Empathy

We’re born with empathy. Fairness is innate. Demonstrations of this have been given over and over, even cross-species demonstrations. Isn’t repetition leading to the same conclusion a part of scientific methodology?

We ignore the fact that we’re a part of the ‘animal kingdom’ with many of the same characteristics, many of the same thoughts, many of the same goals.

Why?

This is an attempt to respond to fm without making it a one-on-one between just us.

Perhaps my problem is that I don’t know the context of your question, but I’m not sure that we do ignore our animal ancestry.

Out of context, I can’t tell: are the first two statements meant to be related? I believe innate empathy has been demonstrated for several species, but that doesn’t entail fairness. Fairness is an evaluative political/philosophical tool, rather than a measurable behavioural feature.

Yeah, I don’t think empathy necessarily entails fairness. In fact, I’d be interested in any non-human demonstrations of fairness that you can present.

I’ve given examples of fairness when I talked about the experiments done with monkeys, grapes, and cucumbers and with chimps, grapes, and carrots. Look them up:

www.newscientist.com/…/dn12913-enviou … t-a-fair….

thebillfold.com/tag/chimps-know-whats-up/

You’ll find a lot more articles if you google the two subjects which I’ve underlined for you.

There’s evidence that human babies show a sense of fairness as early as 15 months:

sciencedaily.com/releases/20 … 161636.htm

I’ve also seen a clip showing two premature twins in the same incubator. The larger twin comforts the smaller one and helps it to survive. Unfortunately, I can no longer find the link.

That’s what fm and I have been talking about. He feels we’ve separated ourselves from nature which causes human ‘problems.’ (He says a lot more than that, much of which I agree with.)

I think we have ignored the fact that we’re animals and have latched onto the Biblical idea that we’re ‘superior’ to animals. I think the title of the thread is The Power of Words upon the Perception. Start at:

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=181064&start=50#p2361285

and go from there. Then come back and tell me how I’ve either misread or misinterpreted what’s been said. I don’t want to set up a contest–I just want to know where I’m ‘wrong’–and I’d really like to have the discussion continue, if possible. :slight_smile:

Thanks for the links. Very interesting. I’m going to read a bit more on it. I can definitely see a link between empathy and fairness, but I’m still not sure if it is a necessary link.

I read all you wrote and about half of what fm wrote on page three from your link. I agree with statiktech, it’s very interesting. I don’t see where you’re “wrong” anywhere, in fact fm is reminding me of Heidegger’s Being and Time, which I’m studying right now, and he’s speaking in terms that seem to imply an ambiguous nature to truth, so in light of that neither of you can be wrong.

The way we think we’re superior to animals is an interesting topic to include in discussions related to truth, I don’t really have anything useful or insightful to add to that part of the conversation, and perhaps this has already been said, but to me there’s nothing natural sounding about not thinking we’re superior to other animals. it seems to me that at least all higher mammals act like they are superior to other species.

I think this that was very well said, perhaps thinking in words needs to be made distinct from thinking without words, or to be more precise; actively thinking needs to be made distinct from just living and acting with thinking taking a passive role. Only in the case of the later can one truly solve or deal with human problems.

I assume by “I would be a part of the natural world”, you mean “I wouldn’t be a part of the natural world”.

Above as you know is the first part to the paragraph you quoted, I believe that fm might agree that using the term “world mind” was a stretch. So I doubt he was talking about the collective unconscious or that he believes in it.

So yes you are absolutely right in my opinion. I have much more to say on this subject, but I’ll wait for now to add more.

Interesting links, liz, thank you :slight_smile:

Though they do think that dogs, for example, have an innate sense of fairness.

wired.com/wiredscience/2008/12/dogenvy/

Moreno, We keep learning more and more about animal emotions, particularly mammalians, including the aquatic mammals–most of those studied do show empathy and fairness–I just can’t lead you all to all the literature. I saw a film clip about a diver freeing a dolphin from a fishing line it had entangled itself in. She knew the diver was freeing her and stayed patient and quiet while he cut her free. Before she swam away, she rubbed her face against his head to thank him. Stories like this abound.

A sociologist took his dog for walks along the beach. At a certain point, he’d throw a ball into the water. After a few throws, the dog was able to calculate where along the beach he should enter the water that gave him the shortest distance to swim out and retrieve the ball. A baby elephant was extricated from a mud hole by a team of naturalists and went running off to meet with his mom and older sibling, waiting for him a safe distance away. After a joyous reunion, mom and sibling trumpeted their thanks to the team and then moved on.

I think most of the research has been done to ‘measure’ the level of awareness and cognitive abilities (in order to show man’s superiority?) in animals. Yet we’ve all gone through pretty much the same evolution, at least until speciation, so isn’t it rational to assume we share a lot with our animal cohabitants?

