…and why does it have the effect on humans that it does?
i asked this question to a bunch of my musician friends a number of years ago, and they just kind of stared at me or gave uninteresting answers. i’m wondering if anyone around here has any opinions on the subject. here are some questions that have popped up in my mind:
what is it about the rythmic, repeating or cyclical nature of music that we find pleasing?
Well, humans adore music so much because we adore repetition… kind of like enjoying your comfort zone. There are algorithms and sequences in music that we grow to expect and enjoy because they hit at exactly the right moment we know them to. It’s largely a mathematical thing.
what is it about the rythmic, repeating or cyclical nature of music that we find pleasing?
…nature itself repeats sounds. It has a regularity. The sound of animals, rain, thunder, etc. The vast cycles and seasons of nature can also convey the essence of sound. Myth and music are merely the ‘transcriptions’ of these. We have been exposed to this for much longer than to our own creations. Music is the mathematical and emotional representation of a kind of onomatopoeia. In short, its part of our DNA.
why don’t most animals respond to music?
…what gave you this idea? If plants, as proven respond to music why shouldn’t animals. They do just not on the same level. It’s extremely likely that they enjoy some Mozart much more than you as long as it’s not the Hell scene from Don Giovanni. If a tree can read 85% of your DNA why shouldn’t animals have some sort of reciprocal relationship with music?
what is it that we find pleasurable about music?
…harmony as we understand it whether it be in embedded in sound, a mineral or a landscape, etc. Again, it is a reflection of the world - as we are! Of course, there is much more that can be said on the subject! For example, the “fractal” aspect of music and nature. Often in myth and sometimes it seems even in Quantum Theory itself music is the blueprint of everything that exists!
That’s a fascinating subject which I also don’t understand. I would really love to read an article about it, but I couldn’t find one.
I generally agree with monad tho. It’s probably the winds, the rain, etc…
However it seems weird that we should like these sounds. After all neither wind nor rain helped our prehistorical ancestors in survival. If anything we should hate these sounds.
Animals do like music. Usually farmers let cows listen to classical music when they milk them. It improves the results.
Yet the music our civilization invented is an abomination of nature. It uses the same mechanism that enjoys the voices of birds and rain, and mutilates it with artificial loud constantly changing sounds.
It seems like the more complex the sounds system is, the more we compelled to hear it. I have no idea whatsoever why complex and shifting dynamics helped our survival 20,000 years ago. Maybe the noise of many insects and birds attracted us then as potential prey.
I think what is so wonderful about music is that its a powerful medium that everyone can connect with. It brings out our emotions and feelings sometimes without us even realising it. It has the ability to reach our hearts and souls, it is story telling with ryhthmn. For me music is therapeutic, often I hear a song and it will bring back a memory from my past, I can listen to music that everyone else can too, but I can still make it my own because of how I interpret it. To this day I only have to hear a particular piece of music and I can be in tears from happiness or sadness.
As the tempo in music changes from either fast to slow, so do our emotions…one minute we can be all excited from it & the next minute calm.
A lot of people have difficulty in talking their feelings out to another person, so when they find a song they can identify with, that focus on issues that are affecting them at that moment it can be an empowering experience. It can be a great motivator, it can make us feel good about ourselves.
Most babies are sung lullabies from birth, not only because its soothing for the child but its also repetitious & through repetition we learn.
And as far as animals relating to music…from my personal experience, many years ago I worked with race horses, we played music to them constantly or had the radio on… we actually found the horses were calmer & more relaxed on race days, and weren’t as frightened by the noise & excitement of the track. They were pre-conditioned to noise & sound through music.
Music is the only language everybody can understand. You can speak your native tongue and people cannot understand you. But play music and everybody understand.
What’s that supposed to mean? If I want to convey a message I should do this with music? How? Maybe Bethoven’s 7th symphony really means: “Look, there is a rabbit!” ???
And in prehistorical times there was only one language, the language of the clan. As a member of the clan you would never meet members of other clans.
First proposition Patterns
The brain is a forager of patterns.
It is an ordering biological tool.
The mind is its projection in time/space.
As such it is attracted to patterns and order.
