philosophy for younger students

My friend passed along an anecdote that showed some of the challenges–even dangers–that can arise when younger students interact with philosophy. I would be interested to hear if others have had similar experiences or have any advice when similar tensions arise. See below.

We had a bit of a dust-up at our middle school today. Fight between two boys. We had to take some measures, including some confiscation and locker searches and such. Sort of unpleasant all around. This was an unusual sort of disagreement. It was the classic split over Hegel. You see it all the time in the media but don’t think it will happen in your school. John, a 7th grader, is a pure old school Hegelian of the right. Hegel is reconcilable with Christianity, taking the metaphysical very literally, all of that stuff. James, an 8th grader, is hard line Pittsburgh school. There just is no reconciling these perspectives. We know tensions had been simmering on the playground for a while, but the other day it did come to blows. So…we now do daily searches of backpacks and lockers. No Hegel is allowed at school, period. And we had to confiscate a good collection of sources: Marheineke, Goeschel, Brandom, McDowell…We’re keeping custody of those books for the time being, and the parents actually want it that way. It’s insidious how a national epidemic comes home, and then you realize you have to take it seriously! The school is actually developing a Hegelian-conflict resolution team, comprised of both faculty and students, to model dialectical mediation on some of the thornier passages. Strange world!

1 Like

Cool…I’d be focused on Logic & Reason with that age group.

Cheers!

Just wait til they discover Kant. Mathematics teachers everywhere are gonna be pissed.

Just ban everything but the presocratics.

Then they will be forced to sit and meditate about every single thing, and this will cool their youthful passions.

Plato should be cause for expulsion.

Critical Thinking…it’s The Baseline philosophically speaking.