I’m going off a hunch here, but in the Christian tradition is there, or has there been, a tradition which purposefully limits intellectuality?
Essentially, this stems from an idea I once had, that the mind, when indulged in too much, inhibits Being, it inhibits one’s experience of life, one’s joie de vivre.
According to how Eusebius (1st Church Historian - 4th c.) speaks of early Christians, those with the highest training in philosophy, in the Greek Sciences, and those that could intellectually expound The Divine Scriptures, were considered the cream of the crop. Intellect was valued back then.
They expect joie de vivre in the next life.
But it is true that Christianity is very hard on sexual joie de vivre.
To adopt an unfamiliar use of language, I would say that God isintellect. A thought, an idea, a conception. Yet it can’t be attained as such, so it involves practice. Rules, morality, how to act, how to be, what to do. In this mode of Being, you are more atune to the wishes of your God as opposed to some silly monk that locks himself away from the outside world.
Well…a historian is an intellectual so he would say that…
Being a General, would you really advise all of your privates to work out their own strategy in the midst of a war or have faith in their leaders? Those who can’t faithfully team up, face the worst of the worst… alone.
Yeah, the Bible advises against trying to be intellectual unless trained in the art of spiritual (psychological) war games, just as any Shaolin temple; “Have no gods before Me!”.
On religion and the psyche. James of the NT argues that external (to the body) wars come from conflicts within the psyche. If the human psyche can be described as comprised of mind, body and spirit, James’ description appears to me to make more sense than Plato’s argument for a soul imprisoned in a body awaiting release.
Except it was historical characters in his historical accounts that were considering those early Christians educated in philosophy as the cream of the corp.
The “Genesis” story of creation in the Garden of Eden may be a metaphoric description of the creation of the human psyche. Serpent=brain base; Eve=midbrain; Adam=prefrontal cotex. It’s a description of the triune brain. That may be why the story still speaks to us, not because of the problem of disobedience, but because of the problem of uniting the three aspects of the human psyche.
Serpent=basic drives; Eve=emotional input; Adam =rational mind (naming of the animals etc.) As a story of simple disobedience, the creation story fails in several ways.
Apologies if I’m taking a broader view of mind/body interactions that your OP warrants.
Or it could be utter nonsense, I personally would imagine it is merely the ramblings of some bemused itinerant peasant in an attempt to make sense of ontology…
“Every blade of grass, every bird in flight is important to the wise leader.”
Kiergegaard did. I can’t recall an anti-intellectual Christian scholar before him. The Church has traditionally been pro-intellectual, especially compared to non-Greek, non-monotheistic faiths.
If anything, churches kicked it all into high gear with monks copying all those books and then you got all these religious universities and religious schools. I’m sure in between, at some point, that the educated people were the ones in the churches. They were the ones that were doing the reasoning while the cave people kept on in the caves trying to keep a fire going. This isn’t to say that there haven’t been intellectual movements that might have been counter to the views or desires of religious groups, but I think to suggest that religion suppresses intellectualism is a bit of a stretch. I mean besides…the statement is such a blanket one. Blanket statements almost never hold up to scrutiny.
There is the Catholic Christian and the Christian who formed their own thoughts about morality, those who would not accept immoral laws applied by the Catholic Church to cause or enable morality, as it went against the truth of Christian love and a loving, kind, caring life is a life that supports spiritual truth.
As God is the creator and the so “called” intellect as the spirit causing the creative condition, it was accepted that only God knew the creative function and that human kind has no purpose trying to understand the applications, as they realized that this type of thinking only caused disasters and plagues. Humanity learnt not to change Nature.
I don’t think the catholic Church is in any position to judge anyone given their appalling record on human rights, and their recent sex scandals but in principle they can say whatever they like, if it makes sense there’s an outside chance people will at least give them there attention if not their obedience.
There are Catholics and there are Protestants and then there are the plane bat fuck insane none of the above sects.
There is a thread of anti-intellectualism in Christianity at least going back to Paul who said in I Corinthians:
Notice that under the category wisdom he includes Greek philosophy. However, V is correct and some of the so-called Church fathers considered themselves philosophers. Theology became necessary for the church and can be considered professional philosophers. So, Christianity has been ambivalent toward intellectualism.
A potentially helpful context is that he is quoting from Isiah - that’s where it is written…
and in Isiah it is referring to a response, by God I presume, to those who know the Words and perform the right actions, but whose hearts are wrong. So stipping THEM of their wisdom is revealing what they really are. Rather than it being something that is a general attack on wisdom.
Here’s the Isaiah…
IOW it is not an antiintellectual program - for example to remove the intellects of people because they do not Believe or so they can Believe.
