"My Generation", attempt two

[b][i]“My” Generation

Rough Draft[/b]

Don’t talk of dust and roses –
Or should we powder our noses?
Don’t live for last year’s capers:
Oh, give me steel, give me steel, give me pulses unreal…[/i]

  • David Bowie, “Big Brother”

[b]I.[/b]

We live in frightening times: but all times are equally frightful, particularly to those who lack a future against which their own can be contrasted. Apocalypticism is not the defining characteristic of this or any age, but is rather the perennial philosophy of those who grow weary of the endless Now and seek out respite in the past (or in the future; it is all one).

Romanticism is the name of this belief in the invaluability of the present. If I may speak plainly, I have observed that ours, or, at least, mine, numbers among the most romantic of ages. It is one of the most pietous, most patriotic, and certainly the most cantankerously petty generations to have been spawned in quite some time; also, the most pretentious and pathetic - and lacking in laughter. Everywhere one looks one happens to set one’s eyes upon a teenager dressed up like a black-clad little priest, mouthing belief in moralistic flights of fancy and all the while indulging in little acts of hypocrisy for the thrill that comes with the violation of boundaries and borders of one’s own demarcation. Today one no longer crosses the line: one simply crosses the back of one’s hand like a little black stigmata and moves the line.

I am a man out of time. Neither boy nor adult - each has been denied to me, for good reason - I nevertheless know when I am. I have tested the spirit of the age (using methods both Pauline and Hegelian in origin) and have found it wanting. A great exorcism, then, is in order; a tremendous putting-out of the stagnant zeitgeist which has thickened so as to make it impossible to breathe cleanly today.

“But,” you will ask, “are you yourself not just as impassioned, just as inflammatory, and even just ask weak as those whom you profess such hatred for? Do you speak out of revenge, as a lover spurned? Or perhaps, as a poor social invalid, unwilling or unable to recognize the shifting winds of public sentiment?”

If so accused, I could hardly deny either charge. I am guilty of each; both as one who could not - ‘compete’ here would not at all be accurate; with me there is only subterfuge - for the affections of a woman, and one who could not, and, above all, would not, permit the effervescent flux of public opinion to impede upon my own sense of self-possession. Moreover, I suspect that these two are quite as one in our current climate. When I speak, therefore, it is with the forked tongue of the hypocrite and liar: but also with the words of the accultured one who knows precisely what leitmotives have accrued themselves to his character and who has developed an ear to listen for when they make themselves heard.

Make no mistake, dear reader: there is no rancor, no overbearing malice in me. Neither is there any prejudice which I do not admit to with a smile. For, to be sure, I love even my displeasures: they bring such laughter, out of both cruelty (towards myself and towards the rest) and – pity? --, that I cannot but help be well-disposed towards them. I have no ‘social agenda’ to advance; rather that I could advance upon all of them–!

And so it is not out of an offended morality which I write (and those who know me well understand just what I lack in this regard), but out of taste, which has always taken precedence over the former in all such, to turn a phrase which is not mine, ‘untimely ones’. For in this infinite night of the aesthetic, what room is there for morality?

No. I condemn nothing, not even myself; and, though there be much self-pruning and purging in these pages, this essay should not, in any way, to be taken as a sermon against the fashion of the age. To the contrary: it is critique in the highest sense, the critique of the metaphysician who no longer believes but continues to find it clever to wear the mask of God, from time to time. Accordingly I shall take up the watch from the highest peaks; this means, to wit, looking down, from the tip of one’s nose, where it is required.

And such a God is required: for it is the Christly instinct against which I wage my war war, against the victim’s instinct - and especially modern self-victimization (as ecstatic resignationism). For a task such as this it is better by far to be a swordsman, to know how to parry and riposte; but insofar as I am not a swordsman I ought instead to be a tank commander. For where the blade fails, the division surely triumphs in the end.

II.

Psychologically considered, this question is of paramount importance, especially to myself: is this generation merely a great many pierced and posed Young Werthers, lured into yet one more futile generational revolt by the silver-lined sturm-clouds of romanticism? Or is there something more, something which might constitute an Event and which at any rate will most certainly be cause for conversation in the coming years and decades?

