The parable of the wish-fulfilling tree

Once a man was traveling, accidentally he entered paradise. In the Indian concept of paradise there are wish-fulfilling trees, kalpatarus. You just sit underneath them, desire anything, and immediately it is fulfilled–there is no gap between the desire and its fulfillment. You think, and immediately it becomes a thing; the thought realizes automatically.

These kalpatarus are nothing but symbolic for the mind. Mind is creative, creative with its thoughts.

The man was tired, so he fell asleep under a wish-fulfilling tree. When he woke up he was feeling very hungry, so he said, “I wish I could get some food from somewhere.” And immediately food appeared out of nowhere–just floating in the air, delicious food. He immediately started eating, and when he was feeling very satisfied, another thought arose in him: “If only I could get something to drink…” And there is no prohibition in paradise so immediately, precious wine appeared.

Drinking the wine, relaxed in the cool breeze of paradise under the shade of the tree, he started wondering, “What is happening? Have I fallen into a dream, or are some ghosts around and playing tricks with me?” And ghosts appeared! They were ferocious, horrible, nauseating. He started trembling, and a thought arose in him: “Now I am sure to be killed. These people are going to kill me.” And he was killed.

This parable is an ancient parable, of immense significance. Your mind is the wish-fulfilling tree–whatsoever you think, sooner or later it is fulfilled. Sometimes the gap is such that you have completely forgotten that you had desired it in the first place–sometimes the gap is of years, or sometimes of lives, so you can’t connect the source. But if you watch deeply you will find all your thoughts are creating you and your life. They create your hell, they create your heaven. They create your misery, they create your joy. They create the negative, they create the positive. Everybody is a magician, spinning and weaving a magic world around himself, and then he is caught–the spider itself is caught in its own web.

Once this is understood, things start changing. Then you can play around; then you can change your hell into heaven–it is just a question of painting it from a different vision. Or if you are so much in love with misery you can create as much as you want, to your heart’s content. But then you are never complaining, because you know that it is your creation, it is your painting, you cannot make anybody feel responsible for it.

Then the whole responsibility is yours. Then a new possibility arises: you can drop creating the world, you can stop creating it. There is no need to create heaven and hell, there is no need to create at all. The creator can relax, retire. That retirement of the mind is meditation.

The thinker is creative with his thoughts–this is one of the most fundamental truths to be understood. All that you experience is your creation. First you create it, then you experience it, and then you are caught in the experience–because you don’t know that the source of all exists in you.

  • Osho

Hi A,

So, from this parable, are we to understand that we create God?

JT

Hi JT,

No I don’t think it is saying that we create God but rather that we are God. If we watch our minds, really watch them we will observe how we create our reality – or our illusion for that matter. Whatever we think about that is our experience. If I think the world is filled with ugliness and nasty people then so it is. If I think the world is filled with love and beauty then so it is. The key is that all things, ethereal and physical are created by our minds. This is why there is a school of thought that suggests that our physical health issues are created by the mind. Thought is Creative.

The parable is telling us that thought without awareness is disastrous. This is why the world is in chaos, because we are unaware of our own thoughts and intentions and go around unconsciously creating our lives and then instead of taking responsibility for our own creations we attribute them to others. Once we become aware of our thoughts a) we can change them and b) we can as spiritual beings realise that we don’t need them. That is why spiritual adepts emphasise meditation because it helps them not to create illusions within the mind. But Osho is alluding to the fact that meditation in and of itself is not the final destination that there is a simpler Way, that every moment there is a possibility to be meditative and if we can manage that, we will ‘see’ that we no longer need any of the illusions we have been carrying because we are already. We just are. What is standing in the way of this realisation is the mind itself.

A

But if I myself am my own wish fulfilling tree, and you are yours. My desire is to find love and beauty in the world, and yours is to find ugliness and hate, wouldn’t one somehow outweigh the other? We are not islands.

I understand what you’re saying, but I don’t know that it is always true, however there is no arguing against it because when your speaking about the unconscious then who’s to know what their desires are exactly anyway so in turn everything that happens to a person can be presumed to be caused by these said desires. Additionally when you bring past lives into the picture it gets even more ridiculous. I just don’t believe this because some things are simply out of our control. In some ways though I wish I did believe it.

Hi vortical,

I think what is meant by ‘the thinker is creative with his thoughts’ is something entirely different from having pointed desires. It is referring to something much larger yet so much more precise – it is referring to ALL our thoughts at any given moment. You know vortical, when you are driving and someone cuts you off in traffic, what are your thoughts? When it appears that someone has done me wrong, my lover has left me he must hate me – all just thoughts – yet we believe the thought so vehemently that the thought for us is true - is it truly they who have done me wrong or is it simply that I ‘think’ they have done me wrong? We have habitual thought patterns which determine our experience. Our experiences are not real in the ultimate sense but are all part of the illusion.

There are so many influences at work here. Yours is not an easy question to answer without looking at all the possibilities. We cannot say that reincarnation is nonsense merely because we ‘think’ it is nonsense. If what Osho is saying is correct and it rings true for us then we must investigate the possibility of many lives which would indeed explain a lot in our current circumstances. Simply because we cannot prove it, does not mean that it is not true. I digress, so I’ll stop.

