This should go in the Philosophy forum, but I feel it would get modded.
Frank Sinatra didn’t write songs you pathetic retard. Bob Dylan was the kind of miraculous anomaly that comes along about once a century.
I did it my way,
Cabrones.
Ah, yes, the Paul Anka version of a French song.
But let’s let the openness of the thread title give us the opportunity to compare which was better at supporting black rights and the civil rights movement in general. I give the nod to Sinatra. While Dylan’s music had an impact, Sinatra put his ass and his career on the line many times and started this in the 40s. He broke segregation in Vegas single-handedly (for performers anyway and the other dominos fell not long afer) - well, with the help of about 20 goombahs as Quincy Jones affectionately called them. He started before he really had the later power he acquired and was very blunt and clear. I’m not saying one can objectively conclude this, but he gets my nod cause he was 'bout that action.
ffs
Who is better, Bach or Ed Sheeran? Ed Sheeran because he once helped an old lady cross the road.
While I genuinely respect Sinatra for what he did 1) my response was tongue in cheek and 2) I made it clear that I was using the vagueness of the title to shift what we were evaluating him on - only in your mind did I say he was a better musically.
But you found a way to be outraged.
Chur, sis.
Cool that you think Dylan is on the level of Bach, you postmodernist you.
Sinatra was less annoying in public compared to Bob Dylan.
![]()
Oh, I think they are good competition for each other in that category, one a Jekyll and Hyde sometimes narcissist and the other a smug, arrogant guy.
I need to see the device, the research team and their credentials and the measurements.
I guess that I am a bit biased being a Sinatra fan.
Bob Dylan had a few hits, but he was still super annoying.
![]()
That’s fine. Neither of us is objective, about the music or degrees of obnoxiousness. And most of what I’ve heard about Sinatra was semipublic or private. Dylan might even just be awkward and shy but he does come off like a dick. They both seem like Jekyll and Hyde characters actually, with moments of generosity, humor, humility and moments of yech. If they both liked me, I think I’d always be worried about my safety around Sinatra. And around Dylan I’d worry about his in relation to me.
Sinatra has to be considered one of the greatest singers/voices of all time. Try singing any of his songs as he did…near impossible.
Dylan has to be considered amongst the greatest songwriters.
Moronic to even compare them. Sinatra wasn’t even a songwriter. He was a thug who could sing. I don’t think anyone can ‘croon’ any more. It’s a lost art form. And don’t say that Buble guy. He’s just a pale imitation. It was of an era. Bing Crosby was another great one with a truly beautiful voice.
Bob Dylan was a poet who could also write beautiful melodies to go with his poetry, plus his phrasing was second to none. A great singer in his own unique way. His sheer body of work at such a young age is mind-boggling.
Bob Dylan: How many roads must a man walk down?
Sinatra: I walked down every fucking road and I did it my way.
How dumb are some people exactly?
Dylan from floater about people getting in stupid arguments:
Sometimes it’s just plain stupid
To get into any kind of wind