Do Black Holes Equal Universes?

Do Black Holes Equal Universes?

Copyright 2007, Dennis H. Kane

Notice: You can copy and distribute this work as long as you do not modify it in any way.

In order to get a full grasp of the Cosmological Problem, two important discoveries from Einstein are going to have to be understood:

  1. E=mc^2
  2. The universe is composed of a self-adhesive, flexible substance that is called the spacetime continuum (or just “spacetime”).

The fatal flaw with current cosmologies is that they do not come to grips with these fundamentals. In fact, they completely ignore them. Cosmologists instead remain wedded to using physical models that treat space and time as distinct, empty dimensions that are simply meant to be “filled in” with the equations of particle physicists. Using this context, a true cosmology is not even possible, because spacetime must be understood as the primordial substance that allows for the existence of all of the substances that we experience in every day life.

Theoretical particle physicists (TPP’s) always proclaim that space is simply a vacuum, filled with something called “vacuum energy”, out of which particles may appear, causing a phenonmenon called “antigravity” (aka “dark energy”). Upon closer inspection, this notion becomes so incredibly preposterous that it almost boggles the mind! In other words, what they are saying is that the total energy content of the universe is constantly increasing because “dead space” is actually filled with a kind of energy that mysteriously replicates itself. This is the necessary axiom of today’s so-called “cosmology”.

In order to believe this axiom, however, we are forced to forget everything that we were taught about the conservation of mass-energy in junior high school! We are told that this principle no longer applies to the real world, because of what the TPP’s, in all of their infinite wisdom, have jotted down in their notebooks.

However, if we were to just close our ears to those “rabid dogs” called TPP’s, then perhaps we can start to make sense of the universe that we’ve been given, using Einstein’s discoveries. This way, a whole new world of possibilities becomes open to us!

If we are to understand that the universe is constantly gaining in mass-energy while at the same time holding on to common sense, then we must come to the unavoidable conclusion that the known universe is simply a dynamic part of a much bigger system. In this way, our universe must consist of at least one “inlet valve” into which mass-energy is input and possibly one or more “drains” into which mass-energy escapes (any guesses as to what these drains might be called?).

Now let us think about this always changing (by way of general relativity) substance called spacetime. It is said that mass-energy causes spacetime to expand, which thereby allows mass-energy to travel longer distances in the same periods of time (as witnessed by bending light and the slingshot effect of satelites around planets). What this is really saying is that mass-energy causes spacetime to grow and that spacetime causes mass-energy to grow (space grows while energy content grows). Well, this seems to be the classic case of a vicious circle. It seems, by all rights, that this “law of gravity” should spiral out of control at the very moment it is implemented! We are supposed to think that mass-energy causes itself to grow!

What is really happening here is that it makes precisely zero sense to speak of mass-energy and spacetime as being different kinds of substance. For every reason imaginable, spacetime is mass-energy and mass-energy is spacetime. So, let us see if we can borrow a razor from our good friend, Ockham. For the moment, let us use mass-energy and forget about that thing called spacetime. But even the term “mass-energy” is unnecessarily complicated, because mass and energy are two sides of the same “E=mc^2 coin”. In fact, we could just say that an amount of mass-energy is simply a “mass” of Energy. In this way, we are able to reduce the two fundamental concepts of cosmology (spacetime and mass-energy) to one easy to understand idea: the universe is simply a mass of Energy.

In fact, whenever we talk about a universe as a whole, it is of fundamental necessity to talk about it simply as a singular, undifferentiable mass of Energy. After all, any of its internal differences are of concern only to the relationships between the beings of the universe in question. If we think in these terms, then we can plainly see that there is no way that this mass can grow without some kind of external input.


If we think of a black hole, we understand an extremely dense mass of Energy that is called a singularity. We understand that Energy is always being “pulled” into black hole singularities. The effect of this action upon the incoming Energy waves is profound: they are stretched out until they are nearly completely flat (think of a sine wave). It is said that this dramatic decrease in the frequency of Energy waves means that time dramatically is slowing down inside of the singularity.

