Here is a question for anyone who believes in the existence of Hell…

(Note: I asked the following question about 6 years ago over on the PN forum, but I figured I’d dust it off and ask it here.)

The question is primarily based on the Christian (and Muslim) belief that many (indeed, most) humans are going to end up in a literal hell of eternal torture and suffering after death.

With that in mind, the question is: Would you, Christian or Muslim,…

(or anyone else who believes in the existence of the heaven/hell scenario)

…be willing to relinquish your eternal life of bliss in heaven if - by reason of some kind of divine law - it would extricate a loved one from an eternity of torture in hell?

In other words,…

(at least in terms of this hypothetical situation)

…if you understood that your sacrifice would forever erase you and your loved one from the “Book of Life,” would you be willing to do that if it would end the eternal suffering of someone dear to you?

And to extend the question a little further: would you do it for a stranger?

What makes you think this isn’t hell?

2 Likes

That’s a fecking big question.

So do you mean choose the void for both of you, or enjoy paradise while a loved one suffers?

How could you enjoy paradise if you knew a loved one was suffering?

Off to the void for me, unless I’m the one going to hell, then I hope to fuck the other loved one chooses the void.

What does this mean?
Trading places? Obliterating my own soul? Remaining alive perpetually in this purgatory?

If its obliteration, i would think about it. The other two options have very far reaching consequences for me to just blurt out an answer, but in all honesty, this question has no merit, since there is no way for you to save or redeem anyone else.

Such a redeemed soul would break divine law.
A soul that sinned and that should be in hell, is now what? Going to heaven? Thats not how this works.

There is a reason why no amount of holy scripture, love, care, theism, church going, grooming, whatever will mean that someone goes to heaven, and thats because the qualities needed to do so have to be internal and based on one’s own core values.
Thats the difference between (in example) following the 10 commandments and having internalized the 10 commandments.

There is in no way, shape or form a gap and cheap backdoor in the design of this universe that would allow you to trade around souls.
This is why i turned my back on this entire cesspit in the first place.
Whats the point of a shared existence in which you can never save anyone else but yourself?

The design and pattern of this tapestry folds back onto itself.

Yep, it is a huge question, especially for those who believe in the generally accepted concept of Heaven and Hell as proposed by the Abrahamic religions.

So do you mean choose the void for both of you, or enjoy paradise while a loved one suffers?

Yes, that’s the dilemma that the question poses to Christians and Muslims (or, again, to anyone who is somehow able to justify the existence of a dimension of eternal torture).

How could you enjoy paradise if you knew a loved one was suffering?

That’s the core point of the question!

But don’t ask me, ask a Christian or a Muslim,…

…and if any of them say no, they would not relinquish heaven to save a loved one (or even a stranger) from eternal torture,…

…then I think it would be fair to ask them why they think they even deserve a spot in heaven to begin with?

And if the Christian says it’s because they accepted Jesus as their personal savior,…

…then have them explain the rationale behind the need for a “savior” to save them from the eternal torturing that he (the savior) is personally going to do to them if they ignore his offer to save them from him torturing them. ← (Make that make sense.) :roll:

Off to the void for me, unless I’m the one going to hell, then I hope to fuck the other loved one chooses the void.

Thank you, niallm, for giving what you and I both know is the correct answer.

1 Like

No.

il_Nulla wrote:

Obliterating my own soul?

Yes → to save a loved one from a literal eternity of unimaginable pain and suffering.

il_Nulla wrote:

Remaining alive perpetually in this purgatory?

In what “purgatory” are you referring to?

il_Nulla wrote:

If its obliteration, i would think about it.

Really? You need to “…think about…” performing an act that would save a loved one from being tortured for eternity?

il_Nulla wrote:

The other two options have very far reaching consequences for me to just blurt out an answer, but in all honesty, this question has no merit, since there is no way for you to save or redeem anyone else.

What is it with you people who cannot get into the spirit of a “thought experiment” which clearly stated…

seeds wrote:

“…if - by reason of some kind of divine law - it would extricate a loved one from an eternity of torture in hell…”

…? - (Note the presence of that initial “IF” in that prefacing sentence.)

il_Nulla wrote:

Such a redeemed soul would break divine law.

