As with a film like The Color Purple, Precious stirred up conflicting reactions from within the black community.
There were folks who applauded it for portraying an experience they see as [for some] true to life. There were folks who condemned it for perpetuating what they see to be flagrant racial sterotypes.
nytimes.com/2009/11/21/movie … .html?_r=0
revcom.us/a/189/precious-en.html
blog.sfgate.com/abraham/2009/10/ … scar-buzz/
It would seem that a case could be made for either point of view.
Not many characters like Precious around. And certainly not many of them around who play the leading role. But it is hard to say with any degree of certainty what it means to be “good” or “bad” when you are born and raised in an environment like this. The mother and the father—what is their own backstory? What sort of childhood did they have? Some conservatives like to insist that none of it matters…just as some liberals will insist it is the only thing that does matter. Has that been resolved yet?
How bad is it? Well, for one thing, her father rapes her. She had a baby [his] born with Downs syndrome. Claireece calls her “Mongo”. That’s short for Mongoloid, she says. Her mother is nothing less than an abomination at times. And her whole world revolves around eating, watching televison, conning social services and viciously abusing Claireece. Claireece is morbidly obese. She’s pregnant again with her daddy’s child. Her daddy has AIDS.
For all practical purposes, it is way, way beyond my capacity to grasp.
IMDb
[b]Over 400 girls were interviewed from across the country for the part of Precious. Gabourey Sidibe was cast a mere six weeks before the start of shooting after being forced to the audition by friends.
In the final confrontation scene, Mariah Carey was not directed to cry; rather, she was supposed to react with stone faced horror, just as Ms. Weiss does in the novel. However, Carey was so overpowered by the performances of Mo’Nique and Gabourey Sidibe, she broke down in tears and ducked her head away from the camera as not to ruin the scene. Director Lee Daniels loved Carey’s natural reaction and kept the shot of her wiping her tears in the final cut.[/b]
at wiki: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precious_(film
trailer: youtu.be/LpU8rJ_ZwOs
PRECIOUS [2009]
Directed by Lee Daniels
[b]Claireece: [voiceover] My name is Claireece “Precious” Jones. I wish I had a light-skinned boyfriend with real nice hair. And I wanna be on the cover of a magazine. But first I wanna be in one of them BET videos. Momma said I can’t dance. Plus, she said who wants to see my big ass dancing, anyhow?
…
Mrs. Lichtenstein [principal] Hello, Claireece. Are you pregnant?
[Claireece looks away]
Mrs. Lichtenstein: You’re 16; you’re still in Junior High School; and you’re pregnant with your second child. Is that correct?
[No reply]
Mrs. Lichtenstein: Are you pregnant, again?
[Mrs. Lichtenstein huffs, exacerbated]
Mrs. Lichtenstein: What happened Claireece?
Claireece: I had sex, Mrs. Lichtenstein.
Mrs. Lichtenstein: Do you have any other thoughts about your situation, Claireece?
[Claireece shrugs]
Mrs. Lichtenstein: Claireece?
Claireece: Am I in trouble?
[No reply]
Claireece: Thank you, but I have to get back to math.
[She gathers her things to leave]
Mrs. Lichtenstein: Sit down, Claireece. Sit down right now!
[Claireece sits back down]
Mrs. Lichtenstein: We should have a parent-teacher conference with you, me and your mother.
Clarieece: My mother’s busy.
Mrs. Lichtenstein: Alright. How about if I come to your house?
Claireece: If I were you, I wouldn’t.
…
Claireece: I hate crackheads. Nobody ever rings the bell but crackheads.
[Claireece walks over to the intercom]
Claireece: Stop ringing the godamn buzzer you motherfuckers![/b]
Nope. Not this time.
[b]Mother: Who is that, Claireece.
Claireece: The white bitch from school.
…
Mary: Precious! PRECIOUS! PRECIOUS! Get down here, bitch! You brought that white bitch up in my house? You wrong to bring that bitch up in here!
Claireece: I ain’t bring her in here.
Mary: Well, why the fuck did she ring my buzzer? I can’t hear you, Precious. Since you got so much mothafuckin’ mouth and you gon’ bring a bitch up in my house… why did that bitch ring my goddamn buzzer?
Clarieece: I ain’t tell her to come here!
