Reality is one thing and not made of many discrete things

All things share a similar property in common.

Anytime that you view multiple things, you can describe all of those things as “something that I view”. If those things can be described with a similar description, then it seems like that must be because they are actually the same thing.

This is position is anti-intuitive to many who adopt a scientific mindset, but this seems to be logical if the above makes. There are no boundaries in between individual objects, because we never observe those boundaries in our scientific observations. It seems that, when we talk about individual objects, we are, perhaps unconsciously, talking in terms of their being a boundary in between those things. But just as our way of speaking posits boundaries between countries that really are just many aspects of continuous land, it seems that the idea of separation between objects and/or separate objects is a similar, arbitrary and/or illogical way to divide up reality.

Two ways of looking at one and the same reality: holistically, as you are, and as a plurality of discreet entities.

Everything is being, and you can divide up towards infinity, or look at it in it’s totality. Just two perspectives on the same phenomenon.

If multiple perspectives are being used to understand reality, then those perspectives themselves are data that reality is made up of. So, in other words, we could shift this conversation to take on a more straightforward format, to simply talk about reality, which consists of multiple perspectives and the “phenomena of reality”. It seems that, the way you are laying out your argument, that you are saying that stuff in reality that can be called “perspective” and that stuff in reality which is “the phenomena of reality itself” are two sides of the same coin, they are both ultimately parts of reality.

Further, it seems, that in order for your statement to achieve more clarity, we need to clarify how the stuff of perspective “changes” the stuff of phenomena. This “relation word” is ambiguous to me. The idea of something changing when seen through the lens of some perspective is itself something that needs to be clarified, or reduced to something we can observe. In other words, do we ever observe the state of something that is called “perspective” distorting or otherwise changing some phenomena that we are inclined to call “reality”?

I don’t think we ever strictly observe this, and so I question whether talking about a “perception and reality distinction” (and, therefore, as a result, of a distinction of “multiple perspectives”) is a well-formed way to talk about reality.

If you ‘see’ a Thing, you can claim a Non-Dual perspective, but if you are Touching a Thing while looking at it, your Unity become a Synthesis.

Why? Touch doesn’t effect the Intellect in the same way, and there is a time variation in juxtapositioning and unifying a Synthesis of Thingness… and you have to assign Spatially a corelation pf active touching and looking as a factoid. Thinking verbally in your mind assigns another variable, and it too has time dialation and dislocation of a sense of self.

If you really wanna mind fuck yourself, take a water melon, touch it, while looking at it, and lick it, all at the same time… and while looking at it, put one foot in cold water, another in hot, and do it infront of a attractive woman looking at you all strange, dealing with the awkward embarrassment… then tell me reality is a unified singular.

Since you live in Berkeley, sign up for The San Francisco Philosophy Group. Its on meetup.com

If you ‘see’ a Thing, you can claim a Non-Dual perspective, but if you are Touching a Thing while looking at it, your Unity become a Synthesis.

Why? Touch doesn’t effect the Intellect in the same way, and there is a time variation in juxtapositioning and unifying a Synthesis of Thingness… and you have to assign Spatially a corelation of active touching and looking as a single factoid. Thinking verbally in your mind assigns another variable, and it too has time dialation and dislocation of a sense of self.

If you really wanna mind fuck yourself, take a water melon, touch it, while looking at it, and lick it, all at the same time… and while looking at it, put one foot in cold water, another in hot, and do it infront of a attractive woman looking at you all strange, dealing with the awkward embarrassment… then tell me reality is a unified singular.

Since you live in Berkeley, sign up for The San Francisco Philosophy Group. Its on meetup.com

Thank you for your response Contra-Nietzche. I am curious what you mean when you say that “there is a time variation between looking and touching”. Do those have to occur at different times? I think I agree with you, if I understand you correctly. It seems like you are saying that the data of looking and the data of touch are something that exist in the fundamentally unified reality. Is that the correct way to understand what you are saying?