Not in the case of this, again, “thought experiment.”

il_Nulla wrote:

A soul that sinned and that should be in hell, is now what? Going to heaven? Thats not how this works.

Good grief, again, this is just a speculative, philosophical “THOUGHT EXPERIMENT” in which it is okay to imagine that you and your loved one (by your sacrificial act) are completely erased from the “Book of Life.”

Furthermore, are you talking about the billions of humans who “…should be in hell…” for committing the unforgivable sin of (as I pointed out to naillm),…

seeds wrote:

…not accepting Jesus as their personal savior to save them from the eternal torturing that he (Jesus) is personally going to do to them because they ignored his offer to save them from his personal decision to torture them…

…because of what two mythological idiots did at the behest of a “talking snake” in a mythical garden called Eden?

il_Nulla wrote:

There is a reason why no amount of holy scripture, love, care, theism, church going, grooming, whatever will mean that someone goes to heaven, and thats because the qualities needed to do so have to be internal and based on one’s own core values.

Do you mean like the moral qualities missing from a person who says they would need to spend some unspecified amount of time “…thinking about…” the consequences of performing an act that would save a loved one…

(such as a grandpa or a grandma, or a mom or a dad, or a sister or a brother, or a wife or a husband, or your very own children, or a best friend, etc., etc.)

…from an eternity of torture?

il_Nulla wrote:

Thats the difference between (in example) following the 10 commandments and having internalized the 10 commandments.

There is in no way, shape or form a gap and cheap backdoor in the design of this universe that would allow you to trade around souls.

How about “internalizing” the Christian message and spirit and be willing to sacrifice one’s own life in order to save another, just as Jesus allegedly did?

Though it can be argued that neither God (the Father) nor Jesus (the Son) actually “sacrificed” anything,..

…for they both knew that, in the end, Jesus would still be alive in a higher context of reality.

1 Like

You no longer exist and they don’t exist: is that the correct interpretation?

Yes, to a loved one. No, to a stranger.

I’m not saying one shouldn’t, but I doubt I would save the stranger. Unless Heaven is really boring.

Eternal Hell, what an awful idea. Whoever thought of it should be spanked for…

as long as it takes for them to think it might be forever, then let them go their way.

Punishment is revenge via hate. Politicalized it becomes crime and their version of justice. God with politics and metaphysics. Hell on earth.

That’s certainly an aspect of it, but on some level if must torture anyone who believes it is possible. Even Christians or Muslims who may get off thinking of the punishment of non-believers or bad people, must worry. The religions themselves make it clear that you may not be correct about your own self-assessment of ‘goodness’ and who can’t find reasons to doubt that? This may be suppressed from consciousness, but, it must be roiling around somewhere in the unconscious.

Forever experiencing agony. Forever. That idea has to burn a hole in anyone who hears it.

Hell is mothered into existence by infinite hate. Hate is lust-revenge. A hungry desire. Dwelling on pain. Negativity.

Punishment (technically) is a consequential strategy and outcome of an act or acts that transgress law, rules, norms and contracts. Its supposed strategic efficacy is to reduce the frequency of, and/or recidivism to, said behaviour/act(s). It seldom works

Exactly. God is considered a loving being then a God of punishment. I find this disturbing.

Yes, that’s the correct interpretation.

greenfuse wrote:

Yes, to a loved one. No, to a stranger.

Well, considering the possibility that you might not actually have any loved ones who would be willing to give up heaven to save you,…

(not to mention the real possibility that all of your loved ones have also been condemned to eternal torture)

…then you’d better hope that everyone who considers you to be a “stranger,” doesn’t feel the same way as you do.

Anyway, the thought experiment faces another problem in that according to what the Christian dogma implies, there would not be nearly enough souls in heaven to save (in an even, one-for-one trade off) the vast number of souls who are writhing in agony in the fires of Hell.

greenfuse wrote:

I’m not saying one shouldn’t, but I doubt I would save the stranger. Unless Heaven is really boring.