Firstly, to wit, I do not mean by this query anything of the sort that execrable, unpsychological natures, such as Lee Carroll’s, have in mind when they proceed to “spiritualize” the current generational situation in neo-pagan terms. For that movement, like Wicca and other such Christian apostasies, are plagued by precisely the same metaphysical prejudices they mean to oppose (incarnation; “sin” and “guilt”; transcendentality; etc.) and are therefore unworthy of serious consideration. That they believe in their own doctrines does not bode well for their sense of taste. This is not the Age of Aquarius.

And neither do I mean in any sense to pass objective judgment over the phenomenon I observe. For I owe a profound debt, not to psychiatry, which concerns itself only with the physiology and bio-chemical constitution of the brain and which deems itself fit to codify into medical practice certain normative ethical judgments, but to philosophical psychology; and, in particular, to two psychologists hitherto unparalleled in the history of the field: Arthur Schopenhauer and Friedrich Nietzsche, without whom I would have been unable to judge my observations in accordance with established philosophical conceptions. Thus, when I pass ethical evaluations, it is purely as a phenomenological exercise of self-discovery: more of the following is of me, of my own character, than of any “objective” undertaking.

With this aside, let us articulate the question thusly: what is the meaning and “metaphysical” character of certain the emotional and ideological conceptions currently in currency amongst individuals of my generation? Wither do they come? What purpose do they serve? And, above all, what is the cost of their value?

III.

We Hessians, as “natural men” who “receiveth not the teachings of the Spirit”, understand the passions well enough - which means understanding and bearing the burden of the war against morality (for morality is precisely the opposite of passion, that which deadens). As contrarians by nature, we would be offended if told that we possessed within ourselves immortal souls; this would mean being unable to contradict ourselves - or to lose ourselves, as men who live in their bowels are occasionally wont to do.

But we have long been asleep, and do not know our way. Everything today seems disoriented, confused: was it such when we laid down to rest? What is it about modernity, about modern “culture”, which so arouses our intuitive ire? For this age is, recent political developments notwithstanding - and these, too, shall surely pass - the most highly educated, most humane, least oppressed and oppressive and most superficially godless which has existed or which could yet have existed in the course of human history. By all rights, we ought to be satisfied with it –

Ought to be and are not. For we alone have nostrils delicate enough to sense and to distinguish between the apparent and the merely apparently apparent, between superficiality and depth. Beneath the atheistic veneer this age likes so well to adopt lurks a sublimated Christianity of monstrous proportions; a veritable resurrection of God.

This will not be immediately apparent to those spiritual deformities who have had the misfortune of being born without inner sensery-organs. That I even have an audience today seems to put this assertion to the lie. However, as I shall here demonstrate, the ideologies which have gained possession - in every sense of the term - of my generation are replete with Christian and Christly concepts: indeed, one might well say that this is the most devout generation in a century.

Let us consider, for instance, egoism, that young offspring of liberal individualism which is embarrassed by its parent and wants to keep it out of sight of its friends. That this concept is currently fashionable is undeniable; that it is also in every way Christian is equally apparent. For consider precisely what is contained in this proposition: “I am”. Is there not recourse here to a spiritual notion of “self” as unified, whole, inassimilable and inviolable? And is there not also an implicit denial of the body and its inner movements as the measure of man? This is not to suggest that egoism itself is invaluable in certain persons worthy of assuming this belief; but there is no place for it within an immoralistic worldview.

A related - and all too moralistic - concept is to be found in the “straight-edge” ideology so very current amongst this generation. Implicit in this ideo-theology is, once more, that of soul: under this worldview one possesses a spirit bordered on all sides by flesh (mere flesh; weak flesh); it is such that one cannot abide even the smell of tobacco for fear of being “tainted”, of being violated. That I have been approached several times at various venues by individuals possessed of this ideology in mind and the evangelical spirit in heart belies a basic tendency innate within this ideology to reproduce itself, as if it cannot not abide the loneliness of the solitary life and desires company. From whence does this particular belief stem? Firstly, from a fear of mortality; also from the spiritual concept “soul”; and, not lastly, a fear of physiological degeneration on the part of the adherent, as a reaction against the self-destructive tendencies which today have been widely popularized by the very media outlets this sect tends to employ. That this does nothing more than reinforce soul-belief, thereby aggravating the condition it wants to be rid of, is quite apparently lost on the dogmatists of this religion. And it is no surprise that the spiritual forefathers of this movement were Hare Krishnas: Easternism - Schopenhauerianism - is everywhere within this faith, including the cult of the “artistic genius”, which is simply the cult of the world-redeemer once removed.