The brain can only comprehend what it can store and analyze.
Storage requires ordering (Cataloguing, Categorizing).
Ordering the confusing or chaotic or complicated demands simplification/generalization.
We create approximations to efficiently act. We understand by finding a pattern and extrapolating the entirety.
Second proposition Resistance
The path of least resistance implies that repetition lessens resistances creating habituation and experience.
We are drawn to the familiar because a neural pathway, once established, is more easily reused, rather than replaced.
Continuous use makes something familiar and easy.
This attraction to the familiar creates behavioral patterns resulting in thinking, species or culture.
Third Proposition Energy
Energy is a resonating activity.
It is action/movement manifesting or universal flux.
Matter is resonating energy at a specific tone, making it more or less substantial in relation to our sensual acuity.
Fourth Proposition Music
Music is a sound exhibiting patterns and repetition.
Otherwise it is called noise.
It is energy made audible.
Conclusion
The familiarity of the pattern makes it attractive.
It awakens remembrance by stimulating neural pathways which might have become forgotten or by harmonizing with our own energies it can imitate our becoming.
This is why music can be emotional and exhibit psychosomatic effects.
We are energy and so the vibrations are intimate to our becoming.
Listen to the music, there’s happy music, melancholy music, music that makes you laugh, cry, shout, dance, there’s music for funerals, parties, weddings, military, religious, national anthem, etc, name it, there’s a kind of music that everybody understands. Ceremonial drums, intonations, incantations, hand clapping, these are musical sound to another one’s ears. We don’t have to have a common tongue to understand music. We know music when we hear it. It is a universal language.
I’ve always felt that, but never actually concieved it intellectually…
what makes you think that music seems to be the blueprint of everything that exists?.
also, what is the ‘fractal’ aspect of music and nature? I don’t know any science…
I think our music is based on the rythmic recurrence of increasingly dramatic harmonies. The key word being dramatic - different musical keys correspnd to different emotions. We westerners have the Pythagorean system which is based on the golden mean, which is the balance of equal growth, the methematical key to the buildup of substance without losing balance. (A rams horn)
In primitive cultures, music simply had the aim of exiting people and purging them through sweat. This is still mostly the use of music among the populace - easy harmonies to ease the mind and a steady beat to get the blood going.
On the other hand there is Bach. I believe what makes him and all lesser composers great is the cosmic spectacle unfolded in the comprehension of paradimensional consequence expressed in sound, which is, of course what we mad men in our cavities of reverberation consider to be the cosmic substance.
It’s interaction with and correspondence to all we feel when we feel we ‘ourselves’, which is the direct awareness of our DNA.
Most animals depend too much on their hearing to allow a luxury such as music to keep their attention away fron the bare necessities, which will keep them alive.
The same reason people usually abstain from strong hallicunogens during work hours.
Music = pleasurable to us
pleasurable to us = music
has any of u heard of musicology? it studies what this thread talks about…
I don’t understabnd something though… how come some accords correspond to emotions? I mean… can u give examples? cause I feel more like a SONG porttrays an emotion but that song is made up of many different notes…
also, I don’t think i’ve ever felt any emotion by hearing a random note…
i just feel emotions by songs.
and also, what does the golden mean have to do=? please do explain, I’m a dummy when it comes to anything mathlike.
that article is really interesting. however, as an lifelong musician i have to think that people who say musicians make music to attract the opposite sex have a bit of a skewed perspective. yes, it’s a nice side effect and many people do make music to get attention, but largely i don’t see that as the driving purpose. most of the musicians i know will do to bed happy after a night of playing. if anything, it’s a substitute for sex.
the talk of pattern recognition really speaks to me. this is something that i’ve thought a lot about. obviously the predictability of the patterns plays a lot into music appreciation. some people like very stock, common patterns. other people don’t enjoy anthing but the most obscure, most unrepeating compositions.
i was reading an essay called “if man is to be man” by perry pascarella the other day. in it he says that scientific exploration is a natural continuation of our evolution. we gained a large brain size, became self aware, and now we explore the universe. i wonder if music tickles our pattern recognizing curiosity in a much more ‘realtime’ sort of way.