So then, are you suggesting that if you knew that in a house a few doors down from you, a child (who was a “stranger” to you) was being savagely tortured by a madman, you would have to be bored to do anything about it?

That’s like game theory. And I don’t have to hope, there is no Hell. I’m giving an honest answer which I am not presenting as the right answer, but note your argument: you are arguing in terms of self-interest or pointing out a threat. Not especially morality driven motivation.

Which minimizes the previous arguments.

I can’t even see where the question comes up. I can call the police. If I know the madman I might consider that me and a baseball bat can fix it. I could call a bunch of friends if for some reason there are no police. It’s not a parallel situation.

Have you given all the money you possibly could to feed the poor in the 3rd world? Perhaps you have a few devices like whatever you wrote this on that you could pawn and send the money to a good charity feeding them.

In the thought experiment I am in Heaven, presumably with people I love, at least now, once there. Yup, I need a reason to give that up. If it’s boring, well, an eternity of boredom is Hell. If it’s lovely then, yes, it’d be hard to give up. But I’ve already had conversations with God about this kind of thing, the problems with how things seem at the very least. I’d be speaking my mind ‘up there’ also if there was in fact a Hell. Whose responsibility is the Heaven and Hell set-up? Sacrifice to be good comes right out of the same Abrahamic massive guilt trip, threat, break the spirit idiocy as Hell. Our role model Jesus and his suffering taking away our sins because his madman Father has a Hell. So, we walk around with sacrifice and service (a class metaphor) and submission (how to appease dangerous power) and surrender (what we do when we lose a war) as guiding metaphors for Goodness, spirituality and religion. Yech!

An who are those metaphors benefitting?

And there are real answers to that. It’s not no one.

1 Like

You don’t need to die to be in hell.

There are many facets of hell here on earth for the living.

:clown_face:

1 Like

Get with the program here, greenfuse. Of course there’s no Hell.

For the umpteenth time, the OP is a “thought experiment” directed at the Christians and Muslims (and whoever else) who believe such a place exists and that so-called “sinners” will be sent there for an eternity of deserved and justifiable torture.

The point is that if you are a rational thinker then the OP is not meant for you.

greenfuse wrote:

I’m giving an honest answer which I am not presenting as the right answer, but note your argument: you are arguing in terms of self-interest or pointing out a threat. Not especially morality driven motivation.

Nonsense!

The argument is thoroughly powered by a morality driven motivation.

I mean, how much more “immoral” can the notion of eternal torture be?

seeds wrote:

Anyway, the thought experiment faces another problem in that according to what the Christian dogma implies, there would not be nearly enough souls in heaven to save (in an even, one-for-one trade off) the vast number of souls who are writhing in agony in the fires of Hell.

greenfuse wrote:

Which minimizes the previous arguments.

No kidding?

Pointing out information that I’m already aware of doesn’t change the fact that you seem to be going out of your way to miss the point of the, again, “thought experiment” that is meant for the Christians and Muslims who haven’t given much thought to what it is that they believe.

seeds wrote:

So then, are you suggesting that if you knew that in a house a few doors down from you, a child (who was a “stranger” to you) was being savagely tortured by a madman, you would have to be bored to do anything about it?

greenfuse wrote:

I can’t even see where the question comes up.

It comes up because you implied that existence in Heaven would have to be “boring” (as in not worth holding onto) before you might consider saving a stranger from eternal torture - as per the conditions laid out in my thought experiment.

greenfuse wrote:

I can call the police. If I know the madman I might consider that me and a baseball bat can fix it. I could call a bunch of friends if for some reason there are no police. It’s not a parallel situation.

Again, greenfuse, you need to get into your head that this, again, “thought experiment” is not meant for a rational thinker such as yourself.

greenfuse wrote:

Have you given all the money you possibly could to feed the poor in the 3rd world? Perhaps you have a few devices like whatever you wrote this on that you could pawn and send the money to a good charity feeding them.