What this means is just that whenever a mass of Energy grows, it is also true that the time that is internal to it also grows (or stretches). However, since space and time are forever bound together into a substance called spacetime, then an increase in the “length” of time is identical with an increase in the “mass” of spacetime. Furthermore (pay very close attention here), to say that spacetime grows is equivalent to either of these two statements:

  1. space expands
  2. time expands

Within the singularity of a black hole, then, there is precisely no difference between the following two ideas:

  1. time expands while space remains constant
  2. space expands while time remains constant

It is funny how physicists describe the singularity of a black hole only in terms of #1 and the singularity of the moment of the “big bang” only in terms of #2. In all respects, however, both kinds of singularity have the exact same essence: their spacetime increases. According to both Einstein’s theory of general relativity and to common sense, then, there is precisely zero difference between a black hole that continually slows down time and a universe that continually expands! They are tautologous!

A black hole singularity is a “big bang” singularity!

For every imaginable reason, then, it is entirely necessary to say that our universe is the singularity of a black hole and that our black holes contain universes. To say otherwise is to slap both Einstein and your own good sense squarely in the face!

The Energy that is always being input into our universe, then, has precisely nothing to do with a mysteriously replicating entity called “dark energy” that only finds life in the weird scribblings of the notebooks of those crackpots called theoretical particle physicists. But rather, it is the same ordinary kind of Energy that is always disappearing into countless black holes across our own universe!

The only problem in all of this is that we haven’t fully come to terms with that mysterious force that is called: gravity. All we have shown is that the concept of gravity, as such, leads into a vicious cycle, whereby spacetime and mass-energy become what are known as infinitely recursive functions (computer programmer terminology) that continuously feed into each other. Perhaps, then, we should consider that spacetime might just grow and shrink all on its own accord, much like a living organism. As we don’t want to violate our common sense understanding of the conservation of mass-energy (aka spacetime), the growth of spacetime in one region should cause the shrinkage of spacetime in another region. And when this growth becomes too great, perhaps there is a moment during which it could be said that spacetime ruptures, causing it to drain into a region that is known (depending on your perspective) either as a black hole singularity (in which time grows) or as a universe (in which space grows).

Just as speculation, because we now think of spacetime as a kind of living organism, perhaps it is just as likely that a black hole can start shrinking, causing either of these phenomena (again, depending on perspective):

  1. time within the known black hole starts shrinking
  2. space within the hidden universe starts shrinking

In either case, we could say that Energy (spacetime) is being returned from the singularity of the black hole back into the surrounding universe. After all, if regions of the universe can arbitrarily start growing, there is no reason why they cannot arbitrarily start shrinking! (Consider this the Kane Hypothesis).


All of the problems in the state of the cosmology are due to the fact that physicists are mere technicians without anything in the way of genuine philosophical intuition. This fact is almost unavoidable if we consider that academies are tremendously competitive institutions that must always outdo one another with the newest, sexiest theories. In fact, it is in their best interest to invent bizarre mathematical theories that are taken as confounding, yet amazing revelations concerning the “strange, hidden ways” of the universe. After all, many people just want to live their lives in constant states of amazement, brought about by the so-called impressiveness of mathematical symbology. And these are precisely the people who feel ethically bound to support the “sciences”, no matter how fantastically ungrounded are the sciences in question.

Theoretical particle physicists are modern day alchemists, claiming that they are able to turn iron into gold with their mysterious formulations!

They are today’s “Rainmen” who are able to count a six-deck black jack chute but aren’t able to tell you if a car costs more than a candy bar!

Einstein was simply an honest man with good philosophical insight who was confounded at every turn by those “mathematical wizards” who wanted to make everyone else think that only the “elect” could understand the ways of the cosmos!

Viva la philosophe!

(To understand where I am coming from, read almost anything by Heidegger.)

So is that to say that the spacetime–not matter/energy–that the black holes ‘suck in’ is then fed into the new universe? What determines how the spacetime will ‘pop up’ into units of matter/energy and what inhibits it from ‘popping’ back into nonexistence?

This determination must be absolute considering the the law of conservation; all the matter/energy that we see before us was created in the Big Bang, and dark matter/energy is but the result of a continuous inlet flow of spacetime from the parent back hole, right? So we know where matter/energy came from (spacetime), but what caused/causes it to come in to existence?

Also, some scientists believe that, aside from the massive breed of black holes that churn away in outerspace, there is a much, much smaller breed that could very well be anywhere, even within our brains. Do they also have their own universes?

