Do Atheists Float?

Atleast your honest. :stuck_out_tongue:

It really isn’t all that mystical to be an atheist. It is a normal position.

I disagree. In the present world, one needn’t feel the twang of irrationality for suggesting that Thor, Zeus, or Krishna doesn’t exist. I see no reason not to apply such thinking to any other divinities.

This becomes especially important when one adopts a metaphysical system that does not include any gods. I generally have a hard time taking anyone with a massively underdeveloped metaphysical system seriously – to simply shrug this issue off is the same as building a house without a foundation!

Now, could I be wrong about my metaphysical orientation in the universe? Of course! It would be silly to suggest that I am infallible. However, within that metaphysical system gods have no place.

I take issue with anyone who ‘completely rejects the possibility of god’s existance’. I’m sure that doesn’t describe all atheists. Does it describe you, Joker?

You are probably correct, so nevermind the specific divinity people choose to worship. But to dismiss away the possibility that some god may exist somewhere… that’s a difficult position to maintain.

And I don’t think you are trying to do so, but the poll for this thread asks whether one rejects the possibility of god. One option for answering is ‘yes, completely’. It is this that evokes my comments and I think Standard23’s too, although he is welcome to correct me on that point.

Well, but in that case what does “god” mean and what separates it from “alien” or even “thing”?

I mean, if the term “god” is purposefully left undefined and can mean anything, well, of course god could exist. Heck, I’ll even go out on a limb and say that god does exist because we can define it however we want. I believe in this laptop I am typing on, does that mean I believe in a god? I sure hope not!

But that is not the correct interpretation of option #1, the option to which Standard 23’s reply refers. Option #1 in no way implies the weaker claim that you seem to believe it does, i.e., that a god doesn’t exist. That option concerns possibility, not probability. It implies the much stronger claim that a god cannot exist.

This is what both ‘Standard 23’ and I find silly. Anyone who believes that a logically possible god cannot possibly exist either is an irrational loon or doesn’t understand the meaning of the words in the claim.

In your case, it’s obviously just a slight oversight; a failure to recognize that option one deals with ‘possibility.’

Are you either a theist (i.e., one who has a belief that god(s) exists) or an atheist (i.e., one who does not have the belief that a god(s) exists)?

I know you’re busy so I’ll take the liberty of answering that question for you :wink::

Yes.

We all are either the one or the other.

We all either believe a proposition or not (for whatever reason).

Here is the same point put in terms of Bertrand Russell’s famous teapot: Either we believe that a china teapot is orbiting the sun at this moment or we don’t.

Of course it’s possible that such a teapot IS in orbit round the sun, but where is the evidence required to rationally believe such a proposition? An unlimited number of propositions may be true, that no one has the first bit of justification to believe are true.

Practically-speaking, no one can disprove the claim that a china teapot is in orbit about the sun; but the failure to disprove a claim, when there is no reasonable way in which to do so, is no grounds upon which to justify a belief that the claim is true.

RC-- your reasoning is flawed, you must first know what Kris defines as atheist, religious, and agnostic, so it was silly to answer for her/him, without knowing this(and just plain rude to do it under any circumstances).

So Kris, explain? I am very interested to know the answers.

Did you not see the smiley face at the end of my answer?

. . . oh nevermind.

And my reasoning wasn’t flawed because I stated the definition for ‘theist’ and ‘atheist’ that I used in my question before I (jokingly) answered it for Kris.

Just in case you missed it, I used these definitions:

theist: one who has a belief that god(s) exists.

atheist: one who does not have the belief that a god(s) exists.

Defined thus, we are all either a ‘theist’ or an ‘atheist.’

shrugs I think that people who say that the world could be flat are foolish and wasting their time. I think that people who say that JFK wasn’t shot are foolish and wasting their time. I think that anyone who earnestly believes in the Flying Spaghetti Monster is foolish and wasting their time.

Are all those things possible? Not in the sense the word normally means.

Of course they´re possible.

Possibility is distinct from probability - that´s the difference we speak of.

By that rendering, everything is possible.

I tend to be in favor of rejecting definitions that cover everything because the word lacks any meaning.

No, to be any of the above I would actually have to believe in the concept of gods. I do not believe in any part of the god concept. Wether for or against. You see to be an athiest one has to believe in the concept of Gods in able to deny its existence. They have to believe that gods do not exist. to be a theist you must believe in the concept and believe they exist. To be an agnostic you have to believe in the concept and be as wishy washy as possible.

I do not believe in the concept of gods. IMO it and all arguments for and against the concept are… well, hell, unbelievable to me. Fun to participate in but, not real either way. Atheism , agnostic and theist are all not real to me.

True, very good point Xunz.

Still, I think there are plenty of things which clearly could not be possible, such as someone saying “Nothing exists”, so I don´t think the term is all that vacuous.

I completely reject the possibility.

Do you accept the possibility of the universe being infinite? If yes, then you should also be able to think is possible that God is infinite, and began our finite world.

Just because the cosmos is infinite doesn’t mean that there ought to be a god or anything.

By looking at old myths where humanity anthropomorphizes god as being human is only enough proof to me of it’s illusion in conjecture.

Human beings have an insane hysterical desire to be acknowledged by a cosmos that is severely indifferent.

I´m not on about ought, but possible.. If you readily accept infinity, why not the possibility of God?

Whoever said the God we speak of in this thread had any hint of human in “Him”?

I couldn´t agree more. I don´t think there´s any ethical, supernatural or whatever else aspect of the universe.

However, who´s to say God can´t be indifferent to us?!