I am responding as you are trying to undermine my religion by attacking me personally. You write this quick vicious dig at me with zero relevance to the topic and nothing constructive in it, whilst (for the second time, first time being my BeingMuslim ID hiatus) waiting a while and knowing l’m away (my ID clearly states “On hiatus from here, too busy IRL - have fun! Peace.”). I am fasting right now, and l am trying to devote myself to things not to do with this world.
I fail to see what any of this has to do with my rebuttal of yet another long video posing a radical theory that Islam was completed after the death of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) - here
I posted the rebuttal formally and respectfully and l invited you to study Islam’s primary texts so that you may better discern what is said of it.
In response, you ignored everything l had written, which took hours to formulate as l had to trawl through your video (which you failed to adequately put into your own words, you’re happy just throwing stuff out there), here, and here
Instead, your reply insisted that l have an absolute insoluble problem with academia, as it implied l made no academic rebuttal, and thus it accused me of Invicible Ignorance:
Also in a previous thread here.
and thus the implication is that you need not answer my rebuttal
… just as you need not formulate a case against Islam in your own words, you’d rather sling a video
… and you clearly don’t see the need to study Islam in its own terms first, before uncritically accepting revisionist theories against it.
It is actually yourself that once again exhibits Invincible Igorance - you have not taken me on academically. Islam was completed by the time of the Prophet’s Farewell Sermon.
This is supplemental to the myriad other mistakes you / your espoused revisionist theories have made in their writing off Islam as something invented by men generation after generation, which l have meticulously catalogued in my replies.
You typically ignore my replies (here and in the Yahwist revisionism thread) at least in that you don’t counter them, you just re-assert what you already wrote, e.g. l post a theory that deviations from monotheism are already catered for in the monotheist narrative that people lose their religion when they become enamoured by the material world. Your response is ever: restate that some artefact has been found showing a stringy wiry deity with stringy wiry wives / daughters etc. But l already countered that.
You are thereforre trolling, i.e. making repeated negative assertions without integrating feedback.
Having seen you give at least 2 upvotes to people making personal attacks against me, l can honestly say your attitude has taken an even worse turn, by accusing me of a propensity toward slandering others:
And to top it off, you use the terrorism slur on me, quoting a partial Qur’an verse which people who hate Islam, and want to undermine it any which way, will always give a partial version of. And you try to call me to account for BIn Laden. Of course, when l respond to rebuke people projecting this dreadful sliur against me, you then broadcast to the world (once l’m away for long enough) that you find me to be “quick to slander”.
I can definitely say you are a liar (because you relentlessly push revisionist theories about Islam and other Abrahamic whilst ignoring their rebuttals), and a slanderer (buy projecting the slur of terrorism on me, and wilfully misquoting the Qur’an). You have no hope of ever liking Islam or past iterations of monotheistic faiths. Your core aim here to spread lies about these faiths. It seems you have even become enamoured to Sufism? Kindly do not associate with this beloved institution.
If you want to discuss Qur’an 9:5 (009.005 Then, when the sacred months have passed, slay the idolaters wherever ye find them, and take them (captive), and besiege them, and prepare for them each ambush. But if they repent and establish worship and pay the poor-due, then leave their way free. Lo! Allah is Forgiving, Merciful.) then do so on an independent topic and quote the verse in its entirety, as l have just done.
May Allah judge between us, peace be upon you.