I think it’s an opiate, as in one of the many and not the, as in the only one. Though one could argue that it’s the strongest one.
That’s one of the main things I dislike about religion. The general apathy and meekness it causes in people towards real life issues because, after all, god is going to make everything right after death… yea right. And it’s that belief that is keeping under control billions of people. If people realized that this is their only life and they’re wasting it on being tools for the higher authorities we’d probably see some quick, positive changes. But again, that would take too much work and sacrifice for the general public. It’s easier to just pretend everything is alright because an imaginary being will help… when you die…
A religion can induce these effects, certainly in certain situations. It can also do the opposite of those first more positive sounding ones, say with ‘God fearing’. Religion can induce guilt, shame, subserviance, dominance, fear, Peace, self-rightousness,humility and a whole host of other mental states.
Long term religious belief might lead to heightened anxiety, but it does not necessarily have this escalating tolerance issue. And, in fact, some religious practices, for some, increase the peaceful effects, since they get better at the practices (thinking of the altered states kind of training abilities, though there are other ways they may find more Peace. And note: I do not have Peace as a core goal, just responding in terms of the way Marx is making an analogy.)
It seems to me any belief system can act both like an opiate and unlike an opiate. Marxism can ironically also work this way. People identify with a class of people the coming great future, the nobleness of the proletariat. It gives many a fairly simple system to organize their thoughts and reactions around. This can bring Peace. Capitalism, scientism, whatever. Some people end up feeling good and relaxed because they consider themselves ‘one of the brave ones’ facing the harsh truths. Religions are very complicated phenomena and humans are very widely varied in terms of committment, interpretation, reaction, ability even. Human Opiates use is a very rigid system by comparison/process. Simple, fairly predicatable effects in a narrow range.
just to snatch something from Another thread…
If many people felt this way would this mean that atheism (or agnosticism) is the opium of the people? Nah.
In many contexts the use of this quote by Marx is a kind of collective ad hom.
I’d add that consuming an opiate isn’t necessarily that much of a bad thing if you do it in good measure and it can bring happiness in life (at the expense of some other things). Just like religion. But then again, no opiate is still better than any opiate, just like religion, at least for me .
I actually agree with that, well, most of it. I wouldn’t say that Marxism is an opiate the same way religion is. Marxism makes people want to change the world, it tries to rise the consciousness of the people to the injustices done to them, it deals with problems, it’s active. That’s not to say I agree with it, just pointing out the difference.
Religion focuses on the invisible, untouchable and ultimately unknowable and therefore reduces our awareness of what’s actually going on in the world. That’s what makes it an opiate.
I don’t think he’s saying that he’s an atheist because it makes him feel better, you’re confusing cause and consequence.
Actually, religion is not having enough effect on people to be an opiate.
The better candidate is media.
Second to that would be the perfectly legal drug of alcohol.
At the same time, given the Calvinistic nature of the connection between Christianity and Capitalism, it still seems to be having an opiate-like effect on some of the less rational among us in America: the right wing. But, because of that lack of rationality, that aspect of it is dying off. And Capitalism is too smart to expect to depend on it forever. Therefore, it will turn to media and legal drugs (on top of consumption) to keep us in the Land of the Lotos eaters.
At the same time, it will sustain the Calvinistic sense that our rightness w/ god (the invisible hand) will be defined by how we succeed: the resources we have to enjoy when on alcohol and drugs.
Christianity, for example, seems to make people want to change the World. Similarly other religions. Some do interpret the religions as a reason to withdraw from politics, but generally even there they would agree - even if they do not act on it - that parts of the Bible encourage people to make the World better, at least locally, by treating people well, etc. And then just because you Believe in Marxism does not mean you are Active. Marxism included the belief that the proletariat state was inevitable. Some Marxists took this to mean they need do nothing. Others actually supported fascism, thinking this would bring on the revolution faster than dealing with more liberal governments they considered oppressive. And then on the other side of the spectrum we could see the implicit moral and political passiveness inherent in the idea of the unseen hand of the market.
That does not work, in general, for a religion like HInduism, whose practices include meditation which increases awareness of what is happening, and is a religion that does not hide the various evils of the World. All religious systems if actually practiced regularly include practices that increase awareness - not that, say, Christianity Thinks of it this way since many are cut off from the mystical roots and practices. But given Jesus’ message awareness of the poor and suffering and the implicit and explicit messages about dealing with this actually makes many Christians dive in to reality in ways that neo-cons never would - say, Liberation theologists or hospice workers or missionaries - I Think you are oversimplifying things.
I didn’t say he was. I was merely pointing out that he found himself happier, as he says, without the religion. Coming down from a drug and its blissed out state is generally NOT experienced this way, and so, if there are other people who have reacted like him in some significant numbers - and I am pretty darn sure there are - then there is a weakness in the opiate analogy.
Religions are extremely complicated phenomena and the larger organized one give out a wide range of messages. It is not my experience that religious people are more cut off from reality. Though if you have actual scientific research that shows that they are less are of people around them, social problems, politics, their Children, and so on, feel free to provide some links. Religious people tend to be a Little less infatuated with modern social media, especially the more religious ones. I would be surprised if being detached from what is going on correlates better with religious commitment than use of digital media - though obviously individuals can combine these things.
What Group with what philosophy is more aware of real Life and what data supports this?
“Christianity, for example, seems to make people want to change the World. Similarly other religions. Some do interpret the religions as a reason to withdraw from politics, but generally even there they would agree - even if they do not act on it - that parts of the Bible encourage people to make the World better, at least locally, by treating people well, etc.”
Imagine what an asset it would be to a just cause to have someone who believed in a reward after life. Such people would surely have broader boundaries as to the limits they would go to for that cause. Note, for instance, the Quakers who were willing to burn themselves alive in protest of the Vietnam war. Christ, himself (regardless of whether his beliefs were true or not) was a model for the role religion could play in the pursuit of justice.
The dark side of that, of course, are the suicide bombers.
I Think some religious people do end up focusing more on the World due to religion, others are more like World deniers - suicide bombers being one Group. Those who Believe in reincarnation have a long term investment in the planet that one lifers would not.
I mean, I am pretty critical of the big five, for a variety of reasons, but to call them opium like is to radically simplify and may even be more wrong than correct.