I used dog training because children can’t discipline their dolls or toys. They can’t babysit their siblings too until they are of a certain age.
But, yes, a hobby can be helpful but still might be limited if the child is young. But sometimes children or adults may think that finger painting is a hobby when some might consider play. There needs to be structure and rules.
But I agree that having something to pursue, such as a hobby is one choice only. Giving children chores is another, but the extent of chores is limited by the age of the child.
The idea of having a dog was to “show” children discipline in action but not directed at them. Dog training is about discipline on a small scale, basically.
And many, many parents do not discipline their children enough. They probably don’t have any clue either on how to train their dog. And sometimes when people learn that their pet is much happier being trained and exercised (like keeping kids busy with activities) then they have all that they (dog) need.
Actually dog training says discipline, exercise and affection for your dog are all of its basic needs. Children need the same thing. The exercise can also be play or activities (hobbies) which is also how you can bond emotionally with your child, when engaged in fun activities.
Children get bored because their parents don’t spend enough time with them, helping them be creative and helping them learn. Dogs get restless because they don’t get exercised enough. Dogs will misbehave because they don’t know the rules. Same thing with kids.
You can visit someone at their home and watch their dog to get a sense about what kind of parent they might be. Obviously there are differences between training a dog and raising a child; but so many people don’t get the discipline part of the dog ownership equation. Those same people will probably have bratty kids too.
But there can be other ways of engaging children in activities where they learn responsibility and “consequences” and enforcing the rules. It can be hard to think up all the ways of teaching these things with young children because the are so immature and learning basic stuff. Dog training was an easy and obvious example to use. Dog training is an excellent example of discipline in action on a small scale.
That mother of the 5YO is not being consistent. Consistency is about being a good disciplinerian. Parenting is a tough job that needs people who are capable of being tough when it comes to the rules. Parents will give their gives too much affection out of guilt for working long hours sometimes. Dog owners give their pets too much affection and the dog is the leader of the pack (the dog thinks that way and gets territorial). Having a pet also teaches the parent the importance of discipline.