Perhaps more gloomily, there is the matter of the current trend of self-mutilation and scarification which has today grown into a half-cliche and which tomorrow will be fodder for tabloids and mid-afternoon television programming. However much this tendency might frighten petit-bourgeois housewives, there is nothing either new or radical in this: we have it, in an ideologically-developed form, in the abandoned Catholic doctrine of “mortification of the flesh” (“emo” – another name for “Franciscan”).

In each of these instances one comprehends something enlightening: a basic disgust of and torment by the flesh, by the encroachment of pain and pleasure and especially desire. How is it that such an anxiety might have arisen, and what methods has it utilized to insinuate itself within a society so very nearly rid of religious concepts and conceptualizations not two decades before?

[b]IV.[/b]

Historically speaking (take heed! when one speaks of ‘history’ one speaks with seriousness itself: for ‘history’ is a laughing matter), our modern culture constitutes a regressus to the worst excesses of the Black Death. Our means have increased in accordance with our sciences - the syringe has replaced the flail, for instance - but our ends remain every bit the same: chiefly, self-abnegation in favor of an abandoned and abandoning God, as a means to reclaim some semblance of spiritual substance long since vanished.

For it is, as ever, the martyr’s instinct which rises to the fore of cultural activity during periods of moral and religious unrest. Nietzsche writes thusly in his Nachlass:

"Morality guarded the underprivileged against nihilism by assigning to each an infinite value, a metaphysical value, and by placing each in an order that did not agree with the worldly order of rank and power: it taught resignation, meekness, etc. Supposing that the faith in this morality would perish, then the underprivileged would no longer have their comfort - and they would perish.

This perishing takes the form of self-destruction - the instinctive selection of that which must destroy. Symptoms of this self-destruction of the underprivileged: self-vivisection, poisoning, intoxication, romanticism, above all the instinctive need for actions that turn the powerful into mortal enemies (as it were, one breeds one’s own hangmen); the will to destruction as the will of a still deeper instinct, the instinct of self-destruction, the will for nothingness."

This is the ‘cure’. One must first understand the treatment to glean something of the disease. And what is this disease, this soul-sichness, as it were? Certainly not our age’s imagined ‘moral turpitude’ (this line of reasoning is as diseased as that which it wants to cure, for it draws from the same tainted romantic wellspring; further, all immorality constitutes a cure and a liberation), but a decline of the ecstatic spirit. Or, more accurately, a mutation of the self-same.

For let us ask here: what is ecstasy? Is it not a feeling of delimitation, of ascension, joyful and free? Whatever it is, it most certainly is not the slavish enrapture of the martyr as he flogs the flesh from his back, or that of the pathetic junkie as he presses down on the plunger - the individual under the thrall of enthousiasmos would rather flagellate others than be himself flagellated. This answered, let us ask once more: from where does this degeneration of the ecstatic feeling come?

The answer which almost gives itself, which wants to be given to him with the gall to ask, is soul-belief. For this belief denies to the ecstatic that strange and wondrous ability to take leave of oneself, to dispossess one’s self, which is so necessary to the ecstatic-ritualistic method of induced experience that any effort to engage in such a divine and macabre undertaking is necessarily thwarted by the presence of such a prejudice. So defeated, it is only natural that this premature ecstatic ought to turn to despair as a measure to vindicate his own sense of completeness without which he grows increasingly incapable of suffering life. So completed, it is inevitable that the ecstatic should undergo just such a defeat.

For this is the truth of the matter: the present vogue for self-destruction stems, not from an absence, but from a completeness, from a metaphysical prejudice which has lain hidden for twenty centuries in full view of even the least insightful of observers. This process, which readers of my previous essay will know under the term ‘consanguinity’, constitutes an exchange of ‘essences’, as in, for instance, the ritual of communion, or the Biblical myth of transfiguration; also possession, and, more immediately, the sensation which a tasteful aesthete might feel while under the spell of Wagner’s Der Ring des Nibelungen.

This is more than mere rhapsody, although rhapsody certainly has affinities with the feeling of consanguinity, being itself a minor key of the same basic piece. Quite briefly, it constitutes a tremendous collectivization of the individual; a consumption of the individual; a total and utter leaving-oneself-behind, and a losing oneself. It is madness, to be sure; but even the pious old parishoner who enjoys nothing more than hymn-singing experiences the trembling pleasures which accompany the sweet encroachment of the void.