You are right in that the entire universe is nothing more than a single substance spread out and concentrated in varied ways with no exact forms or boundaries. But our minds have no option but to discern hope from threat and thus matter from space, stronger vs weaker, larger vs smaller, and so on. If we were not living, we wouldn’t have to do that. And if we stop doing that, we would not be living.

Yeah but sometimes there are things that I don’t see and I can’t go around describing them as ‘something that I view’. Still they might exist or not but who knows, if they don’t exist I still don’t know about them so they might as well exist… get it? Reality is difficult to decipher when you use words.

I get it… when you stick your joystick in the lovegrotto, they’re not actually separate but part of one continuous pulsating action. And when I smack my discretely packed up fist into your face, your face isn’t separate from my fist but cosmically connected. So the secret of any kind of unifying perspective is because when you have a thing, you usually have another thing as well, and these are then more often than not involved in some situation. So yeah the realness is the situation and not the thing.

No, I am not saying that, I am saying time in touch and time in sight are not unified, and our comprehension of either uses different circuits in the left hemisphere to interprete it.

This has been known since ancient times, you see this in the cognitive debates.

I’m quite active as a Dualist on Non-Dualist boards and groups, know some of the best known advocates in the west on thus subject… it is largely a impossibility to achieve a perceptive unification of reality. The Non-Dual side usually tries to blame thoughts, and focus on the visual cortex alone… but in order to unify thought, you need the Intellect (greek intellect) which triggers thought.

Every which way triggers neural circuits which results in Dualism, there simply put is no way to be conscious and not be Dualistic at the same time.

The second reason why time isn’t unified via conjoining vision and touch is you gotta synchronize and favor one over another.

I will give you a very simple test… take a penny, and place it on the wall, using just one finger to hold it up… at eye level, and stand as far away from the wall as possible. Do it for five minutes.

What happened? At first, time was unified and simple… so it seems, then more and more aspects of your body you usually dont notice started lighting up.

That penny got heavy as hell, didn’t it. Muscles started to fail, you likely were dancing on tippy toes moaning. Why? Cause it hurts. The brain doesnt focus it coherently in time, it just focuses on processing pain. Visual time becomes secondary.

During sex, time can go quicker or slower than pleasurable impulse, same due to great trauma.

Idiot Savants process Tactile information first, then visual. Regular people, visual then tactile.

But our ‘knowing’ of time via the intellect usually just simplifies a understanding of one abstraction of time (which isnt time… the complete agony of holding that penny was time). If you focus on something else, you just assume the same temporal frame of reference follows. We know this is wrong when it gets extreme, such as in car accidents where time can fly by very quickly when it is not a constant… slipping in and out of focus.

We always do that.

Hence why Colonel Boyd developed the OODA Loop… it maps our rates of change of perception and time via feedback cycles.

It seems that our mind typically does this create this separate sense of self from other people and things, but can’t we break free from this pattern of conceptualizing? Freud, at the beginning of Civilizations and its Discontents, claims that perhaps when we are young, when we have the luxury of omnipotent gratification (our needs always being met), that perhaps we have less of a conceptual division between self and other. Perhaps Freud’s literal account is not true at all, or true in respects to when its supposed to occur, but maybe there is some people who experience less of a distinct sense of self, whether infants, Bodhisattvas, or Joe six-packs.

This quote makes me think of this question: what does it even mean to talk about “other stuff that I don’t percieve”? I see what you are saying, and I want to take the idea even one step further: not only can we not know whether there is other stuff or not, but maybe we can’t even begin to think about there being other stuff besides what one views because “other stuff besides what one views” is not an even well-formed, semantically elucidated idea. I am curious if you have any insight on that.

No, you can’t. You can try and thus remove many former thoughts (the purpose of getting you to try), but the mind cannot exist without conceptualizing. Mostly the mind merely loses the words to describe its new concepts and thus cannot communicate.

So you can’t talk about the pistons in an engine merely because they are not sitting in front of you?
…also something that merely removes one’s ability to think.

You seem to promote several of those “let’s all be blind” thoughts.

