Are Goats Philosophers?

It can be said that half of philosophy is spent in a state of Observation, and the rest is via Argumentation.

Goats, I have noticed (Observation) appear to possess the same traits.

Tell me otherwise (Argumentation). How is a goat not a philosopher? Furthermore, are you a goat? Some of you seem pretty goatee to me.

Personally, I wouldn’t call a goat a philosopher because I’ve actually understood what goats have said before. Not so with most philosophers. There again, this just may be because I’m not intelligent enough to understand philosophers.

The first goat seems to be a good observer, while the second one must be good in argumentation.

With love,
Sanjay

^^ lols, so true.

well I am a Capricorn. :stuck_out_tongue:

…but maybe there is something prior to our linguistic minds, a set of basic states also going on in us. I sometimes think we are like animals but with an extra bit of brain shoved on the front lol

Curry goat, accompanied with rice and peas :stuck_out_tongue:

That last goat looks crazy man…

Mags,

You just caused a huge loss to philosophy as we will miss the contribution of two great philosophers. You cannot be that selfish. Shift to chicken.

With love,
Sanjay

What makes you think goats engage in argumentation???

Gib,

Why do you think that animals can not argue?

Look at this -

drive.google.com/file/d/0Bwkj1Y … cslist_api

With love,
Sanjay

Oh, I don’t know…

I mean, sure, under strict behaviorism, a Canadian’s internal mental state can’t be determined from observation alone… they speak, but it has yet been proven its true intelligence and not merely mimicking the words that they heard Americans say. They are, at best as we can ascertain, the Cartesian Beast Machine, and valid to dissect without anaesthesia for organ harvesting.

Or… you can say a angry goat is being a bit of a argumentive shithead. Scientific opinion is a leap of faith, either way Gib.

I think that’s a stretch.

Its as big as a stretch as Canadian Nationalism.

OK.

The image of the second goat - he’s the real philosopher. He just came upon some elusive truth which had been escaping him and now he’s agonizing over it before he comes to accept it and make it his own.

The first goat is thinking about her boyfriend coming to pick her up.

^^ lols so true :slight_smile:

Why do the yanks say stuff like that a bout Canadians, is it because they know inside they are traitorous scum :mrgreen: . Or generally a nation of gun toting criminals and so despise that which they could have been. :stuck_out_tongue:

I don’t know. I’m guessing it has something to do with our ties to the English.

I see no profound loss in making curry goat out of… goats… a dish which brings eternal happiness to the many upon tasting its curried delights.

My parents keep goats (amongst other farm animals) and they just always seem to be on the attack.

I just noticed… goats have the oddest eye slits. They’re rectangular.

What does that say about their natural habitat? What does it say about their subjective visual experience of the world?

Are the secrets of the universe hidden in those philosophical goat eyes? :laughing:

I never got over seeing goats for the first time in Iraq, those ones have eyes like a slit, up and down. They were bouncing around palm trees, one looked at me, I looked at it… they are fucking weird, like something that should of died out in the last ice age, but we decided to preserve those stupid things as they are so easy to exploit.

O also had one as a neighbor in Waimanelo for a while, neighbor built a hut for his goat bigger than the guard house I was living in. Damn thing never shut up. Or the chickens. Or the tweakers.

More supporting evidence: hoe goats like to snift one another’s urine and aerate in their mouths to experience the full aroma of it.

Not to assume what were doing in Iraq?