We must take care here, however, not to interpret this in a Platonic sense, as Nietzsche did in his The Birth of Tragedy (a mistake for which he continued to berate himself for a decade after the publication of that piece). The consanguineous act is not at all an experience of primal unity, either ‘higher’ or ‘carnal’, but rather a disintegration of both into a more basic substratum. For unity requires singularity - and singularity, ‘in-itselfness’, sichness, does not exist, at least for the ecstatic. It in fact cannot exist under such a condition.

Let us consider, for example, the self-consistent logic of religious possession. Regardless of the faith-system underlying such an event, there nevertheless remains in every instantiation of this motif a basic underlying substructure: the individual becomes displaced by the alien spirit, vacating itself (or, conversely, becoming subsumed by the alien spirit; it matters little), and is reduced to nothingness: but a nothingness which nevertheless remains a somethingness- Zerrissenheit, a pulling-apartness and multiplicity. Thus we have, for instance, the case of the Gaderene, whose demons, upon being exorcised, promptly fled from his body into a herd of pigs.

If one could transpose this logic onto an ontological plane one would have grasped the core characteristic of the ecstatic, Bacchanalian experience: Being, viewed ‘from within’, seems to he who reaches this happy plateau a great multiplicity and Becoming. In this state pleasure and pain are themselves one and the same, and equally meaningless; neither pain nor pleasure suffice as an elevator by which one acquires such lofty inner vistas. Unfortunately, this requires feats of the synaptic system not likely executable by nerves roughworn through years of cathode-ray abuse; such states are therefore unattainable for our poor, pale teenaged esotericist, who consoles himself with egoism and other such worthless soul-beliefs: that they are not sufficiently atheistic for such willful exertions is evidence; they retain the Christ-type.

(The animists of Africa do much better than our befuddled friend: by assigning to each degree of intensity an animal fetish, they thereby create a locus of sorts for each individuated state of feeling, subscribing to each a physical totem and thereby permitting easier recourse to memory in attaining any one of them; by the time the teenager learns this method, his feelings have deadened and he becomes satisfied with such imbecilities as statolatry and the national flag.)

What, really, does it require to effect such an inner-transformation? Nothing but courage, the courage to leave one’s self behind, in the sand, buried, forgotten. And courage, to our woe and misfortune, is much lacking in the present generation. In its place they have formulated their credo in a single word: depth. It is a tempting doctrine, one which promises many starry nights, but also a very erroneous one: even the least informed Heraclitean-at-heart knows that the world is shallow; and how could it be otherwise, when music carries us off (in the – spirit --) to such beautiful crevices and recesses of the mind? One either feels fleetly or not at all.

[b]V.[/b]

On a related subject: why is so much of modern music so [b]bad[/b]?

In short - because it no longer moves.

Music is immoral and anti-moral, for it necessitates an inner possession entirely at odds with the liberal-Kantian worldview. Under the influence of masterly musicianship one’s inner being is dissipated, shattered as if under the blow of a hammer, and this vacancy in turn is filled with each new note: every note is in itself a “little soul” of sorts, though not a spiritual entity. One’s highest senses resound with the sound of music; one’s most primal instincts reverberate under it; and all the world grows light by virtue of it. Music is both immanent and depersonalizing: it makes even the thought of death disappear beneath its waves. For this reason it was a matter of policy among the Puritans, for instance, to place under the ban all music not immediately useful for religious worship, where this de-individuating aspect could be harnessed in the service of the Christian faith.

Also, music - really musical music - always requires for itself a purpose, a goal: it is not reflective but active, and it takes as its goal some externality towards which it can be directed. It thereby attains its purpose. Our nihilistic epoch, however, out of fear of purpose, has so thoroughly demotivated music that it is no longer music at all but mere noise: a great many solipsistic wails constitutes the Top 40, and nothing more. (“l’art pour l’art” is a meaningless noise to be abolished.) For our modern, Apollonic culture has created of music a deformity out of its desire to recapture its essence - the cult of beauty and the cult of the individual are quite at peace with the cult of spirit.

Modern “rock” musicians have, for instance, in their desire to make each individual song as personalized (for the sake of essence) and as brief (for the sake of marketability - also for sanity) as possible, drastically reduced the importance of the refrain in the structure of the whole, and have virtually removed the chorus from composition. Does one understand just what the chorus means to music? It is the very beating heart of music; the one connection remaining to modern man to the realm of the Dionysian.