Thanks for now your second bit of feedback, he is who is contra against he who is contra Wagner.

Your account is invoking observations of brain states to figure out the question of sensation in respects of time, but shouldn’t we be able to look at the information of sensation itself, and the information of time (to whatever degree it is actually information! Time, we are told, is a stubbornly persistent illusion), and figure out how those fit in with one another, without invoking the brain? This seems to be the proper way to understand experience and the brain, since any observation of the brain is itself an experience and thus should be understood as an aspect of experience, as opposed experience somehow “being based” in the brain.

So, I think Husserl would disagree with you here, and I am inclined to agree with Husserl. It conflates the intentional act of consciousness with the intentional content of consciousness. At least for Husserl, reality would not include the act of consciousness, because consciousness is not a “think among things.” Consciousness is simply the awareness of things, of reality. Sartre will say something very similar when he says that consciousness is nothing - not a thing, in other words, not a part of reality, not being. I think that’s basically right. Reality is all that consciousness, which is not reality or not a thing, is aware of. The argument for this, I think, would be that consciousness simply does not show up for us phenomenologically are part of reality, as a thing among things, a being among beings. The objects of consciousness: chairs, tables, numbers, logical formulas, thoughts about dragons - these are all part of reality, but consciousness itself is not a thing; cannot be reified. To speak of reality, then, is to be speaking of the content of awareness, excluding awareness itself, because awareness is not a thing. Perhaps you will find that claim implausible but something about it seems right to me. Consciousness is not reality or a part of it but is rather our opening onto it. In Heidegger’s vocabulary, it is the clearing which lets beings be.

So when you speak of reality, you are actually speaking of the phenomenological contents of consciousness, but not consciousness itself.

Now as to whether or not reality is all one: Anytime that you view multiple things, you can describe all of those things as “something that I view”. If those things can be described with a similar description, then it seems like that must be because they are actually the same thing.

I don’t think the conclusion follows that if things we view can be described with a similar description, then it must be because they are actually the same thing. To spell it out logically, for example, let’s say we have two similar oranges sitting next to each other. They have the same color, shape, weight, etc. such that we cannot discern one from the other through the use of our senses. But it doesn’t follow from that that they are indeed the same, identical orange or substance or being or thing. The formal logic spells this out explicitly:

∃x∃y((O(x) & (O(y) & ((x≠y)))) where O = is an orange, or something like that. So in other words, x is an orange, y is an orange, and y is not equal to x. That’s what we are actually saying when we say that there are two identical

So, I think Husserl would disagree with you here, and I am inclined to agree with Husserl. It conflates the intentional act of consciousness with the intentional content of consciousness. At least for Husserl, reality would not include the act of consciousness, because consciousness is not a “thing among things.” Consciousness is simply the awareness of things, of reality. Sartre will say something very similar when he says that consciousness is nothing - not a thing, in other words, not a part of reality, not being. I think that’s basically right. Reality is all that consciousness, which is not reality or not a thing, is aware of. The argument for this, I think, would be that consciousness simply does not show up for us phenomenologically are part of reality, as a thing among things, a being among beings. The objects of consciousness: chairs, tables, numbers, logical formulas, thoughts about dragons - these are all part of reality, but consciousness itself is not a thing; cannot be reified. To speak of reality, then, is to be speaking of the content of awareness, excluding awareness itself, because awareness is not a thing. Perhaps you will find that claim implausible but something about it seems right to me. Consciousness is not reality or a part of it but is rather our opening onto it. In Heidegger’s vocabulary, it is the clearing which lets beings be.

So when you speak of reality, you are actually speaking of the phenomenological contents of consciousness, but not consciousness itself.

Now as to whether or not reality is all one: Anytime that you view multiple things, you can describe all of those things as “something that I view”. If those things can be described with a similar description, then it seems like that must be because they are actually the same thing.

