing their various perspectives of life in esoteric language that was beyond my comprehension. Becoming bored and being a carpenter by trade I began to look at the table. I started by admiring the finish but then looked at the structure underneath. That’s when I discovered that the men in suits were naked from the waist down and by God if they didn’t all look the same.
In part six I came across a reference to dying for beliefs. I had a brief discussion about that notion with someone who became irate after reading my poem soldier’s lament. My response is now a signature statement: “We agree to die for our various beliefs only because we can’t agree on the one reason to live”.
Hey Deb cut and paste 6-10 into word and print at size 10 and have a read!
the first 4 were actually the slightly more boring sections
…The trial did contain a lot of defense arguments that you might use as a “liberal” in general against any totalitarian ideology but it was very well written and stirring at points - nah best thing I’ve read today I have to say
Krossie, I have read your posts in other threads to which I have contributed. As a consequence, when I see you name in the index I usually click. It is only because you said this piece was well done that I decided to take a look. However, despite your recommendation I will read no more and not because I disagree with you assessment that it well done. It never occurred to me to evaluate the writing. It is the language to which I object. In my opinion religious/philosophical language, rather than reveal it, actually obscures the truth. This piece could be beautifully written but it is written in the most obscure philosophical language. The fact that you said it is the “best thing I’ve read today” gives me hope for tomorrow.
I appreciate that someone has read the entire series and commented. I hope a few more people do. I’ll be patient.
I wonder if anybody would support the prosecution in this case. I was hoping to have jury deliberation, among people who have read the entire series, and see how they vote on whether the defendants should be punished or freed. The rest of the story is up to all of you, whoever wants to take the responsibility and interact.
Hey thanks for you’re very nice words re meself and your point is very much taken in general. My own patience has worn very thin with “professional†obscurers like Deleuze, Heidiegger etc. Similarly for a lot of pseudo-science and so.
The use of language as a tool to hide rather than illuminate is time honoured but there have never been so many tasty “jargon pots†from all sorts of subjects as right now in the 21st century.
That said, though, I thought he actually explained 3 philosophical systems very well as he went along including pragmatism which was fairly new to me. Obviously this is a philosophical board and people will/have to use some of the jargon some of the time.
However it seemed to me that Nick was very much in the illumination camp rather then the deliberately obscurantist wing.
I’ll admit though these sort of things are very subjective and I take your general point…
You may need to invite some of your ex buddies over – but on the other hand you might not wana do that
Hey some of us are very sensitive about our retreating folicles!