Theory

I am young and theres probly alot of faults in here but tell me what you think.

Theory on reincarnation

Throughout the years man has looked to solve all mysteries. The biggest mystery still has not been solved yet though: what happens when we die? Through science and reason this mystery can be solved. Through reason we can come to the conclusion that if you believe in life after death, then you believe in life before death and the fact that we are just animals. It is through science that we can determine everything is made out of particles.

When we die, we break down and decompose. Hence our particles get scattered everywhere. We are made up of things that used to be alive and things that were never alive. So the question plagues us: if we are made up just from matter how is it that life produced? Some may say that a distinct pattern of molecules may cause life, but this doesn’t suggest why we are individually controlled and how we all have personalities. Additionally, why one formation would make us have a different sense of being if we’re all composed of the same thing. If our sperm didn’t get chosen we would not exist. If another one was picked instead, you would not exist(which makes sense because it is a fact that things are made in your body from the things you consume, so sperm are made out of the things you consume, so something you consume must contain something that can make life). Someone else would in your place. Therefore, this means there has to be a different makeup for every sperm. Everyone contains a different particle so it would make sense that if a different sperm got picked that other particle would be chosen to become a bigger living organism. So why is this?

If each sperm contained a particle or something even smaller that was even minimally different from the composition of others, it would cause a difference in your sense of being. Hence, this particle would technically be you sense of being.

Now there is the same relative mass on the earth at the beginning of time as compared to now. As a result, life would be a cycle. You would be born, die, break down until you were reborn and the chain starts over again. Relating to the first law of thermodynamics energy cannot be lost or created, only transferred. The same concept can be applied to particles. This means the particles energy is never ending, death is caused by the breaking down of carbons in your body so this particle is not actually been destroyed just the bonds are being broken but the energy is still there in the particle (everything is just chemicals).

The particle, the body and the mind work as a machine for the particle. The particle simply works a battery. When you decompose, you don’t have a brain so you can’t feel anything. You might be floating around in limbo for millions of years before you are made into something again. You wouldn’t have the slightest clue of who you were. All the memories and ideas that were in the machine of your brain and when the brain decomposes, all the bonds are broken and all the information that you have obtained is lost. You could be born into anything that has the ability to think, but be born with none of your old morals or traits. DNA and environment influences this, all your particle does is act simply as a battery and give you a sense of being. For example: if your body was a factory, DNA would be the blueprints, your body would be the parts to the machine and the particle is the battery. Your body consumes these particles and sends them to your reproductive organs, for females they just get disposed. Now that your particle is part of a sperm (living organism) with the blueprint, it has to do one thing, make contact with an egg to make a chemical reaction to produce a larger organism. If the sperm makes contact a chemical reaction occurs in the egg and both the DNA strands are combined and a new organism is to be formed, the cycle continues. Consequently, what you do in your life time doesn’t matter whether you’re good or bad, there is no heaven and hell.

My reasons for not believing in heaven and hell are: someone born in a bad household raised with bad morals will turn out to be a somewhat of a bad kid. Alternatively, what god would put a person in hell for being born in a bad situation? The same could be said for location. If you were raised in a closed area like China which has the belief of Buddhism, you will not get a chance to choose your religion. To think that the ruler of the universe will run to my assistance and bend the laws of nature for me is the height of arrogance. That implies that everyone else (such as the opposing football team, driver, student, parent) is de-selected, un-favored by God, and that I am special, above it all. To think a good merciful God would cause such mass killing on his so called children is ridiculous(quote by Dan Barker). But the main reason for my not believing is we are just animals, just like everything else, to think the savior would come to us in human form rather than any other form. Humans have constantly held themselves higher then everything else, animals do not pray, why? They don’t need to. In the tsunami not one animal body has been found yet. This is because of natural instinct. They ran to higher ground while humans stayed on the ground and prayed and got washed away. The Current Pope, the reprehensive of God has had cancer and an ongoing battle against Parkinson’s and is in poor health at the age of 84. The particle theory can defend everything about it. Whether it be what happens when you die, you decompose and your particles scatter around, how you are born, you are consumed by a living organism .

Really? :wink:

When we die, our bodies break down and decompose. This is what happens to the physicaol body after death. Many of us here; however, also believe in the existence of a soul. I’d go so far to say that I personally believe that death is the result of the soul seperating from the body.

Please define what you mean by “limbo”. Are you refferring to the intermitten state in between when the body dies (and thus, is broken back down again into particles) and when the particles are “remade into life”. ?
:confused:

Please explain this also. I don’t see how you came to this conclusion (Logically) based upon the premises of your argument.

Not necessarily. In theory, it is still quite possible that a child raised in such a manner could turn out to be a “good” kid rather than a “bad” kid as an adult.

A perfectly righteous and Just God could and would. According to the teaching of the Bible, all men are born with a sinfull nature, and thus, are deserving hell.

But, you could, in theory, move out of such a country in latter life, and convert to whatever religion you liked.

