Easy steps to Improve Your Thinking #1

Yeah, the map

Ahem.

Since no one else said it: That would be great if our brains were unilateral thought processes operating in the mode of “We start here, we end there” rather than the “and…and…and…” mode it actually operates in. A map was just mentioned: indeed the construct of human knowledge is a cartography, not a tree.

A 3 dimensional cartography, I would think.

I would agree with you.

Where did all that come from?

The title to this thread is misleading in that it implies some sort of ‘how-to’ exercise that isn’t there. Okay–to improve your thinking, you have to improve your focus. Now, how does one go about improving focus–ignoring the ambient, background ‘noise’ in your mind? A lot of people now use background music. They’ve learned to take the wandering portion of their mind and use it to blot out their mental ‘noise’ in order to use the filtered portion of their minds to ‘focus’ on the task at hand. That’s why so many parents have wondered how their kids can study with “all that ‘racket’ going on.”

The question then becomes, “How do you improve your focus in order to improve your thinking?” I don’t think there’s a single, all-inclusive answer. Everyone has their own individual way of filtering out the unessential background ‘noise’ in order to concentrate on what’s more important to them at the time. The ‘problem’ is one of recognizing the existence of the background noise and finding the best way for you to filter it out–if you want to filter it out. I believe there are people who use free-floating thought to arrive at answers they may never have realized but for those thoughts. Why tune out the background if the background noise can be used?

These are, of course, only my thoughts which have come to me through a partially filtered mental process.

Can you cite some reliable study on that, because I find it to be absolutely false. “Background music” (a concept I think should be removed from existence…I mean, seriously. Do you have background epic poetry? Background Sistine Chapels?) is employed to render boring, repetitive tasks more palatable–not to improve focus but to dull it. Again, I’m going to need a reliable study to consider that statement anything more than a prevarication.

I think you did what so many of us do, MiaC–you stopped reading and started reacting when you hit on something with which you disagree and, in so doing, never read my final disclaimer:

Sure, background music can be used to help make a boring, repetitive job more palatable–but, to me, it can also be used to improve focus. You’ve shown one example of how mental ‘background noise’ can side-track focus when you wrote your last post. To try to give you another example, what are you thinking of now? How much of your free-floating thought is focused on my post and how much is focused on how you plan, if you plan to do so, to respond to my post? How much of your mind has wandering thoughts about things that have nothing to do with this thread?

If you’re honest with yourself, I think you’ll come up with several levels of unfiltered thought that keep you from focusing on only one predominant thought; however, if you want test results from a reliable study, first ask what the study is supposed to show-- introduced background noise used as a means of making boring jobs more palatable, filtering out mental background ‘noise’ through the use of introduced background noise, or free-floating, ambient, mental background ‘noise’ common in human thought?

Oh, btw, I had a professor of Old English, who, when he was ill, would ensconce himself in his recliner chair and recite the Medieval poem, Pearl, in its original language in order to take his mind off his illness. Who’s to say what people use to filter out unnecessary thoughts in order to focus on one?

Indeed I did miss the disclaimer. However, I feel my objection remains pertinent.

But that’s just it; your “background” processes continue to run regardless, so in effect, you’re simply playing a shell game.

What if we refer to personal experience? I found that my ability to produce piecework in AutoCAD swiftly and efficiently was observably attenuated while listening to music, most significantly regarding music with lyrics. To the former bit, I have not anywhere denied “unfiltered thought” existing, nor have I denied the distracting nature therein.

I’m sure you see how this is precisely what I suggested: diluting focus. The intention is not to focus but to not focus.

MisC–I think we’re actually thinking and talking along the same lines. We all have mental background ‘noise’ that keeps us from focusing 100% on the problem at hand. My suggestion was simply that the title of the thread was misleading–there are no easy steps to improve your thinking and there is no single answer to how to improve one’s focus. You, and lot’s of other people, use music. That doesn’t mean the background noise is completely gone. It isn’t. It’s just that, by introducing background noise of your own choosing, you’ve shifted your mind processes somehow.

Is this “diluting” focus? Is this “playing a shell game?” It could be. No matter what, humans have the ability to shift focus from free floating, ambient thoughts, thereby sharpening focus on the thought that’s needed at the time.

This is the sort of mental gymnastics that fascinates me. Is this one of the human attributes that sets us apart from other animals? Do we need to learn other animal languages in order to answer that question? What makes us human is, I believe, philosophical.

…Or philosophy itself. Though I do wonder–what a philosopher the Galapagos Tortoise could be.

I still have some objections but they are far too minor to warrant further pursuit; re the music portion, perhaps a modus vivendi is in order.

Sorry, but I do what I say, usually. And it means I don’t pay lots of attention to something I’m not interested.

