As you all know I’ve asked questions about nothing that weren’t at all nothing. I’ve tried to put the self (something) in nothing, and let me say, if there was a self, it woudn’t be nothing.
I guess what I’m trying to say is… there cannot be something (self…)in nothing… there cannot be properties (immortality, indestructibility…) in nothing…
search around in the threads I gave nothing the properties of immortality and indestructibility along with having a self. I formally abdicate.
So, are you saying that ‘nothing’ CAN be destroyed?
Are you saying that ‘nothing’ begins and ends?
Are you saying that ‘nothing’ has the property of selflessness?
Are you saying that ‘nothing’ has the property of propertylessness?
Saying that ‘nothing’ has no properties, is akin to saying that ‘nothing’ does not have the property of transiency, meaning it is eternal. Basically, ALL negatives apply to it, such as immortality and indestructibility.
And so do the negatives of those negatives, ad infinitum. (Not mortal, not immortal, not not immortal)It totally “transcends” the barriers of logic.
The thing is, NOTHING we say about nothing is true or false, because only things with properties have truth-values…or ANY values for that matter.
No matter what we say about it though, is self refuting, because even defining it in the negative is to give it a negative value. ‘nothing’ means something different than ‘something’. Yet where does it derive its meaning from?
“True” nothingness is only “understood” when the mind is made completely blank. Advaitins try and trigger that stateless mental state.
Koan’s are also designed for that reason. To break the mind out of the limitations of logic.
I am sorry if my words create a bleak reaction.
They are nothing but my experience.
What I have said seems very apparent to me.
Personally, nothingness is a topic that I greatly enjoy. I would be pleased if it continues to be a popular subject.
If you could end it though, by revealing the truth about the matter, that would also be cool.
My stance is, again, that nothingness is not something that can be understood with language. All language is self-refuting in the end.
Its a word that hints at the absolute. Silence, rather than talk, is a better way to “express” it.