I always found strange that Peter is considered the first Pope by the Catholic church. Clearly Paul was the more influential man of god, Paul’s vision and doctrine is what is found in the bible.
Peter was certainly important as he led the church following the crucifixion and the resurrection; however, why would the Catholic church designate him as the first Pope (forget that the papacy is false doctrine).
Paul was not proclaimed the second Pope though I think he died AFTER Peter… Is that correct?
Moreover, I always find it funny that the Catholic church, in many ways, mimics the path of Peter.
If we look at Peter he was always making mistakes (it’s actually funny).
Peter walks on water and starts to sink and Jesus says ye of lil’ faith.
The original Catholic church starts off so well (practically everyone converts and then because of their lack of faith the church begins to sink.
Peter takes Jesus aside saying: never will this [the crucifixion] happen and Jesus says to him (I paraphrase): Away from me Satan!
The Catholic church aligns itself with Satan aligning itself with Caesar, with the crusades, the inquisition, etc.
Peter claims he will never deny Jesus - Christ says before the cock crows you will deny me thrice.
Catholic church adopts many doctrines that deny the teachings of christ.
Paul rebukes Peter for his hypocrisy.
Martin Luther rebukes the Catholic doctrine of an infallible Pope.
In another thread…
I added the post above in case anyone takes offense to the parallelism I posted above… my posts are simply observations (accurate or otherwise).
IMO it would be hard not to designate him as first Pope considering the following passage from Matthew 16:
Why would Peter be chosen in this way? First of all, as I understand it, the name Peter in Greek means rock or stone. Peter’s psychology was the intellectual rock.
Peter had an intellectual grasp of the fundamentals of the teaching and valued it greatly. But at that point, he was still separate from it. He had the intellectual knowledge but the lack of inner understanding of inner evolution and the two distinctly different inner states of “heaven” and “earth”. This intellectual level is the basic starting point for man on earth. If the purpose of the church is the organization of people of differing strengths and weaknesses to make the cooperative effort of connecting heaven and earth, what other foundation is possible that can be realistically built upon other than the man of knowledge?
Knowledge on the level of “rock” is not psychologically digestible. It doesn’t touch your being but rests in the mind. Peter’s belief is not yet in himself but comes through Christ. He has enthusiasm but lacks “root” in himself.
As seen in Matthew 16, his intellect could value Jesus but lacked as of yet to put Jesus into the larger perspective of his mission. Peter was still caught up in the secular with concern for Jesus’ life but without the emotional presence to grasp the importance of the nature of Jesus’ physical death which was necessary to occur.
Peter was still stuck in secular ideas making him naturally want to defend Jesus’ life on earth and still unaware that all this was meaningless in the context of his purpose which was the unification of heaven and earth.
Peter had intellect but was still violent emotionally. Consider John 18:
The deeper meaning has to do with the right ear. The right ear is emotional hearing. Previously Jesus spoke of the need for eyes to see and ears to hear. The sword means fighting for truth but what good is it if it denies the ability to hear it beyond the intellect and experience its emotional depth?
Peter’s task was his gradual emotional awakening where he could get beyond his normal emotional level and experience a higher more conscious quality that over time I’ve read described as “feelings”. The experience of feelings allows the intellectual knowledge to develop into “understanding”
So Peter, like most of us, had to begin with valuing through fundamental knowledge. His task was to develop understanding of the teaching through the emotional experience of it together with the fundamental knowledge of it. When a man becomes emotionally awake he can forgive in a way that the man defending his intellect never can. This is all part of inner evolution.
This is the foundation of the church at least theoretically. What happens over time is because we are as we are.
Paul’s experience of revelation was unique. It cannot be a foundation.
While you have many valid points I think that we must look at the overall influence that these two great men managed over the course of the church. Paul preached to the gentiles… by far the larger group. Paul’s influence is profoundly more effective than Peter’s in regards to how the church developed its doctrine. In fact, without Paul’s epistles much of what is common Christian doctrine would not be as thoroughly understood.
Also, while the scripture you quoted could be used to claim that Peter was the rock upon which the church was built there is another explanationL
Jesus gave Simon this nickname to encourage him and to strengthen his convictions.
At this point Jesus is referring to himself… Could Jesus really think that Peter could have been trusted to protect the church against the gates of hell? Jesus predicted that Peter would deny him thrice, it could be argued that had Paul not come into the picture Peter would have stopped the church from preaching to the gentiles… goodbye church!