When it comes to charity, I’m a person who generally goes by what Jesus allegedly stated in the Sermon on the Mount,…

“But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing.” - Matthew 6:3

So I don’t like talking about it.

But if it might inspire your own giving, I have (since the 70s) been supporting (sponsoring) children in Africa and, especially, Bangladesh through an organization called “World Vision International,” and more recently “The World Food Program.”

I can’t do as much as I wish I could, but I do the best I can with what I have to work with.

Needless to say, they can always use some fresh donors, so, by all means, greenfuse, join me and do whatever you can do to combat world poverty,…

…and then maybe - in a year or two from now - I’ll put you on the spot* by asking you a highly personal question about what you are doing to help the hungry.

*(I cannot help but feel that that was meant to be a “gotcha” question.)

Sure, I knew that, I thought we’d left the test and you were commenting on my answers. I thought it was ‘feedback’. :grinning_face:

Life

Yes. Believe or not, i think.
I think of many things. Like for instance survivors guilt and whether or not my loved would want to be saved at that cost.

Fine. It was a question that disregards the structure and point of the law, but fine, my answer is above.

No, more like the qualities missing from a person who just does things, without regard for other people’s feelings, including those they supposedly love.

You probably still have no idea what i am talking about so lets turn your question around:
Would you want someone you truly love, to kill themselves just so you could avoid the consequences of your own actions?

I know i wouldnt, but hey, im missing moral qualities so im a bad judge.

You dont seem to understand how thin the line is between absolute selfishness and absolute selflessness. Including in this own question of yours where you get to “yolo” “opt out” of existence with (apparently) zero regard to leaving your loved one behind with existence, loss and guilt.

Even in general, such as in buddhist teachings, the first rule of help is that you never do if its unwanted, cause even selfless help has a cost on the receiver’s side in the form of a taken away opportunity to solve their issue on their own and thus grow.

1 Like

Absolutely. Perhaps you are someone who could not give more. Perhaps you are writing on a work computer, you have a cheap, bought-used mobile or don’t have one, you couldn’t move to a cheaper apartment, you eat very simply, vegetarian and buy rice in bulk (or the like), no car and so on. But even if this is all true, there would be parallels to sacrificing your life for a poor person. Even the abstemious Westerner is still utilizing resources that could be sacrificed, one way or another, to aid strangers.

It seems to me that Jesus meant that one should not give with the intention of bragging and being seen us good. It doesn’t mean when asked one should hide it. Intent and secondary gain are what one should be careful about. So, I found out that you do give the charity, but not quite the answer. I found out part of what the right hand is doing.

The thought experiment is a kind of gotcha and the feedback seemed like it also. Though it isn’t only that. And after that, I got this question:

It is a question, but it’s a very odd one. Can you see how interpreting what I wrote as if this question makes sense and starting with ‘So, then…’ implying potential logical conclusion is a kind of attack? I mean, it just doesn’t follow. We have a kind of contractual situation where I can offer my continued existence to stop the eternal torture of someone. And in contrast we have a real world situation, where I am not in an eternal state and I have many ways to help the child. Then 'So, then, I might not do anything when a neighbor is torturing a child if I’m not bored? It’s not in any way a parallel situation. Hm, greenfuse, it seems like given what you said, you’d do nothing about a neighbor if they were torturing a child and you weren’t bored. Huh?? The so, then framing is not justified, even in a question. It is as if I had said I wouldn’t help a stranger who was suffering unless I was bored. Which I did not say.

It doesn’t fit the thought experiment, for the reasons I pointed out. Was it a new thought experiment? You seemed to be addressing me, the one you think is a rational person, about a here on the earth, no beyond the material world situation.

I wouldn’t have responded with a gotcha without that. Your responses seemed to be coming from a holier than thou position. I’m not sure that’s stopped.

And yes, telling me I’d better hope that someone in Heaven would think differently from me if I’m in Hell, is not a moral argument.

And telling me your going to check up on my giving…

So, what I tried to do was see if there is a current way to actually check if you would give up your existence to help a stranger, because it seemed like you thought it was immoral I wouldn’t. So, sure, OK, let’s test.