Historical evidence has already been realized in Biblical information via its archaeological implied statements. Philosophers, who obviously use their own principles involving thinking would imply religious ideals regarding their own selves. Therefore they were documenting astronomical situations along with human historical evidence, plus the archaeological situation that supported wisdom.
How does anyone imply wisdom…other than through the methods which intellect has always implied wisdom involves, this would involve the study of archaeological evidence, astronomical evidence, situation involvement and human Philosophical arguments. Therefore the Philosopher was discussing what the different philosophies involved as far as intellectual discovery…only because Philosophers shared their wisdom amongst many different countries cultural beliefs. As the Greek Philosophers were called Khristos or Christos and the Roman Jesuits from Jewish influences Jesus, the Jesus Christ influence involved the Teachers of a new spiritual awareness.
Through their own discoveries they were made aware that God in either situation is far superior than human intellect…the situation of predictions correlated this fact, where because of the use of sound techniques (which I know you argue about) as Levis (levitation), they knew that they had altered harmonic sound and the timed intervals causing time as a fallout to factor 22 as Revelations instead of the correct intervals of 24 as a timed situation. They therefore proved this through the evidence that they had correlated.
For any of us in common day to question their methods, causes us to research ancient Philosophers, to review in their writings that they were actually studying archaeological evidence through natural disasters.
Hence if Scientists applied a mass removal of oxygen from the atmosphere to support a frequency for nuclear conversion of the radiated stone uranium, they dropped out of the atmosphere a timed interval that related to the factor of 24. Although we are still alive, we are less alive than what we were during the 1800s (due to oxygenated pathways no longer active in cell life) via wavelength depletion. The Philosophers had predicted that 2012 as a timed interval event would have replaced the oxygen mass loss they had caused as Revelation 22 via their calculations of predictions. We lost this Christ holy spirit return body due to Scientists removing it from our Earth Heaven angelic sound frequencies to form nuclear frequencies for conversions. Therefore although we have a clock ticking for 24 hours of life, we are living a loss of life in this 24 hour situation and it could define a loss of God itself, as God represented a value of 20 in the LAW of THE WORD OF GOD. We may be in position 19.
This would be because we did not gain 2012 mass, a total of 1 was removed involving PHI harmonics of squaring involving a HOUSE = uranium…this would be a removal of 4.
NASA involved with testing PHI sound harmonics through their satellite system began to create a higher fall out (UFO bodies of angelic sound), decreasing the timed value 20. Applying the collider would have removed us to a position of another 1 total body loss. Therefore we could be in 18 or 19 as a prophetic Revelation situation via Biblical numbers.
But then there is the reality that these Numbers were factored as predicted events of timed intervals based on Uranium being intact as a created body or cell in the stone. Therefore the timed intervals would no longer actually apply to Biblical Standards, as this is what they were predicted on as values in Sun Time 144,000.
Proving that the Philosophers had actually created timed intervals as an alpha beta situation through the alphabet is via the following fact. As PHI relates to harmonics, harmonics relate to sine frequencies or KEYS, as sound evidence factored through numerical sequences. As the Stone Law is Moses as 2 Tablets the Law 40 is stated hence 20-20. The following demonstrates the secret letter function of using LETTERS with NUMERICAL VALUES. To gain the KEY, it is observed that G for GOD begins the sequence.
GH I J K L MNOP QRST UVWX Y Z as the first 20
AB CD E FG H IJ K LMN OPQR S T (20)
UVWX Y ZA BCD E FGH IJ KL MN (20)
OPQR S TU VWX Y ZAB CD EFGH (20)
The Philosophers therefore understood the values of timed intervals, and knew that by applying sound techniques as per Giza Pyramid/Temples display, that they had carbonized the Earth stone by burning holes into it through applications of alchemy conversion called LEVIS or levitation practices. As archaeology has provided the evidence of human artifacts, the reality explains that they cannot actually carbon date the time when these human beings lived, only because whenever they used stone conversion techniques in their own scientific pursuits, they caused carbonisation also. Therefore in human historical evidence there has been many times when human beings have carbonised the Earth stone, losing their lives through natural disasters because they drop out the oxygen mass in the atmosphere.
When Scientists reapplied the conversion of uranium, they also dropped out a huge oxygen mass in the atmosphere to create nuclear frequencies. Human and Nature, lost many pathways in the wavelengths for oxygenation pathways to be activated and our cellular/life situation changed, as we have all witnessed. Scientists have been burning holes through irradiated signals once again into Earth’s stone body. These holes fill with lava and then eventually the radiated signal in the atmosphere is stopped. Eventually the mass of oxygen has been allowed to be replaced and this happens over a very long time period. This is how we de evolved and then re evolved due to this circumstance. The evidence is the massive UFO angelic body fall out, and no one can deny this witnessing event worldwide.