Remember Jesus is the capstone–the stone used as a foundation of reference for all other bricks… Peter could not possibly be this SAME rock.
Jesus is talking to all the disciples… specifically his twelve (the apostles).
The scripture has to be taken into context…
Though I am infamous for my line ‘context shmontext’
Don’t get me wrong. I’m not denying Paul’s influence even though often misunderstood IMO. The foundation of a church as was being described by Jesus is intellectual as I tried to explain.
The living church sustains itself with spiritual energy or that of the Holy Spirit. Life on earth sustains itself with mechanical and psychic (emotional) energies. When facets of the church begin to lose contact with its source, it begins to substitute the mechanical and emotional energies for the spiritual energies and the result is a secular church.
The idea of Jesus as the cornerstone and Peter as the foundation has to be understood psychologically and not historically. Doing so just reduces the sacred to secular conceptions.
Rock has a particular meaning in esoteric or inner psychological meaning. I was thinking at some point to begin a thread on the psychology of truth but I don’t know if there would be interest. But Rock is the lowest but necessary form of truth. You can read it but it remains in the intellect. The higher levels in the psychology of truth are the effects of the living “water” and “wine”.
Peter had access to the level of truth called “Rock” with the capacity to grow. I do believe that rock meant much more than strength of convictions but referred to a particular level of inner development or of human “being”.
I can’t see why you believe Jesus is referring to all the apostles? In context the passage reads in Matthew 16:
Jesus clearly answers Peter and states that Peter had contact with this higher intuition yet his understanding was on the earth. This is the ideal foundation for the growth of human “being”.
Its not that Peter could be trusted to protect the church. the idea is that the nature of his understanding is the foundation of it. These are two different concepts.
Yes Peter denied him three times but this was necessary for Peter to begin to appreciate the limits of his understanding, his nothingness, through the obvious contradiction between what he says and what he does. Such an appreciation allows him to let go of his egotism and begin real inner growth.
This is my great difficulty in discussing scripture. Usually it is taken as historical and as I understand it, its real meaning is psychological. Consider Luke 24:
Understanding is a psychological process that must occur in a certain way or the results will be worse then never having begun. Sacred text is unique that it can be understood at different levels of quality that reflect the understanding of the reader. You don’t get this in the NY Times. I’ve come to respect these psychological gifts so much that for secular facts I prefer the usual reference books. I’d rather preserve sacred texts to provide its psychology of “being.”
T4m, I can honestly say that assuming there is some truth to what I’ve been learning, the more I’ve become familiar with all of this, the more amazing it has become.
I didn’t think you were suggesting that… I just thought you were stating it for the sake of argument (which I do often).
It’s hard for me to accept this since I think the church is either dead or being practiced by such a small group that it could not possibly reach a large audience.
But I see your point… theoretically, the church is the body of Christ, the body is the flesh and the flesh is weak which should be beaten and made a slave to the spiritual needs of the head (Christ). This sustenance is gained through the spiritual energy (the Holy Spirit) which allows us to remain within “God.†At least, that was the doctrine that was taught by the faithful disciples of Jesus.
Think of the many times that Jesus was taken aside by his disciples for questions and how Jesus would turn around and talk to the whole group. Think of when Peter took Jesus aside to rebuke him and then Jesus says get behind me Satan… he turns and speaks to his disciples. Jesus was rarely alone (typically he had to get away from the disciples so he could pray)
And also remember Jesus asked the question to all his disciples: MATTHEW 16:13-15.
Then in Matthew 20 he spoke to the group again:
But I was saying that it could be argued (not that it was fact). When I imagine this man Jesus talking outdoors surrounded by people I guess i envision Jesus talking first about Peter then about himself…
You know… even though I am agnostic I must tend to agree that the bible has many teachings that go beyond the literal interpretation. One of the great things about ILP is that I learned more about that particular issue here than I had in the past few years.
I fully comprehend the ‘power’ that can be found by a faithful follower of Christ when this person revisits the words (essense) of their lord. It is amazing the effect it can have over people (most often for the positive though sometimes for the negative).
I find the scriptures pretty amazing too–though from a different perspective.
I don’t believe that real Christianity was ever intended for a large audience. The world is against it as it must be since it struggles against its natural progressions. The change of energy creates Christendom which is really all we are exposed to at the surface. Actually the way of the antichrist is universal acceptance of egotistic interpretation. It will sound wonderful, loving, humane, and all the rest. It just denies the energy of the Holy spirit which will result in , after all the “wonderfulness” has run its course, the reaction of the lawful opposite in accordance with natural law.
