If there’s a rule that you’d like to see added, removed or changed, post in this suggestion thread.
1:
If the main thesis of your OP is a statement of fact about some science or math-related topic, there must be some attempt at justification.
eg the post “Evolution is bullshit” would be deleted as an OP.
But the post, “Evolution is bullshit, and here’s why I think that” followed by some attempt at a justification, wouldn’t be deleted.
2:
Pictures must directly pertain to the conversation.
eg a post about chemical bonds with a random picture of Beavis and Butthead is not permitted, but the same post with an illustrative image of how chemical bonds function is.
3:
Insults of any sort are liable to warrant a warning or a short ban, depending on degree.
If someone is wrong, that doesn’t give you leave to call them an ‘idiot’. If someone misunderstood something you said, that doesn’t give you leave to say ‘You have reading comprehension problems’. I’ve said this to people before, and it was a disrespectful and inappropriate response.
4:
If you use the quote feature on the website, you are expected to use it in good faith.
You are expected to either keep the quoted section verbatim, or paraphrase in a way that accurately represents the other person’s viewpoint. If Melody posts, “I don’t think your idea is very good,” and you use the quote feature but make it look as though Melody posted, “I’m an idiot with no sense of dignity,” you may receive a warning for that. Continued offences will result in escalated action.
Math over Physics. Wave over Particles.
1 - Minkowski 4D is a mathematical model describing the behaviour of the Universe at high speeds and in the absence of gravity. What does Minkowski spacetime actually represent in nature? The 4D Minkowski model represents the real structure of the cosmic vacuum, because: a) only in the cosmic vacuum do space and time have the same inseparable structure, b) space without gravity is the structure of the vacuum.
2 – In classical physics, waves consist of particles. In quantum physics, a similar solution was accepted: the coherent states of many particles can be described as the physics of individual single particle. In this sense, classical theory is the limit of quantum theory.
3- Von Neumann formalized quantum physics within the “Hilbert space” (an infinitely large space that houses all possible wave functions). … Hilbert space is a mathematical framework that serves as the collective “home” for all possible wave functions. … “so-called Hilbert empire is more like a castle on a cloud, an illusion”
4 – Schrodinger’s psi-wave function has only one electron in atom. This electron has no orbits in atoms. The electron in an atom can be anywhere. To find an electron’s location in atoms, it needs to use the Born probability density |ψ|² rule.
5 – The Hartree – Fock method. … “The core idea is to approximate a many-particle wave function as a product of single-particle wave functions”, or “The Hartree – Fock method dictates that the many-electron wave function is a product of single-particle. This simplification works remarkably well.” / Book: “Why nobody understands quantum physics”, page 107, by Frank Verstraete & Celine Broeckaert/ … In other words, the quantum particle simplification works remarkably well. The quantum particle does all the wave work.
6 – Planck invented the h-particle from “black body”, which Max von Laue called a “Kirchhoff vacuum”, a small copy of the great vacuum.
7 – Later others said; many coherent wave particles can approximately behave as Planck’s h-particle (which can be like a point, like a ball, like a wave cloud, like a corpuscular). To admit that the origin and behaviour of these two different particles are the same is illogical and stupid.
8-- The behaviour of the many cannot be reduced to the behaviour of the single. The dynamic is different.
9 – Question: why is quantum physics “strange”? Why can nobody understand it?
10 - Conclusion: If in this scenario mathematics dominates physics, and the hero, the quantum particle, plays a secondary role in the theory, the situation becomes strange, confusing, and meaningless.