On the other hand, when/if I focus, I usually tale enough time and pay full attention because of the interest/desire.
So, my time/energy is spent in efficient and concentrated manner on the matters of interest/importance (to me), and it tends to yield better result in terms of comprehension/discovery, and moreover, the satisfaction.

wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Map_and_territory

I prefer to take everything as information, without the presumption that there is “reality”, “truth”, or “territory”, and so on, because this kind of presumption tends to put us and hold us in the perspective in which “something absolutely certain” exists.
And I think it’s a wrong kind of presumption (I’m not writing the reasoning for this, here, though).
So, if we want to be less wrong, I think it’s probably better to reduce wrong presumptions like this one.

However, I do feel/think that some of information is more/less “virtual” than others, for example, and we can classify and separate information according to different criterion.
But I feel/think that these classifications are arbitrary/temporary/hypothetical, just like any division/separation, too.

Anyway, if you are interested in lesswrong.org, why don’t you make a thread about it?
Thinking about what you are interested is one of easy way to focus better (and in satisfying manner).

We can think with awareness and determination if we wanted and if we are adequately aware/trained.
I do agree that lots us us are not so aware and not well trained at ll, though.
This is why I wrote the OP for someone who is interested in less foggy and more satisfying way of thinking. This thread isn’t for someone who thinks s/he can already think, adequately, to her/his satisfaction.

Also, “cartography” and “tree” go together, most probably, depending on exact definitions/focuses you are having with these words.

You didn’t have to ask this if you could follow my focuses.
You are not following them, currently.

If you really want to understand what I’m saying, I’d suggest starting all over from the scratch, without the presumption (and especially the certainty) that you know what I’m talking about.

Perhaps you’re the one who should start over. If you don’t know what this means…

…then I can’t help you.

I have no such certainty. I was trying to have a conversation.

Well, it’s there in the OP for someone who can read:

[b]

  • List up your interests/desires.

  • List up what you tend to think about.

  • List up things you like and you don’t like.

  • Try to be more precise about each items.

  • Think about the relations and differences of each items.

  • Draw sketches, diagrams to visualize them.

  • Try to focus more in the area you don’t like to focus, if you can.

  • Do not overlook subtle/slight senses of discomfort, uneasiness, contradiction, etc, as they can be the sign post of hidden treasure for our personal evolution.

  • Dig and investigate preferences and presumptions in detail, as they are the launch pad (and the restraining devices) of our focuses.

In actual thought process:

  • Stop the thought stream, rewind if needed, to (re)identify the clear focus you had so that you can regain perspective awareness, as soon as you feel confused, lost, unclear.
  • Type your thought, take a note, to (re)trace and reevaluate your thought stream and notice where you had (and you lost) the perspective awareness.
  • Verify the perimeter/criterion of the focus of each perspective segment.
    [/b]

There would be less of background noise with better focusing.
And thinking about something interesting (for you) helps this, for example.
The suggestions I made would help to focus better, as well, if actually take enough time and practice them.

When I was young, I’ve noticed that my (potentially) logical part of mind worked better when I used motor control part of mind by tensing up some muscles or by manipulating something (pencil, eraser, etc).
I guess it’s a bit similar to using up the emotional energy with music.

However, I now think that it’s not really desirable to do unrelated things while we think.
Instead, we can use the emotional (and maybe sensory) attention together with mental attention by thinking what we desire/like.
In this way, emotional and sensory mind is helping the focuses of (potentially) logical and reasoning mind.

I’ve already listed up some methods that work.
Some are used in job/professional training and others in meditation (and more or less esoteric training).

As I said, we won’t have lots of background noise when we are fully engaged in something interesting.
Most of us should have enough memories of activity (playing, hobby, whatever) we did with full attention, because we liked it or because of the desires/interests.

In your case, you were very well focused about that antique elevator in Germany, for example.
You had full attention, I’d say, when you were thinking about it, actually looking at it, explaining/writing about it. I could feel your interest and attention from what you wrote.

There are different kind of background noise at different level, I’d say.
There are emotional (and sensory) focuses that can confuse mental awareness/focuses.
And there are conscious and subconscious and unaligned mental focuses (again, often coming from emotional/sensory triggers).

Using the resources/energy/awareness of different part of our information processing system in well aligned/unified manner is one way of acting/thinking in efficient and satisfying manner.

If you are not sure about what I’m saying, you can ask.
You didn’t ask me much to verify if your understandings/guesses fit what I was saying, in this thread.

To improve and clarify the communication, you can write what you think you’ve understood, and also what you are having problem understanding.
This way, I can confirm if your focuses seem to fit mine, and then give more information for what you don’t understand.

I’ll get back to you with some studies. Only with Mozart though…

Again, I take this as an admission that you haven’t focused (and thus have no idea about) what is going on in the beauty thread. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that. It just makes your derogatory claims about it fairly unacceptable. I think it’s important to clarify that.