The Failure Of Subjective Relativism by Relativism

The Failure of Subjective Relativism by Relativism

The observer is relative to what is observed thus the observer is not fixed.

Subjective Relativism requires the observer as the fixed point, thus requires the observer as absolute thus contradicting Subjective Relativism.

True Relativism would simultaneously reveal the object as fixed and the subject as not-fixed thus revealing subjectivism as indefinite on its own terms.

From one point the subject is relative, from another the object is relative, what remains absolute is the application of the boundaries of context itself as context is invariant by degree of ever present boundaries.

Again, this ALWAYS depends on whether the observer is ‘looking from’ the subjective perspective only or from the objective perspective as well, obviously.

That seems an interesting topic.
I searched the two terms to understand what they actually refer to. In simple words, relativism considers that morality, truth, knowledge etc depend on the individual or a group of people (society), while subjective relativism focuses only on the individual.

For all practical purposes, relativism is what societies promote. They can pretend that they promote objective truths, however the difference between the truths of various communities show otherwise.

From my point of view (Epicurean approach on ethics), subjective relativism works as philosophy as long as the individual is prepared to face the consequences (good or bad) of its choices.

I can strongly believe in the “eye for an eye” idea of justice. Noone can convince me otherwise. Implementing that though in my life means that I go against the justice system of my society. Am I prepared to accept the consequences?

1 Like

So can everyone else. But, if everyone did, then everyone would be blind.

Again, while ‘you’ hold and maintain a belief there is NOT a single thing in the whole entire Universe, including even the Universe Itself, that could show or ‘convince’ ‘you’ otherwise. As I keep saying and proving irrefutably True through ‘these people’ here.

Well, if ‘you’ are NOT prepared to be open and honest, and listen to others, then ‘an eye for an eye’, as some say, is the consequence.

wrong thread, apologies.

The observer depends on the observed, otherwise it ceases to be the observer.

Under true Relativism, the observer or the observed can be a fixed point.

Consequences, fundamentally ‘effects’, can occur from any point.

The subject can produce effects.

The object can produce effects.

Effects remain; they are the limits from the relative reference point so what remains, regardless of subject or object fixed point is the limits of the event.

In these respects relative and absolute reality both occur.

Yes, that is true. However, equating your morality with the morality of your society has less risks of social punishment (legal actions against you, isolation etc) than developing your own moral codes that perhaps deviate from the popular ones.

1 Like

Well, considering the Fact that the Universe ALWAYS EXISTS, ‘the observed’ is ALWAYS HERE, to be observed.

Who cares?

Are ‘you’ trying to make a point here?

If yes, then what it ‘is’, EXACTLY?

Prevention of ostracism, punishment, etc is a meta-moral system as value is placed on group identity and the morals, way of being, to maintain that group identity.

Effectively this results in an identity value system, within the system:

  1. Identity derived via P (punishment, ostracism, etc. as individual)

  2. Identity derived via G (part of the group).

  3. Identity subsumed as G containing P (individual reacting to group)

  4. Identity subsumed as P containing G (group reacting to individual)

And what remains of identity is the boundary of context application, which identity contains the other by the other reacting to it and thus forming an identity at some scale.

Relativism remains.

If the universal always exists then by default existence is indistinct…what do you mean by existence given you use an indistinct term?

If the universe can be observed, than by default, due to relativity, the observer is dependent upon the universe as well and one cannot place the focal point on the observer.

I never used the word ‘existence’ here. Only ‘you did’.

‘you’ might well not be able to, but ‘I’ CERTAINLY CAN.

So the universe is not subject to existence?

If that is what you believe is absolutely true, then okay.