Spiritual Energy

Some four centuries ago Descartes rationalized existence via the famous dictum “I am because I think”.
The modern would might have been an entirely different place today if he had put aside mathematics and concentrated his great mind more on the unifying the distinction between corporeal nature of “I am” and the incorporeal nature of “I think”.
He never did, and so the world went on to dismiss the divine appointment of kings, chop of their heads and adopt man-made constitutions to over-see the government of human behavior. The hollow nature of the Cartesian dictum is clearly evident in the carnage of two world wars and the human condition today, which remains but a button-push away from species extinction.

Back in the 1950’s, a Jesuit priest who had studied to be a scientist, struggled with the obvious conflict of interests between his two callings. It lead him to become deeply concerned with an analysis of the post-Revolutionary period. He decided to tackle the eternal question from the dual perspective of scientist/priest.

He began by adding a rider to the Cartesian statement and, said: . “To think we must eat.” He then went on to say. “That blunt statement expresses a whole economy, and reveals, according to the way we look at it, either the tyranny of matter or its loftiest power.”

The priest was, of course, Teilhard de Chardin, and the statement was made in his completed treatise on “The Phenomenon of Man” which was banned from publication by the Catholic Church until after his death.

As the world shrinks and the pressures grow ever greater, trying to gain a coherent grasp of the link between matter and spirit has become more urgent today than ever before.

Teilhard tried to tackle it as best he could. Though his book made a stir at the height of the Cold War, little in human behavior has subsequently changed. We remain on the edge of the abyss, with nuclear proliferation making the world even more dangerous than before.

Philosophers needs to keep this discussion on the front burner, and I hope many will join in and share their opinions on this matter.

I will begin by quoting a couple or three of opening paragraphs from Teilhard’s work.
[i]
SPIRITUAL ENERGY

There is no concept more familiar to us than that of spiritual energy, yet there is none more opaque scientifically. On the one hand the objectivity of physical effort and work is so well established that the whole of ethics rests on it and, on the other hand, the nature of this inner power is so intangible that the whole description of the universe in mechanical terms has had no need to take account of it, but has been successfully completed in deliberate disregard of its reality.

The difficulties we encounter in trying to hold together spirit and matter in a reasonable perspective are nowhere more harshly revealed. Nowhere is the need more urgent of building a bridge between the two banks of our existence – the physical and moral – if we wish the spiritual and material aspects of our activities to be mutually enlivened.

To connect the two energies, of the body and the soul, in a coherent manner, science has provisionally decided to ignore the question, and it would very convenient for us to do the same. Unfortunately, or fortunately, caught up as we are in the logic of a system where the “within” of things has as much or even more value than the “without”, we collide with the difficulty head-on. It is impossible to avoid the clash – we must advance……[/i]

Would anybody like to make another advance ?

Wow, great post… =D> What an intimidating question! de Chardin is most certainly an interesting character. I can’t be completely sure what direction you’re trying to go bringing Teilhard de Chardin in with this question of matter and spirit – noogenesis or phenomenology? – so I’ll respond to the passage you’ve quoted first, and then attempt to address your larger question.
Teilhard de Chardin

Do you think perhaps psychoanalysis could rightly be held to deal with ‘psychic’ energy-- the energy as the kinetic impulse towards this sort of ‘theoretical’ balance between the spirit and the society?

But perhaps they often do reduce it to a mechanism, an approximate and algebraic structure: psychic energy is reality, the balance between an imaginary spiritual inner reality and a symbolic external social reality. So what’s is left when we take out everything which is more or less a machine?

The unconscious is not a mechanism, but at some level we have to re-cognize the material fact that the unconscious is an ‘abstract’ machine! An abstracting machine made from machines: here I think the more ‘radical’ strains of psychoanalysis (like Guattari or maybe Foucault) are able to illuminate this connection of social repression and spiritual ‘energy’ in a direct way.

It’s ultimately a Nietzschean point: we construct the ‘individual’ just in time to punish or enslave, we create the ‘soul’ just in time to fill it full of sin and lack, we create ‘truth’ just in time to connect it with the foulest lies and most disgusting of abominations.

Remember, de Chardin’s pet theory (noogenesis) is essentially structuralist. The highest from the lowest, then. The original flow of energy is what is being suppressed, diverted, hidden, the brutal marks of ‘civilization’ finally become impercetible. It is at this level only that we can suddenly, magically perceive directly this so-called ‘intangible’ spiritual ‘energy’: at the very same level social and politico-economic energies emerge as seemingly ‘independent’ of the repression of the individual. I think a taste for black humor is needed to endorse this viewpoint, certainly such a disposition is the engine of Marx’s Capital.

Keep in mind that de Chardin was a Jesuit, so he was die-hard utopian and even somewhat socialist, another reason his scandalous publications were banned by the very same church that sparked the far-seeing faith of his beautiful soul. Upon returning from China (uncovering the bones of prehistoric hominids) he said during a conference in Paris:

(Teilhard de Chardin)

Does he mean: sorcery, mysticism, incantation? Or is this also: language, poetry, music, in short–a shared world? How much have we compromised…? #-o

The two main rationales of De Chardin’s thesis interest me greatly.

  1. The dim roots of consciousness pre-existed in primeval chemicals.
  2. The fully evolved expression of human consconsciousness will one day be experienced in the unification of our collective consciousness - as he stated it below:

[

(Teilhard de Chardin)

Though it may seem like a quantum leap for some, de Chardin’s conclusion indicates to me that Creation and its evolutionary progression - from infant naivette to cosmic sagacity - is a process of Divine direction (enjoyment) and not simply the result of random event.

I see an essential inter-dependence in the evolution of mankind’s social contracts and our spiritual belief systems. One could not progress without the other.
Hunter/gatherers could not have existed without animism.
Agriculturalists could not have progressed without shaman mediumship.
National industry could not have evolved without a written scripture and dogmatic religious instruction.
Nor could the present internationalism have come about without a solid reference of scietific determinism.
The fact that all cultures, world-wide, at differing periods of development, all exprienced the almost precisely the same sequence of social and spiritual inter-relationships, supports my view.

This logical evolutionary progression of the physical, in tandem with the metaphsyical, leads one to the conclusion of a collective untified mind, able to transcend the realtive nature of space/time.

I believe, in the “Omega Point”, he is indeed suggesting our ultimate evolutionary transcendence beyond and above the physical.
For me this means: The capability to collectively engage in a conscious dematerialization of the body at the end of our evolutionary cycle, and the emergeance of pure spiritual energy, fully aware and savouring the evolutionary experience as we experience Cosmic Consciousness uninhibited by the restrictions of physics.