I know this is the usual belief but it just is IMO a lawful degeneration of the truth into duality. The body isn’t supposed to be a slave but just not dominate. it must be well taken care of. Even Buddha when experimenting with asceticism gave up on it.
What makes it most offensive is that it appears to close the mind leading to dogmatism when taken wrongly. The real purpose of self denial or renunciation is to open the mind by making the bodily demands secondary. the body benefits from this as well since it is receiving this higher energy of the spirit. No slavery or good or bad here; just the attempt to have the parts of the human organism function as a whole where each part is performing its rightful function and the unconscious body must become the respected servant (not slave) to the conscious will.
Jesus was teaching both the group and its individuals. Certain teaching was only for individuals since it was appropriate for their level of understanding. Consider from the Gospel of Thomas:
Thomas wasn’t hero worshipping and admitted that what he felt was beyond description. So he was ready to be spoken to privately.
Yes I believe that the living church is the image of the body of Christ which contains within it different actualized levels of understanding. These levels of understanding are transitions of understanding an individual must pass through covering the span between the supplicant and divine king all existing within ones “being”. The way of salvation is the way of tradition or being “asleep” in the body and is the long way covering the span of the aeon itself… Access to the kingdom is through the development of the soul or re-birth.
However, as I’ve discovered it, there are three basic levels that exist in culture. The first is the exoteric which is just normal culture and consists of the great majority of what has been referred to in all the great traditions in one way or another as unawakened. The other extreme is the esoteric which exists within the exoteric unnoticed. The esoteric has actualized what the great traditions have spoken of and are few in number. In the middle is the mesoteric layer which consists of people that understand intellectually say on the level of Peter, but have not achieved the emotional realization. The esoteric church helps to awaken the spiritual emotion. The visible functioning’s and politics of the church is exoteric. Yet it can and has included within it the great Christian mystics that have had the experiences similar to Paul. It is the Church’s responsibility to allow people to grow without as yet having had such experiences but the real teaching begins at the mesoteric layer which is the beginning of “understanding”.
There is this fashionable trend to unite Judaism and Christianity in ways that defeat the purpose by ignoring the distinction between grace and law in relation to the “good” that is the goal of the “truth”. From the Journal of Father Sylvan:
Hi Dr. Nick! (sorry, Simpsons joke–I couldn’t help it)
See, I think it was intended for a large audience… but perhaps you meant that it was not intended for everyone since the path is narrow? The goal, as instructed to the disciples, was to preach to message to all nations (read Matthew 28:18-20).
Sorry, I forget that sometimes we are taken literally. I am familiar with the intentions behind the statement and you are right, it isn’t that the body should be a slave (in a traditional master/slave role) it is that the body should not make the final decisions on things like sex before marriage, the want for debauchery, etc.
The real purpose of self denial or renunciation is to open the mind by making the bodily demands secondary.
[/quote]
I can agree that this was the intent.
This is a pretty good outlook on Christianity and it is certainly, in my opinion, closer to the original doctrine of the bible than we find in many Christian denominations today.
Which could explain why there are so many denominations that focus on one particular doctrine or set of doctrines. Very good–I like this idea.
Have you found any group of persons that are practicing what is taught in this living church? Just curious…
Nick, it is a pleasure discussing these issues with you.
I also appreciate a discussion that doesn’t degenerate into name calling so it’s a pleasure discussing these issues with you as well.
Was the intent to preach the message?:
Baptizing with the Holy Spirit is not something anyone can do. Even John the Baptist couldn’t. It is the result of re-birth and not throwing water on someone but comes from someone experiencing “presence” of the re-born. The apostles didn’t follow Jesus because of any preaching. They felt his presence which allowed them to experience what they were psychologically searching for. Teaching to all nations means not to exclude. The teaching is open to anyone but it is as you said “narrow”. it also is unwanted by the majority. The only reason to teach details is when people have felt the value of the teaching. Consider Matthew 24:
Doesn’t imply a warm welcome of milk and cookies.
It has to be this way because since Jesus contradicts man’s egotism. That is indeed a “string em up” offense.
I believe so. My path I believe puts me on the fringe of it. There are many branches flowing from the same root. It really is just sublime common sense. I’ve been fortunate to get to know many with different cultural labels in a setting where labels don’t mean anything in the reality of the human psych in relation to spiritual potential.