Mary: See, I think right now you think you becomin’ a grown woman. ‘Cause that shit you pulled in the kitchen… I shoulda fucked you up. But I let you walk away. And I let you get yourself together. But, bitch, I’mma let you know, don’t you ever pull that shit again. That’ll be your last mothafuckin’ day stayin here. I promise you that. You gon’ send a white bitch to my mothafuckin’ buzzer? Talkin’ ‘bout some higher education? You’re a dummy, bitch! You will never know shit! Don’t nobody want you, don’t nobody need you! You done fucked around and fucked my mothafuckin’ man? And had two mothafuckin’ children? And one of ‘ems a goddamn animal, runnin’ ‘round lookin’ crazy as a mothafucka? Bitch, you know what? See, I think you… I think you tryin’ me. I think you tryin’ to fuck with me. You fuckin’ with my money… and you gon’ stand up there and look at me like you a mothafuckin’ woman? I’mma show you what real women do, bitch. See, you don’t know what real mothafuckin’ women do. Real mothafuckin’ women sacrafice! I shoulda aborter your mothafuckin’ ass! 'Cause you ain’t shit! I knew it when the doctor put you in my goddamn hand you wasn’t a goddamn thing! You wear that smirk on your face, bitch? Get outta…!
[throws object at Claireece]
Mary: Now smile about that! Smile about that, you fat bi -
[Claireece kicks a shoe at Mary]
Mary: I’mma kill you, bitch!
[Mary chases Claireece up the stairs]
…
Claireece: [Taking an assessment test] There’s always something wrong with these tests. These tests paint a picture of me with no brain. These tests paint a picture of me and my mother, my whole family as less than dumb. Just ugly black grease, need to be wiped away, find a job for. Sometimes I wish I was dead. I’ll be okay, I guess, ‘cause I’m lookin’ up. Lookin’ for something to fall on me…a desk, a couch, tv… my mom, maybe.
…
Claireece: The other day, I cried. But you know what? Fuck that day. That’s why God, or whoever, makes new days.
…
Ms. Rain: You guys know that you are in the ABE class. This is not GED. This is to get you ready for your GED.
…
Ms.Weiss [a socialworker]: I need to know about your homelife and your mother. I need to know what it’s like where you live.
Claireece: My mother’s like a whale on the couch. She say I eat all the time, but she always making me eat. Then she call me a fat mess. The only time she ever leaves is to play her numbers…watch TV, eat, watch TV, eat again. Can you help out with that?
…
Claireece: Social worker here.
Mother: Why din’t you tell me that bitch was comin’ so fuckin’ early? Come get my wig!
…
Mrs. Weiss: You know, let’s talk about your father. Tell me about your relationship with him.
Claireece: I don’t know much more than you do, Mrs. White.
Mrs. Weiss: That’s Mrs. “Weiss.” Talk to me about the little you do know about your father. It is important, whether you know it or not.
Claireece: He give me his baby and my one before it, but I don’t never see him…
Mrs. Weiss: Wait, what did you say he gave you?
Claireece: Nothing.
Mrs. Weiss: Wait, Clareece, you just said your father gave you something…
Claireece: Nothing.
Mrs. Weiss: No, I HEARD you just say…
Claireece: You didn’t hear shit.
Mrs. Weiss: I heard you just say your father…
Claireece: You didn’t hear shit like it!
Mrs. Weiss: I don’t care, honey! I need to know this!
Claireece: I didn’t say nothing like it! Let’s move ON!
Mrs. Weiss: I need this to HELP you…
Claireece [Angrily]: Bitch, can we change the subject?
Mrs. Weiss [tossing her file aside]: Okay. Well, I’ll see you next time then. Or maybe you’ll see someone else. But you’re going to have to talk to someone if you want your check, sweetie.
[Long pause, whilst Claireece considers this]
Clarieece: I see vampires too…
…
Claireece [to Mrs. Weiss]: I been going to the doctor, too. It’s nice. Msw. Rain fall out when she found out I ain’t never been to no doctor before. Don’t know how I had my first baby on the kitchen floor with my momma kicking me upside the head. Them the kind of things you talking about when you say, say whatever come to my mind?
…
Claireece [voiceover]: That’s the end of them welfare checks. I just couldn’t lie no more. I shouldn’t have said none of that. Momma gonna kill me.
…
Mother: Your daddy dead. He had the AIDS.
…
Mrs. Weiss [angrily]: You just sat there, shut up, and let him abuse your daughter.
Mary [hysterically in tears]: I did not want him to abuse my daughter! I did not want him to hurt her! I didn’t want him to do nothing to her!
Mrs. Weiss: But you ALLOWED him to hurt her! You did!
Mary: But, those… those things she told you I did to her? Who… who… who else was going to love me? WHO else was going to touch me? WHO else was going to make me feel good about myself? You sit there and you judge me, and you write them notes on your notepad, because you think you know who I am!
…
Claireece [to her mother]: You know to this day, I never even knew who you was, not even after all them things you did. Maybe I was too stupid. Maybe I just didn’t want to. You ain’t gonna see me no more.[/b]