I don’t think the conclusion follows that if things we view can be described with a similar description, then it must be because they are actually the same thing. To spell it out logically, for example, let’s say we have two similar oranges sitting next to each other. They have the same color, shape, weight, etc. such that we cannot discern one from the other through the use of our senses. But it doesn’t follow from that that they are indeed the same, identical orange or substance or being or thing. The formal logic spells this out explicitly:

∃x∃y((O(x) & (O(y) & ((x≠y)))) where O = is an orange, or something like that. So in other words, x is an orange, y is an orange, and y is not identical with x. That’s what we are actually saying when we say that there are similar.

[code]So, I think Husserl would disagree with you here, and I am inclined to agree with Husserl. It conflates the intentional act of consciousness with the intentional content of consciousness. At least for Husserl, reality would not include the act of consciousness, because consciousness is not a “think among things.” Consciousness is simply the awareness of things, of reality. Sartre will say something very similar when he says that consciousness is nothing - not a thing, in other words, not a part of reality, not being. I think that’s basically right. Reality is all that consciousness, which is not reality or not a thing, is aware of. The argument for this, I think, would be that consciousness simply does not show up for us phenomenologically are part of reality, as a thing among things, a being among beings. The objects of consciousness: chairs, tables, numbers, logical formulas, thoughts about dragons - these are all part of reality, but consciousness itself is not a thing; cannot be reified. To speak of reality, then, is to be speaking of the content of awareness, excluding awareness itself, because awareness is not a thing. Perhaps you will find that claim implausible but something about it seems right to me. Consciousness is not reality or a part of it but is rather our opening onto it. In Heidegger’s vocabulary, it is the clearing which lets beings be.

So when you speak of reality, you are actually speaking of the phenomenological contents of consciousness, but not consciousness itself.

Now as to whether or not reality is all one: Anytime that you view multiple things, you can describe all of those things as “something that I view”. If those things can be described with a similar description, then it seems like that must be because they are actually the same thing.

I don’t think the conclusion follows that if things we view can be described with a similar description, then it must be because they are actually the same thing. To spell it out logically, for example, let’s say we have two similar oranges sitting next to each other. They have the same color, shape, weight, etc. such that we cannot discern one from the other through the use of our senses. But it doesn’t follow from that that they are indeed the same, identical orange or substance or being or thing. The formal logic spells this out explicitly:

∃x∃y((O(x) & (O(y) & ((x≠y)))) where O = is an orange, or something like that. So in other words, x is an orange, y is an orange, and y is not equal to x. That’s what we are actually saying when we say that there are two identical[/code]

Thanks, Existenz, for your very thoughtful response.

Sartre’s account, as you lay it out here, is something hard for me to understand, because on one hand it seems to be criticizing talk of consciousness as an object, but then, at the same time, it is still talking about consciousness. It would seem that this is true: consciousness either is or isn’t some information in reality, and, correspondingly, either is able to be matched up to words or is not able to be matched up to them. I don’t quite understand what I mean by saying that some information is “matched up to words”, but it is all I can work with for now, since we, after all, our in a conversation, and using words.

If there are two oranges, I would not say that they are totally similar. What seems like a more helpful description is that those two oranges are two different aspects of the same reality. The fact that we can assign a similar label to them–that they exhibit a similar color, perhaps that they both exist, that they are both approximately round, that they can both be formally predicated as being “o”–is that makes them similar. And I would say that “similar things are the same”. Their differences are what differentiated them as contrastable aspects–perhaps they are different in shape, and it seems they would be taking up different spaces, and thus described by different spatial data–but that doesn’t mean they can’t be contrastable aspects of the same reality.

Those are my thoughts in reply to your post.

So, because the word ‘stuff’ exists, and I can apply this word to anything, that therefore proves that all these apparently different things actually are not?

That seems to make language more powerful than it is.

What you say about countries is a good example of the mistake going on here- a country is a political object, not a geographical object. To say that countries aren’t real because the land is really continuous is like saying my opinion on this matter is no different from yours because they are both projected on the same screen.