Oh, and another thing: if universes are but singularities within a black hole, does that mean that the ‘edge’ of the Universe is but the interior wall of the black hole itself?

Maybe the universe inside the black hole is an ‘inverted’ buniverse where what we consider to be ‘momentum space’ is the inverted universe’s normal space and our space is its momentum space. This makes sense because the momentum of a particle is properational to 1/wavelength. So at a singularity waves would have 0 wavelenghth and therefore 1/0 ----> infinte momentum. So the momentum space at the singularity would be infinte in our universe thus the spacial dimensions of this inverted universe would be infinte.

Probably not making much sense to you here unless you understand what momentum space is. basically its just the inverse of space so short distances are long distances and long are short. so as matter collapses to a point in normal space(like in a black hole) its expanding in momentum space. But these are just two descriptions of the same thing(related by a fourier transform)
So in effect I’m saying our universe expanding out in space could be like a collapsing black hole in momentum space.

The only thing here is how to think of the entropy. A black hole will have a very high entropy; whereas the big band must have had a very small one. So I guess the question would be whats the inverse of entropy? It needs to be low in the case of a blackhole. order maybe but thats too obvious…

There is no proof that black holes exist. There is proof that Hubble’s Law is incorrect…so the theory of black holes has…well, holes in it.

Many in my field of astrophysics disagree with black holes and the big bang. I can provide many names if anyone wishes.

The truth is that Einstien was incomplete, only due to his dying. Had he lived to be 200 years old he would have come to the same conclusion that many of us have. The Universe is perpetual, a stance he believed until Hubble showed him otherwise. Now that Hubble’s law is wrong, Einstein would go back to his original line of thought.

This, of course, flies in the face of what the catholic church believes in (creationism) so we have a problem here.

What field of astrophysics do you work in?

What about supermassive accretion disks that are too big for white dwarfs or neutron stars, a la quasars? What of gravitational lensing? And if there really are no black holes, what do you suggest happens after the death of a supermassive star? (Mind you, I’m no astrophysicist–just a humble philosopher.)

Hmm theres lots of proof for blackholes. General relativity has passed all tests and predicts them. The only alternatives i’ve heard about are black stars…

Please don’t speak of the truth. Science seeks the truth it doesn’t know it.

Of course there astrophysicists with beliefs that go against the norm it doesn’t mean their right or wrong. Instead of providing names(which are useless) provide theories. Your post just seemed to shoot down black holes for no actual reason.

Since when is hubbles law wrong??? Its based on experimental evidence that stars that are further away have bigger red shifts which means there moving away faster. What other theory apart from an expanding universe do you know?

If you want to find some physicist on the internet to say this theory or that theory is wrong or has no proof you can find it… doesn’t mean a thing unless they have evidence for an alternative theory.

Sorry to sound harsh but if your gonna make statements like that you should back them up.

Oh yeah never compare hard science to the catholic church…

Let’s start with Hubble’s law and work towards gravitational waves, which are required for black holes to exist.

Hubble’s Law was shown to be wrong when galaxies were observed to collide. This has happened many times, as any internet search will show.

The first problem is that the galaxies have collided from all different directions, flying in the face of an expanding Universe. Especially one at a constant rate. So here was the first expansion problem.

There are galaxies headed our way right now. Hubble misunderstood redshift, as do most people.

So to save the big bang/black hole theory (they are one in the same, as black holes are BB counterpoints) many physicists NEEDED one thing, to find gravitational waves.
Why? Because as most bangers believed, when galaxies collided there would be a super black hole. This a result of colliding galaxies.

  • Please note that these SAME physicists at one time said that galaxies could not collide in an expanding Universe.

So, the galaxies collide thus creating a super massive black hole. How would this be known? By gravitational wave detection. Perpetual physics knows there are no such waves because gravity is not what they think it is.

But pomo physicists believe gravity has waves. Even though they cannot find them.
So the galaxies collide and the supposed black hole collision should send gravitational waves throughout the Universe, to be easily detected by us.

Kip Thorne has run a bill at Caltech to nearly 1 billion dollars to show these waves. Ooops, they aren’t there.

There will never be gravitational wave detection, ever. No gravitational waves, no black holes. No black holes, no big bang.

No big bang…no Universal creator.