I’ve experienced the “presence” of people who have grown. It has allowed me the experience of a quality of being I normally do not have access to.
I do think the intent was to preach (think of when Jesus sends out the 70 (or 72) disciples to preach). Also, I don’t think you were supposed to baptize WITH the holy spirit, only in the name of the holy ghost. Baptizing WITH the holy ghost was reserved for the day at Pentecost and was done only by the laying on of hands by the apostles. Let us look at the scripture more closely:
This is something that should be actively done… to paraphrase: go teach all nations to observe what I have commanded you baptizing them in the name of GOD (possibly the trinity?). Do you think this is a fair assessment?
Still, this does not mean that they should not preach and that Jesus did not instruct them to preach. Can’t it be argued that Jesus preached that the world would indeed reject their message because it is the message of Jesus? In other words, or more directly–> the world will reject the disciples because they will preach the word of Jesus to the world and then the world will persecute them.
Also, Matthew 24 mentions that MANY will turn away from their faith. Also that MANY false prophets would deceive MANY people (not necessarily those faithful to the truth). So, I think it is plausible to argue that the intent was to take this message to many throughout the nations.
The papacy has always been foolish at best. The church for centuries was guilty of selling indulgences. Catholic priests were not always forbidden to marry or have ‘women’ i.e. little boys. It was St. Augustine, I believe, who changed these rules. Who knows why. Probably couldn’t even get a date with one of those homely looking nuns.
The bottom line is this: The Catholic Church has been anything but the rock of stability a true religion should be. Therefore is it any wonder that there are historical inconsistencies?
If a person is running from a wounded bear in the woods is this an action or a reaction? IMO it is a reaction.
Preaching can be either active or passive. Christianity is about consciousness, presence, re-birth. If it is spoken of unconsciously and without presence it only is an expression of the head or literal understanding. This form of speech is reactive or passive. Active expression is done while in a conscious state of presence…
Head talk only reaches the head of another. Some sort of “expert” can give a wonderful speech and people will be oohing and ahhing about world peace and the like. But this only reaches the head since it originates with the head. Lacking consciousness it is reactive expression. As soon as someone grabs someone else’s behind, the usual breaks out again and that’s the end of “everybody loves everybody”.
A man of real understanding speaks from the understanding of his being or the totality of himself. In this way his presence gives life to the spoken word and is able to touch the being of another. The effect is not as much public oohing and ahhing but a more subtle understanding that is beyond appearance and touching “being”. This is the result of conscious presence so it is active.
It is not a spite thing against Jesus. Experts attempting to secularize Christianity will turn it around and people will think its is wonderful since it is flattering the ego. They will say :“now we are hearing the true message.” What is rejected is not as a result of Jesus but is the result of people not wanting to awaken and one of the most despised if not the most hated mechanical device ever created is the alarm clock.
Taking the message is one thing but expressing it with conscious presence that has gone beyond egotistic limitations is another. Secularism stresses the quantity of belief while Christianity stresses the quality of understanding in regards the essence of man and his relationship to the above and below. To express quality of presence one must gradually grow to become more than a talking head living in self deception.
Nick, passive or active is irrelevant–meaning that one must LIVE it (actively or passively). So, if some choose to do their preaching by passively LIVING a life that does good works or by actively chasing prospective souls it is still a “doing”. The command is to go (the how to get there, the when, and the where are not as important. Now, we know the why, and the who (why? for god, who? all nations).
I don’t think this necessarily means go beating down your neighbor’s door and telling him to change his life towards Jesus. So, I understand what you mean by speaking “…from the understanding od his being…” I think I see this in you and in BOB here at ILP.
Peace and prosperity to you and all those like you.
You are assuming that a person can LIVE it. You believe you have this choice. You don’t. The reactions of a sleeping person are dictated by external influences. A person can begin with good intentions and gradually they will change in accordnce with external circumstances and can even become their opposite.
If a person begins to “preach” as you say without having inwardly grown, he becomes an “expert” or as described collectively in the Bible as the Pharisees. Preaching on this level just does more harm than good. I’ll post the whole of Matthew 23. It is there to be seen for those willing to look. I’m beginning to believe that the calling to become and “expert” is too strong to let the depth of its contents sink in.
This “preaching” is not a “doing” but a “happening” of a dangerous kind.