You can try to take neurological interdependence out of reality, and you can indeed produce stable results… much like the Stoics and Peripatetics and Pyrrhonists did, or the various orders of Advaita-Dvaita did… but the counter arguments tend to be as stable, and they will eventually find weaknesses and paradox in your outlooks…

Reality is Perception… but the focus of perception is Ontology. Your concept, and everyone elses, is specialized and limited, and has some quirks to it not everyone shares. Its why philosophers added a synthetic ontological category, the phenomena-noumenon divide… which nobody likes, no one accepts, but everyone cleverly reverts back to one way or another in the end.

It underlines Sun Tzu’s concept of ‘Formlessness’.

There is a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of consciousness that was brought up with Sarte (he was a pretty smart guy, this isnt a dis) a few posts back…

Under the Two-Vision Theory of the Brain, visual thought begins in the rear of the brain, then branches off into a Where stream of orientation, and a What. They are interrelated, and cascade off into other aspects of the mind.

In Orienting prior to Observation (as per the OODA Loop) we make choices even at this nearly completely unconscious point how we are shifting information.

Why this matters first occured to me in San Francisco… I used to go to The Faithful Fools Dojo about two blocks from the San Francisco Philosophy Group (where it USED to be)… the monk came up from San Jose, and ran it for just a few guys, not like the San Francisco Zen Centers hugh commercial operation… the guy was very educated philosophically… you should meet him…

Anyway… I was all pissed off with the Zen Center, as they just made you sit there… and didnt tell you jack, and I would just stair at the wall where grease stains would form from people falling asleep and smacking their heads off the wall. Everything I learned about Dogen, I learned on my own… not from them.

The Nicheran monk was actually useful… when he said to not think, he cpuld explain how not to if you voiced frustration… mine came up after a few months… I noted whenever he turned the lights down… the actual effect produced a very frustrating side effect…

I explained the footlight produced a exact loom that allowed me to see hypnogogic hallucination patterns, if I WASN’T VERBALLY THINKING!

These patterns were diagonal lines, and in my left eye, moved left to right, in my right to left… and after a while they would compete, and move over into the other eye, clash, push… then push back…

After a while, I would not this and say WTF and it would disappear. Verbal thought made it leave. I would focus on nothing again… blah blah nothing… and would see the lines come back… and part of me would make a color into a shape, like a cross, then a shoe… then I would get pissed because I made floating shoes appear…

I brought this up…he was like ‘really?’… and I noted though I see the colors and images other times, never the waves unless in this dojo…

Then it hit me… my frontal eye fields process spatial info to my left hemisphere, where my sense of unity took place… metely cancelling it out was not enough, as our visual system passes through the frontal eyefield… I arrived at a frustrating paradox… perception without thinking doesnt lead to a state of nothingness, because perception is built AROUND thinking, and even if you dont think, the nerves still will work, will produce interfering side effects.

So… I can focus on nothing, and at a certain loom, even have a visual meter that tells me if I am actually thinking or not, but to notice it makes it go away, defeating the purpose, and to ignore it mocks the attempt, as it gives that elusive anwser every mediator, no matter how experience, wants to know… Am I doing this right?’

Consciousness cascades across the neurological networks and vascular triggers of the mind… but a single sense of self isnt real… every aspect of awareness compounds into a synthesis… I subtracted visual thought, but being a thinker who specializes in thought near the SMA parts of the brain, I literally cant get rid of my frontal eye fields playing with my visual field. My superior imagination comes at the expense I cant shut it off… my FEF was off, but still carrying a current, and my clever as fuck intellect found new work arounds to it.

True story, backtrack it… white guy, japanese wife, san jose nicheran temple.

Contra-Nietzsche, dude, you are cool: I was just at the faithful fools about a month ago for one of their fundraisers, small world! I will respond to the rest of your post soon, of course.

I maintain that “similar things are the same” . . . let me ask you this: what other cogent conclusion can we come to? That, when we apply the same label to multiple things . . . that those things are not the same? That those things are “similar but not the same”? (I would then ask what can be made out of that quoted phrase?)

How would you explain how multiple labels can be matched up to what we consider “different objects”, to use the parlance of common sense?