A

Liquidangel: I don’t think reincarnation is nonsense, that’s not what I meant. I meant that you’re looking at infinite possibilities when it comes to our desires and thoughts when you open it up to every life we could have ever had and this delves even further into a realm which we have no proof of.

What are my thoughts? Hmmm- I can tell you they are not necessarily things I wish for. I am tormented by my thoughts, perhaps I should meditate.

Well the historic Buddha did say upon achieving enlightenment, “In all of the heavens and the Earth there is only One.”

Many mystic Traditions point to this occult truth that behind the world of everyday appearances there is no division between you and I. If we consider this perspective then both your desires and my desires come form a hidden source in which there is perfect accord and agreement. Apparent differences are only apparent while our vision is obscured.

ha ha ha… oh I wish- how it would be if only that were true! Then my entire life must be a lie veiled in obscurity created to deliver me farther and farther from sanity.

There are schools of Buddhism that teach that freedom comes only after the souls has experienced all that there is to experience in this dimension of being. Until it is full the soul continues to return to this world. So that every soul will be both hero and villain, savior and betrayer, loved and hated, blissful and agonized. Every experience is an aid to the soul on this journey.

The opposite of love is not hate, it is pain.

(I just thought I’d add to this post by saying that my mood is a little unsteady today and I’ve kind of felt like a tired angry drunk roving around the forum bitching, so I’ll shut up now.)

The book A Course in Miracles, a purportedly channeled divine message puts a lot of emphasis on the dichotomy of Love & Fear. It presents these as cosmic opposites. Another dichotomy has been put forward in a few sources between Love & Indifference. I have never seen the Love & Pain pair before. There was a young woman with a beautiful voice at a poetry reading a few months back who passionately informed us that, “Love IS pain.” She did a moody and bluesy a cappella song that entranced the whole audience. It was mornful and spoke of great suffering. Yet while she sang it had the undeniable ring of truth.

You’re missing the point. It is not neccessary to delve into past lives, that would only serve to further confuse, and while it may be fun to entertain, it is not the past that matters on any spiritual journey. The past cannot be changed, it is done. It’s not the future for that matter either. It is now, the present moment that means everything - how we live our lives in this present moment determines our future anyway, so it is best to pay attention to the matter at hand. If you want to know your past, it is written right here and now. When we become aware of our thoughts we can see our past - it is clear and when we are aware of our thoughts we can also see our future.

But this must not be misunderstood. When a seer sees your future for example, it is not that they picture the details, it is that they pay attention to the present moment every line on your face on your hands, every movement you make, it is all visible in the now and based on this they can ‘predict’ what will happen, again, not something to concern ourselves with.

Understanding the laws of cause and effect and how they manifest in our lives is useful but is important not to get hung up on the past. It’s over. If we simply understand our hearts, which we get to by observing our mind, in this moment, we can understand everything, because everything exists right here and right now within our own heart.

Yes, I believe my point has been made.

While I don’t wish to contradict Buddhism and while I agree that our every experience is there so that we can see our own hearts, my feeling on freedom is somewhat different. Freedom is emptiness - void - when we are free from this world of duality, free from our desire to be good or rich or loved as all these things only serve for us to be slaves to our own minds…our thoughts…this must be understood if we are ever to become truly free. I don’t drink alcohol for instance and a friend asked whether I don’t just wish to be free and let my hair down once in a while and have a drink - be on the same buzz as everyone else. He doesn’t understand that for me, I am already free, free from the desire to ‘lose’ myself in liquour. My experience is heightened because I am aware. That is more important. Freedom is awareness. That’s not to say I’m concerned about what other people put into their body. That is none of my concern.

There are many recommended paths to Moksha - Liberation, even in the field of Buddhism. Not every Buddhist would direct others to go that way. It is more common in Buddhism to find a prohibition from ingesting intoxicants, for instance. It looks like you are pursuing a path that is closer to Hinduism.

I’m reminded of a comment by Suzuki who observed that zazen is nothing special, that it is not practiced sitting upon a pillow, but in the most ordinary mundane activities of the day. Awareness is holding to the way, not in our thoughts of the past or future, but in the now. Awareness is spontaneously acting out of heart and mind together as one. True awareness is not being aware of our awareness. True awareness is seeing directly, acting directly. Easier said than done.

JT

I’m not religious xander, I try to walk the path of the heart. That is all. But like tentative says, easier said than done.

There is something seriously wrong in this parable. When that person desires, he gets whatever he desires, but when he says, “Now I am sure to be killed. These people are going to kill me” that is a fear and not a desire. So his desire to escape from that never got fulfilled. Remember it was the wish-fulfilling tree and not that whatever you think or fear will come true. Like where is the parable logical? Isn’t it like sooooooooo illogical?

The lesson is written between the lines. It has nothing to do with desires or wishes but rather to do with awakening to the fact that our thoughts are creative regardless of whether they are ‘good’ or ‘bad’. This principle is outside the realm of duality - the point of the parable is to become aware of what we are thinking in order to realise our inherent creative spiritual self.

An apple tree also makes leaves.

A Wish tree also grants fears.

No problem.

I know, but then, why call the tree, the wish-fulfilling tree? Why not call it The Mirror? Hehehe! :smiley:

That is SO true.

I feel like I can’t complete my religious quest because it’s in direct conflict with my quest to be a good consumer :slight_smile:

In all seriousness, Why should a spiritual journey be any easier than any other aspect of life? Life is hard and filled with toil.