I have been watching Star Trek since it started on TV in 1966, yes,
I am that old…
and I was in high school when Star Wars came out…
and there have been quite of few “discussions” about the two…
I wish to engage in one aspect of the two…
I have been watching the recent additions to both,
“the Mandalorian” and Star Trek “Discovery”
and one theme that I have often being trying to work out is present in both,
as they have been present since the beginning of both…
the moral ambiguity of the characters…
Star Wars tends to have a much stronger belief in the 'GOODNESS"
and “evil” of the Characters… in other words, there is far less working
out of ambiguity in the characters… if you are good, then you are good,
and if you are “evil” you are evil… there is no suggestion in Star Wars
about the moral ambiguity of any character… you are either good or you are
evil… and may the two never meet in Star Wars…
and in Star Trek… Every series has had questions about the moral
ambiguity of every single character…
from the original series to the latest series, the moral ambiguity has
been the central question of Star Trek…every single character has
done morally dubious, questionable actions and then they somehow
try to justify or explain away the morally dubious actions…
Star Trek is far closer to real life in its determination to explore
what it means to be human in light of what is “right” and what is “wrong”
in Star Trek, practically every single episode is a case study in
the question of moral ambiguity in human beings…
what is “right” and what is “wrong” and why… is the great
question of Star Trek…
the single dominant article of Star Trek is the first rule of
federation…the prime Directive, “Starfleet general order 1”
the non-interference directive… which prohibits its members
from interfering with the internal and natural development of alien
civilizations…
and yet, every single captain has violated that rule,
repeatedly and is the basis of virtual every single episode…
and how do they explain away and justify each case of violating
the “prime directive”…
it is this case of moral ambiguity that give Star Trek the edge
over Star Wars, for me anyway…
I prefer Star Star Trek over Star Wars because it calls into question,
virtually in every single episode, what is the morally right thing to do?
it is its moral ambiguity that makes Star Trek the better series…
Kropotkin