Besides being a member and poster here at ILP I sometimes read two other philosophy sites, when time allows me to do so. And one thing that keeps being brought up by established members, good posters I might add, is the “quality†of posts or the board in general. These members complain that the “board has become mediocre, populated by idiots, who contribute nothing but one or two-liner moronic, idiotic, responses.†They suggest different ways to deal with these “idiotsâ€:
“Ban them!! No mercy, just ban the hell out of them. They deserve it.â€
“Post their names in public so other members could know who these idiots are.â€
“Why treat them with kindness. We must be ruthless, be firm with our intellectual abilities.â€
“They deserve to be called names. They are idiots, stupid, morons, who don’t know that they are. So, they must be told what they are.â€
“Ridicule them. Humiliate the shit out of them. For they are clueless.â€
“The good and intelligent posters have fled ever since these idiots have increased their numbers. Let’s bring back the intelligent posters and prevent these idiots from posting.â€
It’s hilarious and petty really if you think about it. These self-proclaimed “intelligent, good posters†have developed this intense fear of the idiots. They beg the administration to get rid of them. ‘Let’s not associate with these kind of people.’ As if, their own intellectual capacity is going to be diminished, wasted, tainted, or whatnot, if people of a lesser kind share the same forum board with them.
A new thing is dawning!! Wait. No. This is an old system of discrimination that’s been around for ages. The rich doesn’t want to associate with the poor. Let’s have expensive, exclusive clubs where members know Armani and Bently. The beautiful don’t want to hang out with the ugly, because, man! ain’t they scary. My beauty will diminish if I become acquainted with these uh-guh-ly individuals. The academics—wow! Hey, I’ve got letters following my name, I’m so the intellectual. And you are? What university? PhD? Post-doc? The Christians make sure they wup your ass if you’re gay. Legislate, damn it. Show these substandard humans they are an environmental mistake.
The thing is, one’s strength, ability, intelligence, competence, etc, etc, etc. does not depend on others’ fault or misgivings or shortcomings—when you’re talking about things in the sense I have mentioned. We don’t need to ostracize others for fear that our own capacity will diminish. If they don’t suit your fancy, ignore them. This is a decent reaction. But there is something you could do to put your intelligence to work—educate these “idiotsâ€. Teach them something. This is a more becoming behavior of those “who know betterâ€, those who are established members and profess to have wisdom and knowledge. Because what is wisdom for? What is knowledge for? To keep them for show? For awards night? For competition? See if anyone “in-the-know†is watching then post your well thought-out response?
Don’t leave for fear that your intelligence is somehow compromised because chachacha123, meowmix66, and hornybastard69 have signed up. Ignore them and move on. Or teach them. But complain and whine “Ten ways to discriminate and show your prejudice