The Bible explicitly states" “…And God said, ‘I will have mercy upon whom I will have mercy’…”. God owes humanity nothing. He is God; he makes the rules. And, since he is infintely wise and we are finite, I think that it is possible that we may not have the ability to comprehend what is “really” fair. Because, at the end of the day, if we allways know that what God says goes, then fairness really becomes an irelavent issue, anyways.

You had some interesting and well-thought out thoughts. You also seem to have a fairly good grasp on Science. Thanks for posting. :slight_smile:

Its funny, I watched a documentary on the Davinci Code the other night, and ever since when I come to these forums and see someone quote the bible I think of it. Its really amazing to know just how much of the gospels, of what it supposedly Christ’s philosophy, his words, were actually not put into the bible, and just how much of it the Christain church either suppressed or destroyed, because it didn’t fit they’re views. They actually hunted down and killed every last member that comprimised of an entire religion. It seems the bible that you hold so dearly to be the word of god is so very far from it. The holy trinity, was a concept that a councel got together and agreed on. Anyways I still can’t believe that people accept the bible so easily, when even history tells the tale that the majority of Christs philosophy did not make the cut. It seems it was tailor made to fit a certain idea. Now as for the old testement… well looking at the history of the new testement, you can’t really accept that either can u?

The davinci code is heresy of the highest order. I have read the davinici code, and I found virtually no part of it that could be considered accurate. The davininci code is not a vallid authority on Christianity and the Christian teachings. It takes Christian bielfs, and twists them ever so slightly to create notions that are completely different. The davinici code makes fiction of truth. It tries to state that there are contradictions where no contradictions exist. it is [b]fiction[/i].

My Muslim friend (he is a PhD. He teaches world religious at the local university) would admit to me that his knowledge of Islam does not make him more of an authority on Islam than the Koran is.

Same thing goes for Christianity. If you want to know about the Christian belielfs, you read the Bible. Not a book by Dan Brown. I’m happy to debate/defend the vallidity of Christianity with you in another thread if you would like, but I refuse to even bring the davinici code into the argument. The Christianity of which Dan Brown speaks does, indeed, have contradictions, etc. But the Christianity of the Bible does not.

…okay, sorry about the rant…I got a little carried away there. :wink:

which bible? in the original hebrew and greek?

if you do not have the original, you have someone’s interpretation…

-Imp

I’ll settle for any non-paraphrased translation of the current cannonized scripture so long as it has been accurately translated. Last I checked, the English Standard Version is one of the most accurate of the translations. But even an NIV or King James translation is more authorotative than the writings of a novelist. :wink:

what i will NOT accept is someone who interprets the Bible inccorrectly, and then claims that his interpration is the truth. Translantion and Interpretaion are two different things,

I truly believe, that although have a point of sorts, you have to scientifically completely disprove the existence of the soul. because until you can logically PROVE that there is no such thing as a soul, then you have no grounds to disprove a heaven of any sort, what’s more, even if you can logically prove your theory correct that does not lead to the conclusion that we can be good or bad…
furthermore, lots of the more subatomic level science is hypothesis rather than fact, you can’t disregard entirely one hypothesis with another, however you did say it was a theory, so fair enough.
Good effort, if you deal with the sould problem, at least a little, then you 'll be better off!!

that’s the point, you cannot know if it has been accurately translated

how do you know the story you believe isn’t a lie?

-Imp

You have to ask yourself what is MORE likely: our identities are supported by our bodies and brains, or, our identities are beyond the physical and last forever.

BMW might say identity is not soul. I defy him to give a clear definition of soul. Without a clear definition, it seems silly to maintain that it’s evident.

Our desire to live on, and our pull toward identity maintenance, are both deeply ingrained in us and have survival value. I think these tremendous forces are unfairly used as evidence for something that has no scientific support. Clearly the burden of evidence is on those that believe in soul and afterlife. And there is no such evidence. Just a wish. I wish it, too, but I see living with tranquilizing fallacious beliefs as a missed opportunity, so I choose to except the strong possibility that life and perception are finite, and I’m the better man for it.

Gamer,

“You have to ask yourself what is MORE likely: our identities are supported by our bodies and brains, or, our identities are beyond the physical and last forever.”

This is a very good way of putting it. But are not our conceptions governed by our metaphors? At one time we are compared to a fire burning. Then we are compared to a watch ticking. Now we are compared to a computer computing. What of the case of a wave breaking? Is a wave’s identity “supported” (I suppose you mean reducible to) by its body, or is its identity beyond the “physical” (in this case the immediate water of which it is made)? Or is it entire composed by the mind witnessing it?

Dunamis

BMW-Guy,

I would ask you to re-consider your position on biblical “accuracy”. The real answer is that you believe the bible to be the inspired word of God. Plain and simple. Don’t get off in arguing the accuracy or contradictions in ANY text. It’s a lose-lose proposition. There are myriad interpretations and contradictions contained in the bible. If you don’t like what you read in the Davinci Code, just say that. Calling it heresy, inaccurate, and self-contradictory goe’s no where.

