The Spanish Civil War

Considering that it is probably THE most politically diverse conflict in recent memory, and that it included anarchists, communists, democrats, fascists, nacional socialists, royalist monarchists and all sorts of shades of gray on presque equal footing (well, equal enough to have a war), it should be of great interest to many here.

I’ve done a lot of research on this throughout my life, so here is a bit of a summary of how it all went down:

Pre-1936 Spain: In 1923, the last monarchy was overthrown by a brutal military regime. After a while of this, political unrest led them to resign on 1930 and give birth, so to speak, to the new and democratic Spanish Republic. Much of the unrest had been due to the left in Spain: communists, socialists, pseudo-anarchists, etc, so it is not surprising that the left-leaning Niceto Alcalá-Zamora was elected first. What followed was a progressively violent back-and-forth of power between economically awkward leftists and militarily heavy-handed rightists. Alliances were formed and populations were polarized until

in 1936, the basically unanimously rightist top echelons of the military wing of the Republic decided that they had lost elections to the leftists for the last time. The top guy died in an airplane crash when moving from wherever he was to wherever he planned to stage the coup from, so the baton fell to the undesciferable (I think colonel at that time, can someone correct me so I can edit the info in?) Francisco Franco, who was stationed with his troops in some northern province in Africa. He phoned up the German Furer who promptly sent over some planes to get them into Spain (lol, the rain in Spain…). Thus the right, including everybody from oldskool monarchists to italian-style fascist falangists, made its choice, and they had the guy to get it done. This uprising was supposed to be a quick coup, but nobody counted on…

The semi-organized leftist forces of the republic! (this, btw, is why the leftists where known as the republicans and the rightists as the nationalists.) First of all, although all the top-top guys where basically fascists, many of the lower-tier officers and privates where loyal to the republic, many of them even being leftists themselves; so the government had it’s own, alas less disciplined, armed forces.

Aside from this, the whole world was at this moment split between leftists and rightists and, even though the fascists had support from the likes of Hitler and Mussolini, the left had support from grass-roots volunteers willing to fight for an ideology (George Orwell among them). In fact, most of the inicial warfare fell in the hands, not of the professional army, but of organized militias with heavy international support ranging from stalinist communists (who recieved aid from the soviets and who Orwell loved criticizing) to purest-of-the-pure anarchists.

And so, what was supposed to be a quick and painless coup turned into the most interesting war ever had from a political perspective, lasting almost three years.

Wikipedia list of Republican factions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republican_faction_(Spanish_Civil_War)

Wikipedia list of Nationalist factions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Faction_(Spanish_Civil_War)

(In the interest of objectivism, I will admit that the Falange had the coolest flag)

And then what happened? In purely military terms, this: [youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hhsBNeyZDAs[/youtube] Ignore the Spanish, just look at the arrows and colored areas: Republican territory is green, National territory is red and the arrows represent military action. Madrid, at the center, was the main objective and was held by Republicans until the bitter end.

It is easy to tell that the Nationalists basically ploughed through Republican lines, always gaining and never retreating. The nationalist force was led by a single guy, eventually named Generalísimo (literally: Extremely-General or Very-Very-General) Francisco Franco. “Go here and do this, this way” would say Franco, and it would be done. The republicans, well, they were a loose confederation of militias, some of them so anarchist that they didn’t have leaders period. The comparatively shitty organizational capacity of the Republic led the government to eventually outlaw militias, attempting to force anarchists and communists alike to simply join the state army and obey a unified command, achieving instead an internal state of strife that weakened cooperation of forces even more. Anarchists were mostly regionally based anyways, radiating from Barcelona (the capital of a region of Spain that has always been and still is equivalent to Scotland in the UK: they want to be autonomous). When the Nationalists finally squashed the Anarchist resistance in Barcelona, the anarchists where almost out of the picture. Otherwise, they clung to the anarcho-syndicalist CNT militia group.

So, from a military point of view, a long held ILP myth is validated here: Anarchists will never be able to thrive as long as immense, centrilized state armies are willing to squash them.

However, once Franco won and got started, two other myths become validated: All statists are back-stabing sneaky bastards who would drop a life-long alliance at the drop of a hat. Also, that all fascists regimes are systematically opressive, coercive, and homicidal.

That’s correct. So long as government exists anarchists will forever be harrassed.

Great historical introduction Pezer.

¡Viva la Falange / nacionalistas!

Nah I’m not really serious on that bit, oddly though as I see it now even with such a myriad of politcal factions, I can’t say I have much support for any of them, I’d have to study more on it.

I’m both aware and ignorant of the Spanish civil War, on one hand I’m sure i’m one of the few Americans who is even aware that it occured, on the other hand beyond the generalites that you wrote in this thread I know little about it.

Other than that the Nazis and Fascists of Germany and Italy respectively sent military aid (and essentially testing their new weaponry) to the Fallangist/Nationalists.
With Stalin and Communists,Leftists,anarchists from around the world volunteering for the fight(including the Abraham Lincoln Brigade :smiley:)

And J.R.R Tolkien getting mad at C.S. Lewis for sympathising with the Republicans, as they had been known to drag priests out of churches and shoot em in the head (Tolkien being a Catholic didn’t take too kindly to that.).

Also thanks for using the word Myth in a semi-correct way,instead of just using it as a synonym for an “untrue story” as so many people do.

Yeah, it was the cruelest of confrontations between the left and the right possible in a civilized society. Priests where seen as part of the right, as leaders in their own way, and were considered responsible for the percieved attrocities of rightism. They where executed like enemy combatants, like bishops in chess. They also (the Republicans), in anarchist Barcelona for example, started blood feuds and revenge killings that took the life of many.

On the other hand, Republicans never really even approached the level of sophistication in torture and systematic killing that the Nationalists had, precicely because of their discipline and unified command.

It was not entirely a anarchist civil war as quite a few Communists and Marxists were involved however there was quite a few anarchists in the known ranks that were cooperating within the rebellions.

Some isolated anarchist syndicalist towns were set up in the absence of government control although.

They were reasonably successful until the government destroyed them.

In my opinion the anarchists made their mistake cooperating with the Communists and Marxists.

I agree. But it is hard not to ally yourself with whoever you can when the armies of Mordor approach. The only alliance possible with Mordor is enslavement.

Alliance out of necessity because of a common enemy? Perhaps, however the enemy of your enemy is not always your friend.

I remember in an older post you talked about communism being necessary for there to be Order, what changed in your mind that you stop caring about Order?