sagesound, for some reason, I would vote for the above banner you designed to replace the old one. Except maybe I would suggest a differet enscription instead of āILPā.
Let me start off explaining fully then derive my suggested enscription later on.
I see there is no issue over ethos raised in coming up with new banners. Maybe if ethos should be abolished on the profound level, it should be emphasised on the superfacial level. People feel nervous and weary without ethos, so let us flag up something that will make this harmless nevertheless effective compliment. Sometimes we have to tolerate a certain vice in order for a certain virtue to work out. āA little vanity is good.ā Insofar as morality stays superfacial, it must be propagandised superfacially. Otherwise we have nihilism and general existential chaos for the philosophers, pathological multations for the plummers, et cetera.
Now, let us ask, What is the Ethos of our ILP discussion forums?
BBC decided to label the impression that the title ILP gives out as trashy. This is where we are at a difficult cross road: should we make the banner trashy in accordance with the title in order to declare an anti academic ethos, a free intellectual environment, an everyman symposium? Alternatively, should we make the banner so posh so that Mrs Beckham will feel compelled to join us when she is bored looking after Romeo at Beckingham palace? A posh banner is not altogether in full concordance with a trashy title, but is the banner is really posh, the title will be posh too, polished posh. Perhaps we could use an enscription like this
Philosophy I love, therefore philosopher I am.
Vola. With this explainatory subtitle artistically incorporated on the banner, among the philosophical heads, we reach an ethos that lies beyond trash and even posh. We achieve encompassion. There is something personable about us, yet something reverent, something easy going about us, yet something composed. It is clever yet with grace, passionate yet wise.
Whatever man, just make sure that handsome Nietzsche head is not swapped place with that deplorable torso sqeezed against the right side.