I am less surprised at the outcome of the election in the US than I was in 2016, but I am still baffled by what Trump’s supporters are thinking. And I’m tempted to think that they basically aren’t thinking, as to the extent I’ve heard support for Trump it’s been based on misunderstandings and mistaken beliefs – about what the candidates stood for, what they planned to do, the state of the world and how it works, etc. But the principle of charity compels me to acknowledge that it might be I who is confused abut the world.
So in the interest of to test the accuracy of my beliefs, I’m going to share some predictions about the next four years, things that I think will follow from this outcome. Concrete, testable predictions will make my present beliefs plain, and will commit me to them for future review.
I’ll also provide probabilities, because there’s a lot of uncertainty about how the future will unfold, and a lot that I can’t know yet that could change the circumstances. That means I expect that some of these predictions will not come true, but the goal will be for e.g. 75% of predictions I’m 75% confident about will come true. It also means I can be wrong even when I correctly predict something, e.g. 100% of things occur that I predicted as being 55% likely, it means I was mistakenly under-confident.
I’d appreciate others sharing theirs as well, particularly the predictions of Trump voters/supporters. It would help me understand your beliefs and motivations, and provide an interesting comparison in four years. I think you’re wrong, you think I’m wrong, let’s make make concrete predictions and see who’s got the better grasp on things.
-
Trump won’t be president for his full term. I think the reports of his health issues are real, in particular his mental health appears to be in rapid decline. There’s a relatively high chance that he dies from his health problems before the end of his term, and even higher that he will be effectively incapacitated by then. I can’t imagine that he would actually resign, nor that his staff would use the 25th Amendment readily; more likely he will simply not be acting as president, and his health problems will be quietly covered up while his staff perform the duties of the office. To make this prediction concrete and testable: I don’t think Trump will deliver the State of the Union in 2028 (85%).
-
Aid to Ukraine will decrease. Call it being in Russia’s pocket or simply being non-interventionist, it’s pretty clear that Trump is less committed to resisting them than Biden. For fiscal years 2022-24, the US provided $54B, $60B, and $61B in aid to Ukraine [1]. No year of Trump’s term will see so large a commitment in inflation adjusted terms (75%).
-
Aid to Israel will be relatively stable. For all the flak Biden got, I expect Trump to be worse for the Arab world than Biden. Biden saw Israel as a strategic ally in the region and gave them support and leeway, but he pressured Netanyahu to seek a cease fire and provide humanitarian support in Gaza. Trump doesn’t care about Gaza or humanity, he hates Arabs and likes power, and he’s surrounded by sincere believers in a millenarian apocalyptic cult who see Israel’s dominance as necessary for the second coming. The US has provided $12.5B to Israel in fiscal year 2024 [2]. We will provide more in FY2025 (70%).
More to come…