But we have seen this before – in Socrates:

"As it confronts this new Socratic-optimistic stage world, how does the chorus appear now, and indeed the whole musical Dionysian substratum of tragedy? As something accidental, a dispensable vestige of the origin of tragedy; while we have seen that the chorus can be understood only as the cause of tragedy, and of the tragic in general. . . This alteration in the position of the chorus, which Sophocles at any rate recommended by his practice and, according to tradition, even by a treatise, is the first step toward the destruction of the chorus, whose phases follow one another with alarming rapidity in Euripides, Agathon, and the New Comedy. Optimistic dialectic drives music out of tragedy with the scourge of its syllogisms; that is, it destroys the essence of tragedy, which can be interpreted only as a manifestation and projection into images of Dionysian states, as the visible symbolizing of music, as the dream-world of a Dionysian intoxication."

(Nietzsche, The Birth of Tragedy 16)

Thus we have today, for instance, the replacement of the genuine depth of life in music with ennui, mere ennui and anemic guitars which bleed as though from pierced wrists - and wither?

Because ugliness shakes one’s faith in one’s self! One withers under the world’s ugliness, and pines for release from it. And yet no release is possible, save through music. And yet here, too, release becomes a problem, for one is “released” into the world, into the void, into ugliness itself

We need only look at who today makes music to find the culprit in this undermining of the tragic, immersive nature of music: it is my generation. We have, in blatant, arrogant stupidity, presumed our own inner-woes a match for the turmoil of the “outer” world; or, worse yet, have read our “pain” into that world and thereby have devalued it. Does one yet see the monumental blunder and degeneracy of this perspective? That the world is harsh, unendurably harsh save for the strongest natures is, undeniable That this in any way diminishes its grandeur or precludes it from valuability is an absolute error.

And so, I must say, is the existence of my generation.

[b]VI.[/b]

Much more could be said of my utter antipathy towards the generation into which I was born, but the spite with which I use to write has dried up, and because I cannot saw off the top of my head and use it as an ink-well I fear this should have to suffice.

Having rid myself of all re-sentiments for the time being, I feel it prudent to step back from myself, to procure distance from myself, and to analyze the inner feelings which have led me to my conclusion (however right I may be, there is little doubt that I am caused to feel this way by certain alchemical combinations of sensation which come as they will). And however much I should want to look around it, I cannot help but believe that I, too, am quite smitten by the ideas I’ve portrayed.

Firstly, I find that I so fear the messianic tendency because I myself love it so much: the mythic character of the redemptive drama appeals to me because it offers the possibility of salvation through an absenting from one’s own individual character. This becomes an altogether indispensable psychological panacea for those of us who lack any character to speak of. I find that I desire to portray myself in such a light, for a number of reasons:

  1. The ‘suffering savior’ is always an object of pity and sympathy; were I to become as such, perhaps others would not recoil in hatred at the very sight of me.

  2. That I am still possessed of a troubled conscience is undeniable. This does not all mean to me that I am genuinely guilty, but that I am not made of strong enough stuff to either utilize my guilt conductively or to obliterate it altogether.

  3. A bad conscience wants to make others bad as well: it is manipulative in the sense that it induces invariable psychological affections within the observer which, taken on the whole, leads to their own renunciation of agency. That agency is illusory need not be an admission of its uselessness.

Thus I can say with certainty that the messianic ideal is bad, not because it is immoral but because it is my ideal, and I am bad to the very absence.

Furthermore, in the process of writing this essay, it seems to me that I’ve encountered another means by which an individual might free himself from the shackles of the bad conscience - simple forgetfulness. To forgive is divine; to forget, to the contrary, is heroic, and men are no gods. This, however, requires an elevated state of emotional excitability which, if not properly directed, might very well lead to violence or to self-violence. Passion, in this sense, becomes a painkiller: it induces grogginess. Thus the ancient distinction between passion and passivity is rendered meaningless - one can have not only a desire for self-renunciation, but for the obliteration of the past itself.

To destroy the past: that, and that alone, would be divine.

[b]VII.[/b]

– and does my past preclude me from godhood?

Much better…

Edited: I just don’t get it.

very eloquent. i’ll have to re-read it in order to truly comment.