You give what you can. Well, you could give more, even if you met all the criteria I laid out. You could potentially give in a way that threatened your existence.

My suggestion would be to read back over your responses to me and see if you responded in a charitable way. I’ll leave the thread to the Muslims and Christians who will like everyone else answer honestly. Everyone won’t just give what they can, they will give everything for anyone.

Your question does bring up some interesting ideas.

For one thing, what is the nature or ethical reality of doing ‘the right thing’? Let’s say we all agree that X is good and that it would be right to do X. But then someone else says you only believe that because it makes you feel good. You only do good things because it feels good to do it.

If you were to sacrifice yourself to save a loved one, I am sure at least part of the impulse and action of doing the sacrifice would feel good to you. A kind of moral sense of righteousness, a deep emotional experience or presence of value. Even if the sacrifice of oneself involves pain, this good feeling would still be present.

Did Jesus feel some of that good feeling when he died on the cross? He probably did.

But does the presence of feeling good about something mean that is the only reason we are doing it? Of course not.

And in fact the very idea implies a deep reversal and error. Because we do not do things only because they feel good, rather and more often it is the case that something feels good to do precisely because it IS GOOD. Obviously this relationship between what is good and what therefore feels good can be twisted and distorted, for example when it feels good to eat a bunch of candy because historically our species craved easy sugars for energy (but then later we may feel sick from eating too much of it, a natural consequence of not realizing a rational limit to the action).

But back to the topic question… I think there are a lot of people who would NOT sacrifice themselves to save another person, even someone they love. And I also think there are a lot of people who WOULD sacrifice themselves to save another person, especially someone they love. The idea of eternal torture doesn’t even need to be a factor here, that only makes the case more extreme and therefore trying to extract an easier answer out of people. But I don’t think that is even needed here.

I have seen different kinds of people and how they operate differently. There are strong emotional tendencies and centers within people and not everyone is operating by the same ones. For example, there exists a very strong impulse and ‘emotional center’ that is based in something like parental care for a child. If this did not exist at least in some of us, parents would not have gone to the great lengths needed to protect and raise their offspring. Protecting and raising kids requires a lot of self-sacrifice. Putting the good of someone else over the good of ourself.

Then again there are plenty of people who cannot or will not do that, because they are not built to endure that kind of discomfort or pain. If putting the good of another person ahead of one’s own good causes extreme discomfort or pain, then they simply will not do it, even if it is their own family member or someone they otherwise love. Some people call this narcissism, I think that is fairly accurate although perhaps aiming to identify more extreme versions.

And the same issue applies even for the narcissist: it feels good for the narcissist to put his own good over that of other people, but does this mean he is only doing it because it feels good? Not necessarily, because it IS GOOD to prioritize what is good for oneself. Just as it also IS GOOD to prioritize the good of another person.

When something is GOOD, then we can say that pursuing or doing that thing is also good. It is good to do good things. This is not a meaningless truism. It is an important point with deep metaphysical and ethical implications, including in the area of responsibility.

At the point where a comparative obtains, i.e., a mutual exclusivity appears between doing what is good for me vs doing what is good for another person… when these two possibilities generate a contradiction or otherwise both cannot be the case at the same time, then we have a true dilemma. On what basis does a person resolve this kind of mutual exclusivity? A default seems to appear on one side of the scale or the other. What is the basis for where that default appears? I think it simply comes down to a lot of pretty basic stuff, including our biology/genes and past experiences that have shaped our psyches and emotions. As well as cultural and social or religious influences and ideas that also shaped us, all leading together with our biology-genetics to determine an outcome of how we will feel and react in the more or less extreme situation of being able to only act in terms of our own good or the good of another person.

That can be resolved by appeal to emotional sublimations, for example the higher emotion of love that will sublimate the feelings of personal discomfort or pain that come along with sacrificing our own good for the sake of doing something good for another person. That is a deeply philosophical resolution within the emotions themselves, but again I am well aware that a lot of people exist for whom such forms of emotional resolution, philosophical or otherwise, are simply not possible.

2 Likes