JT

The accuracy of the Bible is another issue in and of itself. I merely mean to argue that the Bible is far more authoritative on giving the things that Christians really believe. Dan Brown seems to have convinved many people that he has some “hidden” truths of the Christian’s beliefs. Regardless of whether or not the Bible or the davinci code is actually true, one should still be able to recognize that the davinci code is not the text on which the religion of Chrostianity is founded upon. The davinci code attempts to show Christianity to be something that is really is not. If it did not do this, it (the davinci code) would be in coherence to the teachings of the Bible.

And, don’t worry. I know just how futile and tiresome those “Biblical contradictions” threads can be. I, like you, do not intend to go there. :wink:

I’ll get back to you guys on the definition of the soul issue. I’m running short on time…:wink:

I may be wrong, but I think the point BMW-Guy wanted to express was completely different than not liking the Davinci Code. If he thinks it’s self-contradictory and inaccurate, why not say so? This is philosophy, isn’t it?

heres the crux of your theory, and ill tell you why its wrong. the little thing inside that sperm that makes you different is a few little adenine or thymine molecules in a different place in the dna sequence. its not like a little marble with your face on it, and the other sperms have another marble with a different face.

what im saying is that when you die, and your particles all dissipate into the area around your grave, that little piece of adenine is the same exact piece of adenine as mine, it just happened to be a few picometers to the left in your dads sperm. its the same piece of matter, indistinguishable. there is no particle that designates that you are sebeax and only sebeax.

i think you just need to read a little about genetics, they arent a blueprint, they are a recipe, and they are all written with the same words and ingredients, just different amounts and configurations. so when you take them out of that configuration, they are literally indistinguishable.

yeah, your adenine molecule does not disappear, it maybe turns into some other chemical or just gets eaten by that blade of grass and then by the cow and then by your great grandson who turns it into sperm dna, but the piece of adenine could have come from anywhere.

basically what im saying is that that particle you are talking about is actually a pattern inside a group of particles that all people. break down the pattern and your essential being is destroyed forever. break down your brain and your thinking stops. ‘i dont think therefore i am not’

what if the koran can be interpreted in a million and one ways, it can say a million illogical, humanity hurting things and your Phd friend happens to have discovered a way of interpreting it that makes all humans more happy than any other interpretation. then some other guy says “hey look, the koran says stab clitorises. the koran is right, you are wrong, heretic”

what then? stab clitorises? no. period.

Well, even that is another issue in and of itself. The davinci code may or may not contain contradictions within itself…really really dunno off the top of my head.

My bigger point was that the davinci code is presented as if it were an accurate representation of Christian teachings, when realy, it is not. :wink:

(But, I appreciate you coming to my defense, anyways. :slight_smile: )

Futureman

Christians will argue that “biblical contradictions” are really people just intepreting the Bible incorrectly. Non-Christians will argue that the Bible really does contain true contradictions. The argumennt will go back and forth and continue to progress at a stalemate ---- I never denied this.

please, next time be kind enough to include the word reincarnation in the title of the thread, so i dont have to go reading it.

Dunamis, I’m glad you’re commenting on this. But I don’t see any uncertainty in a wave…an event, a thing in itself, a small part of a bigger thing. Everchanging. When it reaches the shore it ceases, it’s moment gone forever. Some of it gets sucked back into the sea, but the thing that made it unique is gone forever. Our body gets sucked back into the earth, but the thing that makes us unique goes forever, if we’re anything like waves. (Which is what Future Man was in fact saying about our bodies, more or less, in his last post.)

Gamer,

I agree that the metaphor of the wave does not seem to lend itself to conceptions of the immortality of the self, that is unless one imagines that the force/identity of the wave transfers mediums, out of the physicality of the body, which while alive gives the impression that it is the support and source of its existence, into other mediums which are beyond the physical. The tsunami of Indonesia is still breaking in our minds.

Dunamis

I get the impression that the whole idea in most of these arguments is that the truth of every matter can be pinned down to either right or wrong as if it were simply a small puzzle or math problem. However, my understanding of all this conversation tells me that each person has a valid point to make in their own mind.

I don’t mean to sound like I don’t have any sense of hard truth because when it comes down to it I’m quite conservative. I just don’t believe the whole communication process is working very smoothly here. Everyone is thinking quite logically but expressing themselves much too quickly and irradically.

In fact I might even go so far as to say we’re all simply trying to state the same sort of thing with different objections and insecurities that blind us from actually knowing what it is we’re getting at.

Words will never truly express the universe entirely. They will only point in a direction.

And please don’t tell me that beer isn’t good because I love it.

Nientilin,

This isn’t a series of term papers or manifestos, thank god. (Although both are welcome and will be scrutinized.) It’s a conversation. And as far as conversations go, these may be the best some of us will ever have. If you think these are far too quick and careless, remember how it feels to talk with certain family members, co-workers and friends you grew up with, and be thankful for ILP. Nobody here will ever say “dude, why do have to be so philosophical,” or “Yo, G, why you always disagreeing and shit?” or “I’m sorry, homes, that’s too deep for me man…yo, who wants to go hear some reggae!?”