Here’s another link, of anyone’s interested:

intl-icb.oxfordjournals.org/cont … 6/883.full

You’re linking to the choir, in my case, but thanks.
I very much liked,

amazon.com/When-Elephants-We … 0385314280

Which has an interesting introduction about how resistant science was to animal emotions, intentions, etc. From there it has many wonderful stories.

Empathy is probably innate, but so is aggression.

The only people I know who disregard innate characteristics are the tabula rasa thinkers, who today can be found amongst the post-structuralists. These often come in the form of socialist types. Socialists only believe in the idea that “everything is a social construction” in order to try and mould every one into their political ideology. This is why they are often at loggerheads with biologists, or any one who believes in hereditary; because if we inherit characteristics we are determined animals, and therefore man cannot be moulded into the socialist project with any ease.

And on the conservative side of tabula rasa supporters…
Ayn Rand believed in tabula rasa and passed this on to current Objectivists.
Then you have things like conservative religious people and their fear of gayness being taught - amongts all the other evils that can be taught by evil humanists.
And then there is the whole conservative pedagogical tradition with its emphasis on teaching character and moulding future citizens. Both the right and the left, especially at the extremes see education as filling the child’s basically empty animal mind with the right stuff. Totalitarian states on both sides make nurture a huge part of their programs - twisting ‘nurture’ rather far from the warm feeling associations one might have.

I am not aware of Randians being around any more, I am also sure that Rand does not feature any more in academic literature (I could be wrong, but from my perusal of the social science and Humanities’ academic journals, Rand doesn’t feature).

You are right in that both sides do nurture citizens. Yet, today certain (left-leaning) sociologists are the only academics I know who still teach the tabula rasa.
I suspect you’re American? Conservativism there seems to differ greatly from Conservativism in other Western countries. Americans seem to be very religious for some reason. This doesn’t necessary feature in other Western Conservatives.

I try not to ignore it. It is constantly on my mind. I think about animals all the time. I think we’re meant to be allot better than we are, as a species. Some sort of fall took place, I figure.

Despite this she and objectivism are very popular. Google Ayn rand discussion or forum for starters. Or Objectivist. (but then, I hoe you are right. It’s just I still run into them quite a bit on the net.)

Could be. However she is unbelievably influential on libertarians and conservatives anyway and her books are read widely.

I don’t know any who do. Though perhaps there are some. Neuroscience has pretty much ended the issue, along with twin studies, Chomsky’s work and child development science.

But your post said ‘the only people…’ not ‘the only academics’ and yet you are reacting here as if it was somehow clear that the issue was academics. I really don’t know how to search for tabula rasa academics to see if your new modified assertion is correct or not. I suppose I could try to find conservative critics of Pinker’s work, for example, but I am not going to invest the time.

I suppose this tendency is mirrored by some conservatives not being able to imagine that nature is not everything.

I mentioned convervative religious people, making clear it was a subset, so while I am an american, this makes it clear I was not assuming all conservative people are religious. I am sure there are some americans who haven’t noticed the neo-cons and have no awareness of the large body of atheist right leaning libertarians - as opposed to, say, left leaning atheist anarchist etc. - but none of this, nor other forms of non-religious conservativism have missed my notice. And I haven’t lived in the Americas for a long time, and so on.

Nevertheless religious conservatives exist and have some striking tabula rasa tendencies of thought. On the other hand they have counter thoughts - say around Original sin - but this does not negate the other pattern.

empathy? fairness? please define these before i even respond.

but if i could guess what exactly you are reffering to i would say no to both, they are both learned.

Sometimes, lizbeth, I wish you were more explicit about what you’re actually thinking.
It’s unclear what this part of your OP means in the context of the OP.
Is it an attempt at saying that we don’t recognize enough empathy in other animals, and that we should?
Or are you trying to say something else entirely?
I wish you would just say what you meant sometimes :stuck_out_tongue:

I think, FJ, you’d understand better if you read the entire thread, including all references. To iterate what I’ve already said is unnecessary.

I suggest you also read the entire thread, including the references.

Dan~ Should we just think about animals, or should we think more about our relationship to animals. I think we could have learned a lot from the Amerinds, had we not thought of ourselves as ‘superior’ to them.

fent, how is aggression ‘innate?’ Doesn’t aggression come about, first, as a reaction to an innate emotion such as fear? Wasn’t it then used as a way of gaining dominance over ‘lesser’ animals? Aggression is the ‘learned’ response, imm.

We’ve learned to respond to aggression with aggression. (That’s why the NRA wants armed guards in elementary schools in response to the Newtown massacre.)

Moreno, not to leave you out, I realize that a lot of times, with you, I’m preaching to the choir when it’s the nave I’m trying to reach.