Films of this nature tend to be judged as exceptional or not depending on the level of sophsitication employed in the narrative. And on the level of complexity in probing what for some is not complex at all. If you do this you are in fact Evil and deserve nothing but contempt from all the rest of us. And [at the very least] until the day you die. And then [for some] you will burn in hell for all eternity.
This is always a particularly tough subject for me because I get particularly upset when an adult harms a child—for any reason let alone this one. There’s a part of me that wants to lock them all up and throw away the key. But there is another part that recognizes all the variables that can come together to predispose us [any of us] to do all sorts of terrible things. I’ve done a number things I’m not to proud of myself…and I’ve come to understand the mitigating “past” here all too well. But to kids?
And it is made clear that he has not been wholly rehabilitated or “cured”. He is in fact still a threat.
at wiki: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Woodsman
trailer: youtu.be/sst041HiCUA
THE WOODSMAN [2004]
Written and directed by Nicole Kassell
[b]Boss: The only reason I’m doing this is 'cause I know you did good work for my father. So you be here on time. You do your work. I don’t want any kind of problem, period.
…
Vickie: You never spoke to me before.
Walter: I thought you were a dyke.
…
Vickie: I used to think you were shy…but now I think it’s something else.
Walter: What?
Vickie: Something happened to you.
Walter: Yeah?
Vickie: I’m not easily shocked.
Walter: I get that impression.
Vickie: So, you gonna tell me your dark secret?
Walter: Why do you want to know?
Vickie: Don’t you think I should know before we have sex? I don’t like to waste time. So, you gonna tell me your deep, dark secret?
Walter: No.[/b]
Later…
Vickie: So, what did you do? What happened to you? Walter?
Walter: Why do you want to know?
Vickie: Because I like you.
Walter: What’s the worst thing you ever did?
Finally…
[b]Walter: I molested little girls.
[Vickie laughs in disbelief]
Walter: 12 years in prison is no joke.
Vickie [after a long pause]: How young?
Walter: Between 10 and 12. Once a nine-year-old told me she was eleven. Once a 14-year-old told me she was 12. I always asked how old they were.
Vickie: What did you do to them?
Walter: It’s not what you think. I never hurt them. Never. Look…I want you to go now, all right?
Vickie: I told you I’m not easily shocked.
Walter: Yeah, well, you should be shocked…Or do you get off on this shit?
Vickie [she’s shocked now]: What?!
…
[repeated line]
Walter: When will I be normal?[/b]
And we know the implication of that.
[b]Dr. Rosen [to Walter]: You followed a girl. Perhaps you wanted to see what it felt like after so many years. Maybe subconsciously you were testing yourself. And here you are…talking about it with me. This is positive.
…
Walter: Remember when you asked me what my idea of normal was? Normal is when I can see a girl…be near a girl, even talk to a girl… and not think about… That’s my idea of normal.[/b]
Well, in this day and age is that normal?
Vickie: I got poked around here and there.
Walter: Jesus. Which brother?
Vickie: All three, in chronological order.
Walter: Why are you telling me this?
Vickie: I’m trying to tell you who I am, if you’re interested.
Walter: You must hate your brothers.
Vickie: I love my brothers.
Walter: No, you don’t.
Vickie: I love all of them. They’re strong, gentle men with families of their own. If you ever asked them about what they did to me, they’d beat the shit out of you. And they’d call you a fucking liar.
In some ways the same, in some ways different.
[b]Sgt. Lucas: Do you believe in Fairy Tales?
Walter: Fairy Tales?
Sgt. Lucas: Yeah, like Alice in Wonderland.
Walter: No.
Sgt. Lucas: Yeah, yeah, me neither. What’s that one with the Woodsman?
Walter: Woodsman?
Sgt. Lucas: Yeah, with the ax?
Walter: I don’t know.
Sgt. Lucas: Yeah, you know it. The Woodsman, he cuts open the wolf’s stomach and the little girl come out alive…
Walter: Little Red Riding Hood.
Sgt. Lucas: Little Red Riding Hood! That’s it! That’s it. The Woodsman, he cuts open the wolf’s stomach, the girl comes out without a scratch…You ever see a seven-year-old sodomized in half? She was so small, just broken. I saw 20-year vets on that job. Hard guys, they just broke down and cried. I was there, I cried…There ain’t no fucking woodsman in this world. I don’t know why they keep lettin’ freaks like you out on the street. It just means that we gotta catch you all over again.
…
Walter: Robin…
Robin [who is eleven years old]: Yes?
Walter: Would you like to sit on my lap?
Robin: What?
Walter: Would you like to sit on my lap?
Robin: No, thank you.
Walter: Okay. Doesn’t matter.
Robin: Do you want me to sit on your lap?
Walter: Yes. I would enjoy that. I know this place that’s really quiet…except for the sound of these tiny little birds.
Robin: They sound like finches.
Walter: Yeah, they might be finches. Do you want to see?
Robin: My daddy lets me sit on his lap.
Walter: Does he?
Robin: Yes.
Walter: Do you like it when he asks you?
Robin: No.
Walter: Why not?
[Robin starts to cry]
Walter: Are you two alone when he asks you? Does he say strange things? Does he move his legs in funny ways?
Robin: Walter…do you still want me to sit on your lap? I will. I don’t mind.
Walter: No. Go home, Robin.[/b]
But it could easily have gone the other way. And maybe next time it will. So I’m back to locking them up and throwing away the key. In this very imperfect world.