So we have a few problems.
1- There are billions of dollars at stake and alot of jobs at stake over the big bang/black hole theory.
2- The religious aspect of perpetualty. The solution of SPAD, the double slit experiment etc has shown that perpetual physics was always correct. This means that the Universe was not created by anything other than itself. I’m sure I don’t have to eloborate on this problem.

Why can’t they find gravitational waves? Because gravity is a structural force. This changes everything…

So basically your saying general relativity is totally wrong??? If there are no gravitional waves GR is wrong.

Again all your doing is saying things are wrong with no proof or alternative theories.

Basically your whole argument rests on eiensein being very very wrong and not just about the hubles law. The whole of relativity is wrong if gravitional waves don’t exists.

can u direct me to the paper of these alternative theories please??? And I am a physicist with years of training in these things so please be a bit more explict.

Are you arguing that there is no general covariance??? therefore no einstein field equations and thus no gravitional waves?

Galaxies maybe.

I think that if all the matter in the universe was absorbed into an Ultra-Massive Black Hole, then yes, the Black Hole would contain a universe.

I liked this a lot. Can you expand on this a little more? How do you come to you last conclusion that the momentum becomes infinite? Wouldn’t it actually mean that the momentum becomes undefined? and why do the spatial dimensions become infinite?

Can you elaborate on this? What do you mean by structural force? and even if you were to define gravity differently, why would its effects not be evident/measurable?

Research Jin He, for starters. I am sure you know of Halton Arp, Lyndon Ashmore, etc.
Also, research what Kip Thorne is doing, or not doing.

You must admit this. No gravitational waves have been found.
You can think what you like and assume they will be. Or you can understand why they haven’t been. Because they do not exist.

Perpetual physics predicted this 60 years ago. No gravitational waves.

And I asked you if you wanted names and you said no. There are many institutes all over the world who have disputed these things.
I will pm you several papers when I get to the computer I have them on.

Aristotle was wrong, Descartes was wrong, Newton was wrong, Galileo was wrong. All took years to pass before accepting these giants to be wrong. Einstein wasn’t really wrong, he was incomplete. He was side tracked…I guess that does make him wrong, in a way.

Universe…UNI means one. Cannot have multiple Universes.

Did I somehow imply multiple universes?

If I stack 20 objects on you and puch them down, you’d feel the force. What is happening is the pomo physicist is trying to find the force in the object touching you, mistaking it for the source. The source in this case would be me pushing the objects.
A domino knocks down another domino and so on. The last domino (the gravitational wave believers) are looking at the second-to-last domino and saying “That domino did it, it pushed me down”

The domino fell because of a structure force, the last domino felt a structural force, blaming it on the second-to-last domino.
The last domino should be saying “Maybe the domino that touched me is not the source, maybe it is the result of something else”

A force that is the result of a structure. They would not find force (or a wave) in the second-to-last domino, yet that is where they are looking.

A Universe cannot be ‘contained’. You would need multiple Universe (impossible) for this to occur.

I disagree. If all that existed was an ultra-massive black hole that contained all matter, then what is the universe by default?

I’m following but I don’t see who the blame is being put on? Who is the cause of force? Technically, is not all force derived from gravity? So if gravity is derived from this “structural” force, what is the “structure”?

From all that I’ve read. If what you claim is true einstein was fundementaly wrong: no Gravational waves, no timedilation, no black holes, a non-constant speed of light…these are all the pillars of his theory…stop reading pseudo-science books made to make cheap buck and read an actual book on relativiy…u might learn something.

Fin666,
Am I asking a stupid question? This is the third question I have asked you directly without any response.

Sorry not to respond earlyer. yeah i think your right that the momentum would be undefined not infinte. Maybe it could be the momentum space becomes infintly large so that any momentum state would be allowable in it. So every particle would have an undefined momentum, or rather an infinte uncertainty in its momentum, from it being confined at a single point in space(this just comes from the uncertainty principle). So then the momentum space that the particle would exist in would have to be infinte for it to be able to take any value(postion in the momentum space).

So what I’m saying is that what is space for us is momentum space for the inverted universe and vice versa. So our infinte momentum space in the black hole is the normal space inside the inverted universe.

Its just an idea…im just starting a project on blackholes, quantum gravity and extra dimensions…so hopefully I’ll beable to varify if theres any life in this idea.