Get with the program here, greenfuse. Of course there’s no Hell.
For the umpteenth time, the OP is a “thought experiment” directed at the Christians and Muslims (and whoever else) who believe such a place exists and that so-called “sinners” will be sent there for an eternity of deserved and justifiable torture.
The point is that if you are a rational thinker then the OP is not meant for you.
greenfuse wrote:
I’m giving an honest answer which I am not presenting as the right answer, but note your argument: you are arguing in terms of self-interest or pointing out a threat. Not especially morality driven motivation.
Nonsense!
The argument is thoroughly powered by a morality driven motivation.
I mean, how much more “immoral” can the notion of eternal torture be?
seeds wrote:
Anyway, the thought experiment faces another problem in that according to what the Christian dogma implies, there would not be nearly enough souls in heaven to save (in an even, one-for-one trade off) the vast number of souls who are writhing in agony in the fires of Hell.
greenfuse wrote:
Which minimizes the previous arguments.
No kidding?
Pointing out information that I’m already aware of doesn’t change the fact that you seem to be going out of your way to miss the point of the, again, “thought experiment” that is meant for the Christians and Muslims who haven’t given much thought to what it is that they believe.
seeds wrote:
So then, are you suggesting that if you knew that in a house a few doors down from you, a child (who was a “stranger” to you) was being savagely tortured by a madman, you would have to be bored to do anything about it?
greenfuse wrote:
I can’t even see where the question comes up.
It comes up because you implied that existence in Heaven would have to be “boring” (as in not worth holding onto) before you might consider saving a stranger from eternal torture - as per the conditions laid out in my thought experiment.
greenfuse wrote:
I can call the police. If I know the madman I might consider that me and a baseball bat can fix it. I could call a bunch of friends if for some reason there are no police. It’s not a parallel situation.
Again, greenfuse, you need to get into your head that this, again, “thought experiment” is not meant for a rational thinker such as yourself.
greenfuse wrote:
Have you given all the money you possibly could to feed the poor in the 3rd world? Perhaps you have a few devices like whatever you wrote this on that you could pawn and send the money to a good charity feeding them.
When it comes to charity, I’m a person who generally goes by what Jesus allegedly stated in the Sermon on the Mount,…
“But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing.” - Matthew 6:3
So I don’t like talking about it.
But if it might inspire your own giving, I have (since the 70s) been supporting (sponsoring) children in Africa and, especially, Bangladesh through an organization called “World Vision International,” and more recently “The World Food Program.”
I can’t do as much as I wish I could, but I do the best I can with what I have to work with.
Needless to say, they can always use some fresh donors, so, by all means, greenfuse, join me and do whatever you can do to combat world poverty,…
…and then maybe - in a year or two from now - I’ll put you on the spot* by asking you a highly personal question about what you are doing to help the hungry.
*(I cannot help but feel that that was meant to be a “gotcha” question.)