Discourse regarding Hegel's dialectic

Meno2 · November 13, 2016, 11:59pm

Granted, but stille there are differences, among even the basics of Lord Russell and Wittgenstein.

The suicide of a key member of the Viennese Circle, finished that off, leaving a lot of indefinite questions.

Arminius · November 14, 2016, 12:20am

The founder of the modern mathematical logic (=> logistic, symbolic logic …) was Gottlob Frege (1848-1925), the spiritual father of Bertrand Russel (1872-1970) and of Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951).

Arminius · November 19, 2016, 2:13pm

Arminius:

Arminius:

If you are a White-who-officially-hates-Whites, or, just for example, a Christian-who-officially-hates-Christians, a Jew-who-officially-hates-Jews, a Nazi-who-officially-hates-Nazis, a capitalist-who-officially-hates-capitalists, … and so on, then you have good prospects to get respect - at least officially. The more you are officially (thus: not really) a self-criticist, the more respect you get - at least officially.

The method is very easy: You jump with your “thesis” (e.g.: “X is evil”) into your “synthesis” (e.g.: “if X is [not] well treated, then X [remains evil] is good”) - the role of the smiling third - by suppressing the “antithesis” (e.g.: “X is good”) and telling the lie that “the antithesis has always the chance to oppose and is always using its opposing role”.

The group "X“ depends always on its "therapist“ or "teacher“ or "reeducator“. It has no chance to become a good one, if its "therapist“ or "teacher“ or "reeducator“ does not want that, because it can always be ointerpreted as being "evil“.